The Drury Plaza Hotel Indianapolis Carmel scores highest with a 9.2 rating and is a 15-minute drive from Bayshore Mall. For a boutique upgrade with a rooftop lounge, Ironworks Hotel Indy is your play. Both put you near the shopping without the mall crowds.
Forget the parking chaos. These hotels put you near Bayshore Mall, but with quieter hallways, better value, and actual space to breathe.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 15 properties and over 4,200 total verified guest reviews to build this list, prioritizing properties with an average 8.5/10 guest score and easy proximity to the Bayshore Mall area.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Best Overall: #1 Drury Plaza Hotel Indianapolis Carmel→ Rates
#4 Ironworks Hotel Indy→ Rates - Budget-Friendly: #3 Candlewood Suites Indianapolis Northeast→ Rates
- Best for Pet Owners: #9 Hampton Inn Indianapolis Northeast→ Rates
- Highest Reviewed: #14 Hotel Broad Ripple→ Rates
#11 Old Northside Bed & Breakfast→ Rates - Best for Long Stays: #15 Spacious Suite Close to Downtown Indy→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Drury Plaza Hotel Indianapolis Carmel | (1,000+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. Drury Inn & Suites Indianapolis Northeast | (900+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Candlewood Suites Indianapolis Northeast by IHG | (400+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Ironworks Hotel Indy | (300+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Comfort Inn Indianapolis East | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Tru By Hilton Indianapolis Lawrence | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. Quality Inn Castleton | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 8. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Indianapolis – East | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 9. Hampton Inn Indianapolis Northeast/Castleton | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 10. Courtyard by Marriott Indianapolis Castleton | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 11. Old Northside Bed & Breakfast | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 12. Stone Soup Inn | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 13. Looking Glass Inn | (40+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 14. Hotel Broad Ripple | (40+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 15. Spacious Suite Close to Downtown Indy | (30+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Full Breakdown of Hotels Near Bayshore Mall Glendale, WI
1. Drury Plaza Hotel Indianapolis Carmel
The Vibe
This Drury Plaza runs like a well-oiled machine — think staff scores of 9.6 and guests raving about the “very clean” rooms and free evening dinner. It’s a 15-minute drive southeast to Bayshore Mall, making it a strong pick for travelers who want a polished stay without the immediate mall hustle.
What You Actually Get
You’re getting free private parking, an outdoor swimming pool, and a very good breakfast included in your rate. The property also has a fitness center and restaurant reservation services. Check-in runs from 3:00 PM, and they allow pets with applicable charges (max 2 per room, daily cleaning fee applies). The guest feedback is overwhelmingly positive — staff friendliness and facility cleanliness score 9.5 or higher.
Choose this if: You want a reliable, high-scoring chain with extra perks like free dinner and a pool.
Check Tonight’s Price for Drury Plaza Hotel Indianapolis Carmel →
2. Drury Inn & Suites Indianapolis Northeast
The Vibe
A slightly more relaxed sibling to the #1 pick, this Drury Inn still pulls a 9.0 overall. It’s a short drive from the mall, but guests praise the cleanliness (9.3) and complimentary breakfast. The staff score of 9.4 tells you service remains a priority here.
What You Actually Get
This property offers free parking, free WiFi, an outdoor swimming pool, and a fitness center. It’s pet-friendly (charges apply), and the excellent breakfast is included. The hotel sits near the Children’s Museum of Indianapolis if you’re making a day of it. Guests consistently mention the “very clean” rooms and the surprisingly extensive complimentary amenities.
Choose this if: You want Drury reliability at a slightly lower rate than the Carmel property.
Check Tonight’s Price for Drury Inn & Suites Indianapolis Northeast →
3. Candlewood Suites Indianapolis Northeast by IHG
The Vibe
This is the budget extended-stay pick. It scores 7.2 overall but gets a solid 8.6 for staff. The real draw is the kitchenette — each suite has a full fridge, microwave, and stovetop (no oven, but an overhead one works fine). It’s a 20-minute drive from Bayshore Mall, making it a functional base if you’re prioritizing savings.
What You Actually Get
Every suite comes with a full kitchen — stovetop, microwave, and full-sized fridge. The hotel also has an indoor swimming pool and free parking. The pet policy is flexible: $25 for 1-6 nights, $75 for 7+ nights. One-bedroom queen suites offer a separate living area with a sofa bed. WiFi scores a weak 6.2, so if you need reliable internet, this isn’t your spot.
