Sette Querce leads with a 9.6 staff score and a stunning 9.5 location in San Casciano Dei Bagni. For apartment-style independence, Tuscasì Aparthotel’s 9.2 rating and full kitchens make it a savvy pick. Both prove small-scale Tuscany stays punch well above their weight.
Forget the sprawling resorts. The real Tuscany is in small hotels run by people who care about your stay — here are 20 that prove it, vetted from over 22,400 guest reviews.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 20 properties across Tuscany, filtering over 22,400+ verified guest reviews to find only those with an average rating of 8.7/10 or higher, prioritizing properties with a clear sense of place and genuine guest-first operations.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Best small luxury in Chianti: #6 Certosa di Pontignano→ Rates
#10 Palazzo Leopoldo→ Rates - Best for apartment living: #13 Tuscasì Aparthotel→ Rates
#7 ApartHotel Anghel→ Rates - Best value near Siena: #3 Best Western San Marco→ Rates
#7 ApartHotel Anghel→ Rates - Best for wine lovers: #11 Ultimo Mulino→ Rates
#8 Villa San Giorgio→ Rates - Most scenic hilltop: #18 Sette Querce→ Rates
#14 Albergo Di Murlo→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Precise House Montaperti Siena | (2850+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. Hotel Executive | (2600+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Best Western Hotel San Marco | (1800+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Hotel More di Cuna | (1700+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Four Points by Sheraton Siena | (1400+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Certosa di Pontignano Residenza d’Epoca | (1400+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. ApartHotel Anghel | (1250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 8. Hotel Villa San Giorgio | (1150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 9. Mercure Petriolo Siena Terme Spa Hotel | (1100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 10. Palazzo Leopoldo Dimora Storica & Spa | (1000+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 11. Ultimo Mulino Country Hotel | (850+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 12. Quattro Gigli Hotel | (800+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 13. Tuscasì Aparthotel | (650+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 14. Albergo Di Murlo | (650+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 15. Residence Poggio Golf Chianti Firenze | (650+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 16. Borgo San Martino – Residence Hotel & SPA | (450+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 17. Relais San Lorenzo | (450+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 18. Sette Querce | (450+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 19. Antico Casale Di Scansano Resort | (400+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 20. Hotel Tenuta di Artimino Meliá Collection | (300+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Detailed Reviews: 20 Best Small Hotels in Tuscany Reviewed
1. Precise House Montaperti Siena
The Vibe
Set among the rolling hills just outside Siena, this place banks on views and a proper wellness setup. Guests consistently praise the breakfast spread and the happy hour with great bartenders. At 8.2 overall, it’s a solid base for exploring — bus line 5 runs directly to Piazza del Sale.
What You Actually Get
Rooms come with garden views and solid Wi-Fi (8.2). The indoor swimming pool is free and accessible year-round; the full spa (sauna, Turkish bath, ice machine) costs €20 per person. There’s a good breakfast included and free parking. Pets are allowed on request, though charges may apply. Note that booking more than 4 rooms triggers different policies.
Choose this if: You want a hotel with solid wellness amenities but don’t need to be in the historic center; the bus makes it easy.
2. Hotel Executive
The Vibe
Now under new management, Hotel Executive sits in a quiet residential area a 10-minute walk from Siena’s train station. Guests consistently give staff a 9.2 — the front desk team is known for handing out city tips and maps. Cleanliness scores 9.0, making it a reliable pick for a short stay.
What You Actually Get
All rooms are non-smoking with inner courtyard or quiet street views. The buffet breakfast (continental options) is rated very good. There’s free Wi-Fi (9.2), a restaurant serving Tuscan cuisine for lunch and dinner, and 24-hour front desk. Free private parking is available. Pets are allowed on request with charges. Children 13 and up are charged as adults.
Choose this if: You’re arriving by train and want a spotless, well-staffed hotel within walking distance.
3. Best Western Hotel San Marco
The Vibe
This 3-star punches far above its class. With an 8.8 overall and a 9.5 staff score, it’s the kind of place where receptionists hand you two maps, explain bus routes, and mark parking spots before you even ask. Cleanliness (9.2) and comfort (9.1) are best-in-class for its category.
What You Actually Get
Free parking with lots of space — huge for Siena. Rooms include tea and coffee makers. The breakfast (€10) is rated good. There’s a 24-hour front desk, elevator, and facilities for disabled guests. The hotel offers a Special Protection Program for safety. Pets are allowed with charges. Note that only small pets are accepted, and booking more than 5 rooms means different policies.
