The LUMA Hotel – Times Square leads the pack with a 9.1 rating and a location score of 9.8, putting you steps from the neon lights of Broadway. For a quieter, boutique split, the Hotel Scherman (9.2 rating) pairs a Hell’s Kitchen address with a 9.8 location score and a daily continental breakfast. Both offer prime sightseeing bases.
Finding a place to stay in New York is about picking your neighborhood vibe — fast-paced Midtown, historic Downtown, or the creative Lower East Side. Here are 20 of the best tourist areas to stay in New York, broken down by rating and real guest feedback.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed over 24,000 verified Booking.com reviews across these 20 properties to identify the top-rated hotels in New York’s most popular tourist districts.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Best for Times Square access: #3 LUMA Hotel – Times Square→ Rates
#4 Hotel Scherman→ Rates - Highest guest rating (Midtown): #16 Bryant Park Hotel→ Rates
#11 Casablanca Hotel→ Rates - Best for Downtown / Financial District: #8 Artezen Hotel→ Rates
- Best for Lower East Side nightlife: #13 The Ludlow Hotel→ Rates
- Best for Little Italy charm: #14 NobleDEN Hotel→ Rates
- Best for luxury with a kitchen: #18 Conrad New York Downtown→ Rates
#20 The Langham, Fifth Avenue→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
🗺️ Compare Live Prices on the Map
Tap any pin to see live rates from Booking, Expedia, Vrbo & more.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Club Quarters Hotel Grand Central | (4700+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. San Carlos Hotel New York | (4300+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. LUMA Hotel – Times Square | (3250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Hotel Scherman | (2350+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Hotel Indigo NYC Financial District | (2000+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Hilton Club The Quin New York | (1500+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. Broadway Plaza Hotel | (1400+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 8. Artezen Hotel | (1400+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 9. Mint House 70 Pine by Kasa | (1250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 10. Hilton Club The Central at 5th New York | (1250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 11. Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection | (1200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 12. MADE Hotel | (950+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 13. The Ludlow Hotel | (950+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 14. NobleDEN Hotel | (950+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 15. Pestana Park Avenue | (850+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 16. Bryant Park Hotel | (800+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 17. Hotel Giraffe by Library Hotel Collection | (750+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 18. Conrad New York Downtown | (650+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 19. The Wall Street Hotel New York City | (550+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 20. The Langham, New York, Fifth Avenue | (450+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
New York Hotel Reviews: The Full Breakdown Across 20 Properties
1. Club Quarters Hotel Grand Central, New York
The Vibe
Right in Midtown East with a 9.5 location score, this is a practical base camp for Times Square visitors who want a quieter neighborhood at night. With over 4,700 reviews, the reliability is proven — you get a fitness center, an on-site restaurant, and Nespresso coffee in every room.
What You Actually Get
Each room includes a large TV and an iHome clock-radio, but the real win is the Nespresso maker with complimentary coffee and tea. Some rooms add a fully equipped kitchenette and sofa bed. Pets are welcome (dogs only, per policy). The private parking is a rare Midtown bonus — available at an additional cost. The 24-hour front desk handles late check-ins without fuss.
Choose this if: you value a strong location score of 9.5 and want a dependable, well-reviewed stay near Grand Central.
Check Tonight’s Price for Club Quarters Hotel Grand Central, New York →
2. San Carlos Hotel New York
The Vibe
Scoring a superb 9.7 location, the San Carlos is a 5-minute walk from St. Patrick’s Cathedral and steps from Saks Fifth Avenue. Guests love the comfy beds here — the hotel was rated highly for sleep quality. It’s a polished East Side pick with an on-site restaurant and 24-hour fitness center.
What You Actually Get
The rooms feature a 42-inch LED flat-screen TV and a docking station. The neighborhood delivers: you can walk to Bloomingdale’s, the United Nations Plaza, and multiple sightseeing spots. Discounted parking is available at a nearby garage. Heads up — there’s a $5 charge per package if more than five arrive before your date. The 4,300+ reviews confirm the consistency.
Choose this if: you want a highly rated location (9.7) with a proven record from over 4,000 reviews.