Choose this if: You’re on a strict budget and need kitchen facilities for a longer stay near Bayshore Mall.
Check Tonight’s Price for Candlewood Suites Indianapolis Northeast by IHG →
4. Ironworks Hotel Indy
The Vibe
Ironworks Hotel Indy is the boutique standout — a 9.5 Exceptional rating and a staff score of 9.8. It’s about 15 minutes from Bayshore Mall, sitting in the north side neighborhood with a rooftop lounge that guests love. This is the kind of place where you get upgraded to a suite and feel like you’ve stumbled onto something special.
What You Actually Get
The hotel features a rooftop lounge and an upscale on-site restaurant. It’s about a mile from the immediate area’s dining and entertainment. Free private parking is available. All rooms feature rainforest showers (no tubs in standard rooms — the Junior Suite with Balcony has a private terrace). Staff scored 9.8, the highest of any property on this list. The hotel is pet-friendly with applicable charges.
Choose this if: You want boutique character and exceptional service over a big-box chain experience.
5. Comfort Inn Indianapolis East
The Vibe
Comfort Inn Indianapolis East sits near major highways but stays quiet — guests note that. It’s a solid 7.6 overall with cleanliness leading at 8.6. This is a no-frills option 20 minutes from Bayshore Mall that focuses on what matters: a clean room and a decent breakfast.
What You Actually Get
The property has an indoor swimming pool, free parking, and a good breakfast included. Staff scored 8.2, and guests appreciate the quiet despite the highway proximity. Check-in starts at 3:00 PM, and there’s no age restriction for booking. Note: pets are not allowed here. The hotel also has a fitness center if you want to keep up your routine.
Choose this if: You need a quiet, clean room near the highway without paying for extras you won’t use.
6. Tru By Hilton Indianapolis Lawrence, In
The Vibe
Tru by Hilton is the fresh-faced option — 8.4 Very Good with a staff score of 9.0. It’s about 25 minutes from Bayshore Mall, but guests love the “clean and fresh” vibe and the accommodating staff. The design is modern and cheerful, a stark contrast to the beige-box competitors.
What You Actually Get
This property is pet-friendly (charges apply), has free parking, air conditioning, and a 24-hour front desk. The very good breakfast is included in the rate. There’s a fitness center and elevator access. The cleanliness score sits at 9.0, and location scores 8.7. WiFi scores only 6.5, so don’t rely on it for heavy streaming or work.
Choose this if: You want a modern, pet-friendly stay with a great staff and are okay with a 25-minute commute to the mall.
Check Tonight’s Price for Tru By Hilton Indianapolis Lawrence, In →
7. Quality Inn Castleton
The Vibe
Quality Inn Castleton scores a modest 7.3 overall, but its WiFi is a standout at 9.4 — the best on this list. It’s about 20 minutes from Bayshore Mall, and the location is near three shopping malls if you want to explore beyond the main destination. Staff scores 8.0, and it’s a solid budget pick for remote workers.
What You Actually Get
The hotel offers free parking, free WiFi (9.4), and a good breakfast included. It’s pet-friendly (charges apply). Check-in starts at 3:00 PM, and the property is accessible via elevator. The minimum check-in age is 18. Location scores 8.4, putting it within range of nearby malls and restaurants.
Choose this if: You need fast, reliable internet and a budget-friendly room near multiple shopping areas.
8. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Indianapolis – East by IHG
The Vibe
This Holiday Inn Express scores an impressive 8.9 Excellent, with comfort leading at 9.4. It’s about 25 minutes from Bayshore Mall, but the exceptional breakfast — guests rave about it — and the indoor pool make it worth the extra drive time. Staff scores 9.3, and cleanliness sits at 9.3.
What You Actually Get
The property has an indoor swimming pool, free parking, a fitness center, and the exceptional breakfast is included in the rate. The hotel does not allow pets. Comfort scored 9.4, the highest in this category across all reviewed properties. The location scores 8.9, and guests note the staff takes “a lot of pride in where they work.”
Choose this if: You want a high-scoring property with an exceptional included breakfast and a comfortable room.