Choose this if: You’re driving to Siena. Free parking + exceptional staff = stress-free arrival.
4. Hotel More di Cuna
The Vibe
A countryside escape 7.4 miles from Piazza del Campo, this property runs on attentive service (staff 9.0) and sweeping Tuscan views. The garden and terrace are prime spots for evening relaxation. Wi-Fi scores a so-so 7.6, so plan accordingly if you need to work.
What You Actually Get
Rooms are comfortable (8.4) and clean (8.5). Breakfast offers gluten-free and vegan options alongside the continental buffet. The on-site restaurant serves dinner. One pet is allowed per stay at €30. There’s a gym 1 km away. The area is popular for its Artichoke Festival in Chiusure (April 24-27 in 2025).
Choose this if: You want countryside peace with easy access to Siena’s center by car.
5. Four Points by Sheraton Siena
The Vibe
Surrounded by olive groves in the Chianti hills, this 4-star feels like a resort without the resort crowds. A 10-minute drive from Siena’s historic walls, it balances access with quiet. Cleanliness and comfort both hit 9.1 — rare at this price point. The outdoor pool (open through September) is a summer highlight.
What You Actually Get
Three restaurants mean you’re never stuck on dinner options. Rooms feature tea and coffee makers. The fitness center is open year-round. Free parking is available, and a bus stop right outside the gate goes downtown. Pets are allowed with charges. The pool closes in bad weather, so check ahead in shoulder seasons.
Choose this if: You want a reliable chain experience with genuine Tuscan surroundings and easy city access.
6. Certosa di Pontignano Residenza d’Epoca – Place of Charme
The Vibe
Sleeping in an actual 14th-century monastery is the kind of experience that defines a Tuscan trip. Guests call the breakfast “best in northern Italy.” With a 9.1 rating across 1400+ reviews and historic architecture that includes cloisters and frescoed halls, it’s pure atmosphere. Location (9.3) puts it close to both Siena and Florence.
What You Actually Get
Rooms maintain original character while offering modern comfort (9.0). The restaurant serves dinner, and breakfast is wonderful. Free parking is available, and airport shuttle can be arranged. Pets are allowed at no extra charge — but only in the apartment-style rooms with private courtyards. Wi-Fi is weaker (7.5), a fair trade for 14th-century stone walls.
Choose this if: You want a unique historic stay with excellent breakfast and grounds that feel like a film set.
Check Tonight’s Price for Certosa di Pontignano Residenza d’Epoca – Place of Charme →
7. ApartHotel Anghel
The Vibe
This is the best small hotel in Tuscany for travelers who want independence. Each unit is a proper apartment with a kitchen, making it ideal for longer stays or families who want to cook. Cleanliness (9.1) and comfort (9.0) are strong, and free parking right at the entrance solves a major Siena headache.
What You Actually Get
Apartments include a king-size bed setup in superior units, free Wi-Fi (8.7), and elevator access. Staff (9.2) consistently gets praise for being accommodating — they even allow bike storage inside the apartment. There’s an airport shuttle available. Pets are allowed with charges. Check-in closes at 7:00 PM, so plan arrival time carefully.
Choose this if: You’re traveling with family, on a longer stay, or just want the freedom of a kitchen.
8. Hotel Villa San Giorgio
The Vibe
Set in the western Chianti area, Villa San Giorgio overlooks the Elsa Valley through a sea of vineyards. Staff scores 9.4 — tied for second highest in this list. Value hits 9.0, meaning you get genuine 4-star quality at 3-star prices. The outdoor pool operates May through September.
What You Actually Get
All rooms have showers. The restaurant is open for dinner from 19:30 to 21:30. Breakfast (Italian/gluten-free options) is very good. Free parking is available, and an airport shuttle can be arranged. There’s a vineyard within walking distance for tours. Wi-Fi is weak at 7.1 — a common trade-off for countryside properties.
Choose this if: You’re a wine lover looking for a countryside hotel with stellar service and reasonable rates.
9. Mercure Petriolo Siena Terme Spa Hotel
The Vibe
Immersed in quiet hills next to thermal springs dating back thousands of years, this 4-star is for spa seekers. Two swimming pools and two restaurants give you options. The staff, especially Fatue, receives standout praise for going above and beyond. At 8.1, it’s lower-rated but perfectly suited for pure relaxation.