3. LUMA Hotel – Times Square
The Vibe
With a 9.8 location score — the highest on this list alongside a few others — LUMA is 300 meters from Times Square. The hotel serves a continental breakfast and gets high marks for its very comfy beds. It’s a modern, tech-forward property with an on-site bar.
What You Actually Get
Every room is air-conditioned with a 50-inch flat-screen TV and cable channels. The electronic control sheer and blackout shades are a thoughtful touch for midday naps after sightseeing. King rooms include a sofa area for relaxing. Breakfast included rates are available. A hold for room and tax plus estimated incidentals is placed on your card at check-in.
Choose this if: you want to be in the thick of Times Square and value a 9.8 location score and high review volume.
4. Hotel Scherman
The Vibe
A boutique guest house in Hell’s Kitchen with a 9.8 location score, Hotel Scherman is a 5-minute walk to Times Square and within 600 meters of major theaters. The pillow-top mattresses get consistent praise. Breakfast is served daily — either continental or buffet.
What You Actually Get
Each room has a pillow-top mattress and daily housekeeping services. The concierge team can help with theater tickets. The credit card used for booking must match the card presented at check-in — an important policy note. The property sits on West 46th Street, a quieter side street that still puts you deep in the Theater District action.
Choose this if: you want the best location score possible (9.8) with a boutique, guest-house feel and included breakfast.
5. Hotel Indigo NYC Financial District by IHG
The Vibe
Down on Trinity Place in the Financial District, this property holds a 9.5 location score. It’s a sleek choice with air-conditioned rooms, parquet floors, and a modern restaurant serving Dutch and American cuisines. The bar provides a relaxing atmosphere after work or sightseeing.
What You Actually Get
Each room has a work desk, TV, and free WiFi. The walk-in showers and private bathrooms feel more upscale than the price suggests. A damage deposit is required upon check-in. Pets are welcome. Parking is available. The 16:00 check-in is standard for the neighborhood — plan your arrival accordingly.
Choose this if: you’re doing business in the Financial District or want a quieter, highly rated stay with a 9.5 location score.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hotel Indigo NYC Financial District by IHG →
6. Hilton Club The Quin New York
The Vibe
Perched on 57th Street at Sixth Avenue, The Quin offers a 9.7 location score with Central Park within walking distance and MOMA just 4 blocks away. The beds are frequently rated as very comfy. Broadway and Rockefeller Center are easily accessible from this Midtown perch.
What You Actually Get
The hotel is completely non-smoking. You’re 50 meters from the West 57th Street subway station. Rooms include air conditioning, private bathrooms, and tea/coffee makers. The Hilton Club tier means group policies apply when booking more than 7 rooms. Guest credit cards may be subject to pre-authorization before arrival.
Choose this if: you want a Hilton Club experience with a prime Midtown location (9.7) near Central Park.
7. Broadway Plaza Hotel
The Vibe
Located in NoMad with a 9.7 location score, this hotel is 400 meters from the Flatiron Building and close to Madison Square Park. The property is decorated with modern art reproductions and features very comfy beds. It’s a stylish, high-rated option in one of New York’s best-rated areas.
What You Actually Get
Each room includes a flat-screen TV with pay-per-view channels, a private bathroom, and a hairdryer. The 24-hour front desk is convenient for late arrivals. The resort fee and pre-authorization policy apply — the first night’s room charges and taxes will be authorized on your credit card at the time of reservation.
Choose this if: you want a stylish NoMad stay with a superb 9.7 location and great bed reviews.
8. Artezen Hotel
The Vibe
With a 9.3 overall rating — one of the highest on this list — and a 9.6 location score, the Artezen is a Downtown standout. It’s 1.2 km from the 9/11 Memorial and 1.6 km from Brooklyn Bridge. The hotel includes a fitness center and yoga access. The facility fee covers high-speed WiFi and two Fiji water bottles daily.
What You Actually Get
Every unit has a flat-screen TV. The facility fee also includes free local and toll-free calls, a welcome snack at arrival, and gym access. Check-in runs until midnight, which is helpful for late flights to JFK or Newark. The Wall Street-Financial District location puts you near Bloomingdale’s and major transit hubs.
Choose this if: you want a top-rated hotel (9.3) in the Financial District with a fantastic location score of 9.6.
9. Mint House 70 Pine by Kasa
The Vibe
Housed in a historic landmark building at 70 Pine Street, Mint House offers apartment-style stays with a 9.4 location score. It’s 700 meters from Battery Park. Every unit has a fully equipped kitchen and flat-screen cable TV. The beds are rated as very comfy. Pets are welcome.
What You Actually Get
Each apartment comes with a private bathroom with toiletries. The 24-hour front desk and fitness center add convenience. The historic building adds character you won’t find in chain hotels. Cash is not accepted — bring your card. The credit card used for pre-paid reservations must match the one presented at check-in.
Choose this if: you want the flexibility of a full kitchen and a unique historic landmark stay.
10. Hilton Club The Central at 5th New York
The Vibe
On East 48th Street in Midtown East, this Hilton Club property boasts a 9.8 location score. St. Patrick’s Cathedral is a 4-minute walk away, Rockefeller Center is 300 meters, and Times Square is less than 1 km. The rooms feature air conditioning, private bathrooms with bathrobes, and tea/coffee makers.
What You Actually Get
Each room includes a bidet and hairdryer — thoughtful touches. A damage deposit is required upon check-in. The 10:00 check-out is earlier than average, so plan your last morning accordingly. The location on 5th Avenue makes it ideal for luxury shopping runs to Saks and Bergdorf Goodman.
Choose this if: you want a flawless location (9.8) on Fifth Avenue with upscale Hilton Club service.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hilton Club The Central at 5th New York →
11. Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection
The Vibe
In the Theater District with a 9.8 location score, the Casablanca is steps from Times Square. Guests rave about the food and the comfy beds. A daily continental breakfast is included, plus 24-hour access to refreshments. It’s a boutique property with a strong repeat-guest base.
What You Actually Get
Each room includes a flat-screen cable TV, DVD player, and iPod docking station. Bathrobes and slippers are supplied in the en suite bathroom. The 24-hour refreshment access is a money-saver in a neighborhood where a bottle of water can cost $5. Check-in runs until midnight, accommodating late theater-goers.
Choose this if: you’re a theater lover who wants a 9.8-location boutique hotel with included meals and snacks.
Check Tonight’s Price for Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection →
12. MADE Hotel
The Vibe
In NoMad with a 9.4 location score, MADE Hotel is 600 meters from the Empire State Building. The 4-star property features a terrace, bar, and free WiFi. Select rooms have floor-to-ceiling windows with city views. Beds are rated very comfy. Private parking is available.
What You Actually Get
Each room includes air conditioning, bathrobes, a Revo SuperConnect multi-format radio, and a Samsung flat-screen TV. The resort fee covers a complimentary cup of coffee or tea. Reservations exceeding 21 days are subject to different policies. Pets are welcome. The 24-hour front desk handles late arrivals.
Choose this if: you want a trendy NoMad hotel with standout design features and a 9.4 location score.
13. The Ludlow Hotel
The Vibe
On the Lower East Side with a 9.4 location score, The Ludlow offers spectacular views of NYC skyscrapers and bridges. Each room features hardwood floors, handmade silk rugs, and artisan-crafted Moroccan lamps. Beds are rated very comfy. Pets are welcome. Free WiFi is included.
What You Actually Get
Each room has a minibar featuring local products. The en suite bathrooms are well-appointed. A $75 per night deposit for incidentals is charged upon check-in — any unused funds are released up to 30 days after check-out, so keep your receipt. The Ludlow Loft is the only unit with certain amenities. Parking is available.
Choose this if: you want a wildly stylish, design-forward hotel in the Lower East Side with a 9.4 location score.
14. NobleDEN Hotel
The Vibe
On Grand Street in Little Italy with a 9.5 location score, NobleDEN is literally 12 meters from Ferrara Bakery and Cafe — the legendary Italian pastry shop. Rooms have hardwood floors, flat-screen cable TVs, and walk-in showers. Free WiFi and a restaurant are on site. Beds are rated very comfy.