What You Actually Get
Rooms come with mini-bar fridges and are spacious enough for families. Two restaurants serve lunch and dinner. The fitness center is open. Free parking is available. Up to 2 animals are accepted at €15 per day each. Wi-Fi scores 8.4 — stronger than most countryside properties. Location (7.9) is the weak point; you’ll need a car.
Choose this if: Your priority is soaking in thermal waters and disconnecting for a few days.
Check Tonight’s Price for Mercure Petriolo Siena Terme Spa Hotel →
10. Palazzo Leopoldo Dimora Storica & Spa
The Vibe
A patrician villa from 1310 plus two adjacent historical buildings — this is Chianti grandeur without the chain-hotel feel. Location (9.3) in Radda in Chianti puts you in the heart of wine country. Three swimming pools (including a bookable indoor heated pool) and two restaurants mean plenty of on-site options.
What You Actually Get
Rooms score 9.0 for comfort and cleanliness. The indoor heated pool requires advance booking for 45-minute exclusive shifts. Breakfast is wonderful. Free parking is available. Pets are allowed with charges. The spa and wellness area is available. Wi-Fi is weaker (7.4), but the views from balconies more than compensate.
Choose this if: You want historic charm with modern pool access in the heart of Chianti.
Check Tonight’s Price for Palazzo Leopoldo Dimora Storica & Spa →
11. Ultimo Mulino Country Hotel
The Vibe
Gaiole in Chianti was named the “most beautiful place to live” by Forbes, and Ultimo Mulino lives up to that billing. It’s romantic, historic, and quiet — guests rave about the dinner and wine. Comfort scores 9.0. The outdoor pool operates April to October and isn’t heated, so it’s a summer-only amenity.
What You Actually Get
Rooms are comfortable (9.0) and clean (8.9). The restaurant serves dinner and breakfast is good. Free parking is available. Airport shuttle can be arranged. Pets are allowed with charges. Wi-Fi is weak (7.2) — embrace the digital detox. The property has facilities for disabled guests.
Choose this if: You want a romantic, quiet escape in Chianti’s most celebrated village.
12. Quattro Gigli Hotel
The Vibe
A 3-star with a 9.3 staff score and an outdoor pool — Quattro Gigli overdelivers. Located in Montopoli Valdarno between Pisa (28 km) and Florence (39 km), it’s a strategic stop for travelers moving between cities. The location (8.7) is rated highly by recent guests. Breakfast is very good with hot and cold options.
What You Actually Get
Rooms are comfortable (8.6) with city views. Free parking is available. Wi-Fi scores 8.6. There’s a terrace and bar. Pets are allowed with charges. Check-in is only until 7:00 PM — late arrivals need advance notice. Public transport is available for exploring nearby towns without a car.
Choose this if: You need a halfway stop between Florence and Pisa with pool access and excellent staff.
13. Tuscasì Aparthotel
The Vibe
A near-perfect 9.2 rating with a 9.6 staff score — Tuscasì is the highest-rated aparthotel in this guide. Facilities (9.4), cleanliness (9.5), and comfort (9.4) are all outstanding. Every unit is a full apartment with kitchen and washing machine, designed for extended stays. Pets stay free.
What You Actually Get
Apartments are spacious, modern, and well-equipped. The fitness center is available. Free parking includes a garage with a 2.10m height limit for vans. Wi-Fi scores 9.1 — strong and reliable. Breakfast is wonderful. Self-check-in is available for late arrivals. Location (8.9) is near a grocery store and restaurants within walking distance.
Choose this if: You’re staying a week or more and want apartment comfort with hotel service levels.
14. Albergo Di Murlo
The Vibe
With a 9.7 staff score — the highest in this entire guide — Albergo Di Murlo sets the standard for Tuscan hospitality. Staff member Sara gets special mentions for cycling tips and local knowledge. Positioned halfway between Siena and Montalcino (both 16 miles), it’s ideal for exploring both regions. The pool is a summer highlight.
What You Actually Get
Rooms score 9.2 for cleanliness and 9.0 for comfort. The restaurant serves amazing food — guests consistently praise it. Excellent breakfast is included. Free parking is available. Wi-Fi is decent at 8.4. Pets are allowed with charges. The pool has lovely views of the surrounding hills.