What You Actually Get
Some rooms have a terrace or balcony — rare for NYC. All rooms include a hairdryer, in-room safe, and air conditioning. Heads up: there may be some noise or light disturbances from October 9-20, 2026 due to nearby work. The Little Italy location puts you steps from Soho and Chinatown.
Choose this if: you want to be in the heart of Little Italy with a 9.5 location and easy access to Soho and Chinatown.
15. Pestana Park Avenue
The Vibe
In Murray Hill with a 9.7 location score, Pestana Park Avenue is a 4-minute walk from Grand Central Station, 600 meters from Bryant Park, and a 9-minute stroll to the Empire State Building. The facility fee includes complimentary high-speed WiFi, free local calls, and access to the Pestana CR7 fitness center.
What You Actually Get
Rooms feature air conditioning, private bathrooms with walk-in showers, and modern amenities. The facility fee also covers 10 printed pages per day — useful for business travelers. Pets are welcome. Group policies apply when booking 5 or more rooms. The 00:00 check-in deadline is generous.
Choose this if: you want a central Murray Hill position with a 9.7 location and access to major Midtown landmarks.
16. Bryant Park Hotel
The Vibe
With a 9.9 location score — the highest on this entire list — the Bryant Park Hotel sits directly across from historic Bryant Park. It’s one of the few properties with private parking and has a high rate of repeat guests. The rooms are bright, airy, and newly refreshed, blending history with modern luxury.
What You Actually Get
The hotel is consistently ranked among the top in NYC. A $200 per day authorization on a valid credit card is required for incidentals. Guests under 21 can only check in with a parent or official guardian. The 23:30 check-in deadline is slightly earlier than others. The Midtown location puts you near the New York Public Library and Times Square.
Choose this if: you want the best location score on this list (9.9) with private parking and a high repeat-guest rate.
17. Hotel Giraffe by Library Hotel Collection
The Vibe
On Park Avenue South at 26th Street in NoMad, Hotel Giraffe boasts a 9.5 location score. The rooftop garden is a serene escape. The hotel is a 10-minute walk from Union Square Park and Chelsea. Food is highly recommended by guests, and the beds are rated very comfy. Private parking is available.
What You Actually Get
The decor features photography from the 1920s and 1930s. Each room includes an iPod docking station and a flat-screen cable TV. The daily complimentary offerings — including refreshments — add value. Check-out is at 13:00, which is later than most NYC hotels, giving you a relaxed last morning.
Choose this if: you want a boutique NoMad stay with a rooftop garden, late check-out, and a 9.5 location score.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hotel Giraffe by Library Hotel Collection →
18. Conrad New York Downtown
The Vibe
In Battery Park with a 9.4 location score, the Conrad is an all-suite property with world-class service. It houses 2,000 pieces of artwork and is 500 meters from the World Trade Centre. Breakfast options are extensive — continental, full English/Irish, vegetarian, vegan, gluten-free, and American. Beds are rated very comfy.
What You Actually Get
Each suite has a separate living room, two flat-screen TVs, and an espresso machine. Some units offer Hudson River views. The Atrio Restaurant serves Mediterranean cuisine. Pets under 75 pounds are welcome. Parking fees cover one entry and one exit per 24 hours. Complimentary in-room WiFi is available.
Choose this if: you want an all-suite luxury experience with Hudson River views and extensive breakfast options.
19. The Wall Street Hotel New York City
The Vibe
On Wall Street with a 9.3 location score, this hotel offers elegant, soundproof rooms. Breakfast is available in continental, vegetarian, and American options. The property includes a fitness center and terrace. Pets are welcome. It’s a quieter, more refined alternative to Midtown’s bustle.
What You Actually Get
Each room features air conditioning, a private bathroom, free WiFi, a flat-screen TV, and soundproofing — ideal for light sleepers. The hotel has a terrace for relaxing. The Financial District location is within walking distance of the 9/11 Memorial, Brooklyn Bridge, and Battery Park.
Choose this if: you want a soundproof, elegant stay in the Financial District with a 9.3 location score.
Check Tonight’s Price for The Wall Street Hotel New York City →
20. The Langham, New York, Fifth Avenue
The Vibe
On Fifth Avenue between Bryant Park and the Empire State Building, the Langham holds a 9.5 location score and has a strong base of repeat guests. The rooms include an espresso maker and bottled water during turn-down. It’s a luxury stay with private parking and continental breakfast available.
What You Actually Get
All rooms have WiFi access. Concierge services and a 24-hour front desk are provided. Guests must be at least 21 years or older to check in. The same credit card used for the reservation is required at check-in. Pets are welcome. The Fifth Avenue address puts you in prime Midtown shopping and sightseeing territory.
Choose this if: you want a luxury Fifth Avenue stay with private parking and a high repeat-guest rate.
Check Tonight’s Price for The Langham, New York, Fifth Avenue →
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#8 Artezen Hotel
With a 9.3 overall rating, a 9.6 location score, and generous facility fee perks including Fiji water and yoga access, it’s the highest-rated Downtown property.
💰 Best Value
#4 Hotel Scherman
A 9.2 rating, 9.8 location score, and included breakfast deliver maximum quality for the price in Hell’s Kitchen.
🗽 Best for Times Square Access
#3 LUMA Hotel – Times Square
A 9.8 location score, 9.1 rating, and 300-meter proximity to Times Square make it the best choice for first-time visitors.
How We Ranked These New York Hotels
We evaluated over 20 properties in New York’s most popular tourist districts, analyzing over 24,000 verified guest reviews to find the top-rated hotels across all key categories.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 8.0+ overall and 10+ verified reviews
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized location, cleanliness, and comfort — the categories that drive repeat bookings in NYC
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns
- Location signals: Proximity to major landmarks like Times Square, Central Park, and the Financial District
Frequently Asked Questions
Are pets allowed at these New York hotels?
Yes, several hotels in this list welcome pets. Club Quarters Grand Central accepts dogs only. Hotel Indigo NYC Financial District, The Ludlow, NobleDEN, Mint House 70 Pine, Pestana Park Avenue, Conrad New York Downtown, The Wall Street Hotel, and The Langham all allow pets. The Conrad has a 75-pound weight limit — check each property’s policy for fees and restrictions before booking.
Which hotels offer free cancellation?
Most properties offer free cancellation within a specific window, but policies vary by season and rate type. Hotels like the San Carlos, LUMA Times Square, and Hotel Scherman generally offer flexible cancellation when booked directly through Booking.com. Always review the cancellation policy before confirming — some non-refundable rates offer savings at the cost of flexibility.
Can I check in late at any of these properties?
Yes, most hotels have 24-hour front desks. Club Quarters Grand Central, Hotel Scherman, and The Langham allow check-in from 15:00. Artezen Hotel and Casablanca Hotel accept check-in until midnight. Pestana Park Avenue allows check-in until 00:00. The Bryant Park Hotel has a 23:30 deadline for check-in. Always notify the property if you expect to arrive after midnight.
What’s the most walkable area in New York for tourists?
Midtown Manhattan — specifically the area around Times Square, Bryant Park, and Fifth Avenue — is the most walkable for first-time tourists. Hotels like the LUMA (9.8 location), Bryant Park Hotel (9.9 location), and Casablanca Hotel (9.8 location) put you within walking distance of Broadway theaters, Rockefeller Center, and Central Park. The Financial District is also highly walkable for Downtown attractions.
How do I get from JFK Airport to these hotels?
The AirTrain to Jamaica Station connects to the E subway line for Midtown hotels. For Downtown properties, take the AirTrain to Howard Beach and connect to the A train. Ride-hailing services cost $50-70 for Midtown and$70-90 for Downtown. Many hotels also offer private car services — check with the concierge. The LIRR from Jamaica to Penn Station is another efficient option for Midtown properties.
Which hotel has the best location score?
The Bryant Park Hotel leads with a 9.9 location score, directly across from Bryant Park. It’s followed closely by the LUMA Hotel – Times Square, Hotel Scherman, Casablanca Hotel, and Hilton Club The Central at 5th New York — all tied at 9.8. For Downtown, the Artezen Hotel holds a 9.6 score, while the Conrad New York Downtown scores 9.4 in Battery Park.