Choose this if: You want the best staff experience in Tuscany while exploring Siena and Montalcino wine country.
15. Residence Poggio Golf Chianti Firenze
The Vibe
The closest property to Florence on this list (14 km from FLR), this residence sits in the quiet Chianti countryside while offering easy city access. The outdoor pool has a sun terrace with a safety fence — good for families. Score 8.8 reflects consistent quality across the board, with comfort at 9.1.
What You Actually Get
Apartments with balconies are available. Free on-site parking is included. Breakfast can be arranged. The outdoor pool is open in summer (11:00 AM to 8:00 PM). Wi-Fi scores 8.1. Pets are not allowed. The first set of bed linen and towels is included in the rate. Note that dogs must follow specific rules if accepted.
Choose this if: You want to split your time between Florence sightseeing and Chianti relaxation.
Check Tonight’s Price for Residence Poggio Golf Chianti Firenze →
16. Borgo San Martino – Residence Hotel & SPA
The Vibe
In the quiet Pisa countryside, Borgo San Martino offers two swimming pools and a spa — a solid choice for families with kids. Staff scores 9.0, and the location (8.7) provides a peaceful base. The garden view rooms add to the relaxed atmosphere. It’s 5.8 miles from Acqua Village water park.
What You Actually Get
Two swimming pools (seasonal outdoor). The restaurant serves meals. Free parking and Wi-Fi (8.8) are included. Excellent breakfast is available. Family rooms are offered. Pets are not allowed. Note that booking more than 2 rooms triggers different policies. The air conditioning in some rooms has been noted as an issue by past guests.
Choose this if: You’re traveling with kids and want a quiet base with pool time.
Check Tonight’s Price for Borgo San Martino – Residence Hotel & SPA →
17. Relais San Lorenzo
The Vibe
A 9.1-rated 3-star near Mount Amiata, Relais San Lorenzo impresses with a 9.5 staff score and a pool that guests rave about. The restaurant serves what one guest called “the best beef steak in a while.” Cleanliness (9.4) and comfort (9.3) are exceptional for its category. It’s a spa-optional experience — reserve the spa for €70 per hour.
What You Actually Get
The outdoor swimming pool has a view. Two restaurants serve meals, and there are vegan breakfast options available. Rooms feature tea and coffee makers. Free parking is available. Wi-Fi is adequate (8.0). Pets are not allowed. The property is fully booked often — plan ahead. Note the early check-in cut-off at 9:00 PM.
Choose this if: You want a clean, comfortable mountain-area stay with excellent dining and a memorable pool.
18. Sette Querce
The Vibe
Tied for the highest overall rating in this guide at 9.2, Sette Querce is a renovated 1930s building just 164 feet from San Casciano Dei Bagni. Staff (9.6) and location (9.5) are both elite. Guests love that breakfast is delivered to their room — fresh, tasty, and convenient. Wi-Fi (9.3) is strong enough for remote work.
What You Actually Get
Rooms are spacious with beautiful bathrooms. Cleanliness scores 9.5 and comfort 9.4. Tea and coffee makers are in all rooms. The restaurant serves dinner. Free parking is available. Pets stay free on request. There’s a ground-floor junior suite available for guests with mobility concerns — request room 102. Excellent breakfast included.
Choose this if: You want the best small hotel experience in southern Tuscany with top-tier service and location.
19. Antico Casale Di Scansano Resort
The Vibe
A 4-star resort near Scansano with both indoor and outdoor pools, it’s designed for adults and children 12+ (wellness facilities are adults-only). Location (9.1) offers beautiful views and quiet. The restaurant serves outstanding dinners according to guests. It’s 14 miles from Cascate del Mulino Thermal Springs.
What You Actually Get
Rooms are comfortable (8.8) and clean (8.8). The fitness center is available. Free parking is included. Wi-Fi is weaker at 6.9 — expect spotty connection. Excellent breakfast is included. Pets are allowed on request with a charge of €15 per day. The hot tub and sauna cost €20 per person for 2 hours. No group transport from Scansano station.
Choose this if: You want a resort experience with pool options and don’t mind being off the beaten path.
Check Tonight’s Price for Antico Casale Di Scansano Resort →
20. Hotel Tenuta di Artimino member of Meliá Collection
The Vibe
Part of the Meliá Collection, this historic estate near Artimino delivers a full Tuscan immersion — guests describe it as “fairytale wedding” material. Location (9.1) and comfort (9.1) are strong. It’s only 45 minutes from Florence airport (12 km from FLR). Three restaurants and free bikes make exploring easy.
What You Actually Get
Three restaurants serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner. The seasonal outdoor pool is available. Airport shuttle can be arranged. Free parking is included. Wi-Fi is decent (8.1). Pets are allowed on request with charges. The spa circuit (2 hours per day) is included in the room rate — book your slot at check-in. Note that Borgo rooms are in an annex 1,312 feet from the main building.
Choose this if: You want a full-service resort near Florence with historical character and included spa access.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hotel Tenuta di Artimino member of Meliá Collection →
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#18 Sette Querce
9.2 rating with a 9.6 staff score and 9.5 location — it’s the complete small-hotel package in southern Tuscany.
💰 Best Value
#3 Best Western Hotel San Marco
8.8 overall with 9.5 staff, free parking, and 24-hour front desk at prices that undercut most Siena hotels.
🏠 Best for Long Stays
#13 Tuscasì Aparthotel
Full kitchens and washing machines with 9.2 rating and 9.6 staff
Full kitchens and washing machines with 9.2 rating and 9.6 staff — ideal for a week or more in Tuscany.
How We Ranked These Hotels
We evaluated 20 properties across Tuscany, filtering over 22,400+ verified guest reviews to surface only hotels with an average score of 8.7/10 or higher. Every property was scored on eight criteria including staff, cleanliness, location, and value.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 8.0+ overall and 300+ verified reviews made the cut
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and staff scores — the three metrics that correlate with repeat bookings
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns to flag fluff vs. reality
- Location signals: Distance to Siena historic center, Chianti wine regions, thermal springs, and major airports
Frequently Asked Questions
Are pets allowed at these small Tuscan hotels?
Policies vary by property. Sette Querce (#18) and Tuscasì Aparthotel (#13) welcome pets at no extra charge. Several others — including Precise House Montaperti, Hotel Executive, and Best Western San Marco — allow pets on request with potential fees. Borgo San Martino (#16), Relais San Lorenzo (#17), and Residence Poggio Golf (#15) do not allow pets. Always confirm directly before booking.
Which hotels offer free cancellation?
Most properties in this guide offer flexible cancellation policies, but terms vary by room type and rate. Precise House Montaperti, Hotel Executive, and Best Western San Marco have standard cancellation options — check the specific conditions when searching for your dates. For last-minute flexibility, look for “free cancellation” filters during your search.
What’s the best time to visit Tuscany for small hotels?
Late spring (May-June) and early autumn (September-October) offer the best balance: warm weather, fewer crowds, and outdoor pools open at properties like Quattro Gigli (#12) and Hotel Villa San Giorgio (#8). July and August are peak season with higher rates and more tourists. For thermal bath enthusiasts, Mercure Petriolo (#9) and Antico Casale (#19) operate year-round with indoor pool access.
How do I get from Florence Airport to these Tuscan hotels?
Florence Airport (FLR) is the most convenient hub. Residence Poggio Golf (#15) is just 14 km away. Most Siena-area hotels (Precise House, Hotel Executive, Best Western San Marco) are about 55 km south — a 45-minute drive. For Chianti properties like Palazzo Leopoldo (#10) and Ultimo Mulino (#11), budget 1-1.5 hours. Several hotels offer airport shuttle services for an additional fee.
Which area in Tuscany is most walkable without a car?
Siena’s historic center is the most walkable base. Hotels within bus range include Precise House Montaperti (bus line 5), Hotel Executive (10-min walk from train station), and Best Western San Marco (bus access). For a car-free stay in Chianti, choose Palazzo Leopoldo (#10) in Radda — the village is compact and walkable. Most countryside properties require a vehicle for full exploration.
Can I check in late at these small Tuscan hotels?
Yes, but policies differ. Best Western San Marco (#3) has 24-hour reception for late arrivals. Mercure Petriolo (#9) and Hotel Tenuta di Artimino (#20) accept check-ins until midnight. Tuscasì Aparthotel (#13) offers self-check-in for arrivals after 8:00 PM. Hotels with earlier cut-offs include ApartHotel Anghel (7:00 PM) and Sette Querce (7:00 PM) — always communicate your arrival time in advance.