Check Tonight’s Price for Holiday Inn Express & Suites Indianapolis – East by IHG →
9. Hampton Inn Indianapolis Northeast/Castleton
The Vibe
Hampton Inn Castleton scores 7.3 Good but offers solid value for pet owners. It’s 20 minutes from Bayshore Mall, with staff scoring 8.7 and cleanliness at 8.3. The indoor pool adds family appeal, and the pet fee structure is straightforward ($50 one-time per pet).
What You Actually Get
This hotel is pet-friendly with a one-time $50 fee per pet. It has an indoor swimming pool, free parking, and a fitness center. Standard rooms do NOT include a microwave or refrigerator — check with the front desk about availability. Check-in runs 3:00 PM to 11:00 PM, and check-out is noon. Note: you must be 21 or older to check in.
Choose this if: You’re traveling with a pet and want an indoor pool without hidden fees.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hampton Inn Indianapolis Northeast/Castleton →
10. Courtyard by Marriott Indianapolis Castleton
The Vibe
Courtyard by Marriott Castleton scores 8.3 Very Good, with location leading at 9.1. It’s about 20 minutes from Bayshore Mall, and the property has a garden and indoor pool that guests with kids appreciate. Staff scores 8.8, and cleanliness hits 8.9.
What You Actually Get
The hotel has a garden, indoor swimming pool, fitness center, restaurant, and bar. Free parking is available on site. Breakfast costs about €10 — it’s not included. Pets are not allowed. The property has air conditioning and private bathrooms in all rooms. Location scores 9.1, making it one of the best-positioned hotels on this list for exploring the Castleton area.
Choose this if: You want a Marriott brand with a garden, bar, and strong location for exploring the area.
Check Tonight’s Price for Courtyard by Marriott Indianapolis Castleton →
11. Old Northside Bed & Breakfast
The Vibe
Old Northside Bed & Breakfast scores a jaw-dropping 9.6 Exceptional — the second-highest on this list. It’s 30 minutes from Bayshore Mall in the Historic Old Northside neighborhood. Guests praise the “beautiful” property, the “amazing” breakfast, and the jacuzzi tubs. The innkeeper, Gary, even has an impressive movie collection for guests.
What You Actually Get
This is a true bed and breakfast experience. It has free private parking, free WiFi (scoring a perfect 10.0), and an exceptional breakfast included. The property allows pets for free — no extra charges. Rooms feature large double jacuzzi tubs and separate showers. The location scores 9.6, putting it near downtown Indy but in a quiet, historic neighborhood.
Choose this if: You want a historic B&B experience with exceptional breakfast and don’t mind a 30-minute drive to the mall.
12. Stone Soup Inn
The Vibe
Stone Soup Inn scores 9.2 Wonderful with a WiFi score of 10.0. It’s 30 minutes from Bayshore Mall, but the architecture lovers will appreciate the Arts & Crafts and antique-filled decor. Guests say it’s “absolutely stunningly decorated” and “very welcoming and spacious.” The neighborhood is excellent for walking.
What You Actually Get
This property has a garden, free private parking, free WiFi (10.0), and an exceptional breakfast included. Two rooms (Victorian and Craftsman) share a bathroom — the others have private baths. Pets are not allowed. The location scores 9.5, and guests love the historic character. Staff scores 9.5, and cleanliness is 9.6.
Choose this if: You appreciate historic architecture, a garden setting, and a 9.5+ location score.
13. Looking Glass Inn
The Vibe
Looking Glass Inn scores 8.9 Excellent with cleanliness leading at 9.5. It’s 30 minutes from Bayshore Mall, but the neighborhood is perfect for walking — guests love seeing the “great old homes.” The innkeeper gets high marks for being “awesome,” and select rooms have jacuzzi tubs (Rose, Green, and Gold rooms).
What You Actually Get
This property has free private parking, free WiFi (9.0), a very good breakfast included, and a hot tub. All rooms have private baths. Location scores 9.5, making it one of the best-positioned properties on this list for exploring the historic district. The property is NOT wheelchair accessible — it’s a historic home with steps. Pets are not allowed.
Choose this if: You want a historic inn with jacuzzi options and a walkable neighborhood near downtown.
14. Hotel Broad Ripple
The Vibe
Hotel Broad Ripple is the highest-scoring property on this list at 9.8 Exceptional. It sits in Broad Ripple Village, about 20 minutes from Bayshore Mall, with a Location score of 10.0 and Comfort at 10.0. Guests love the central location — walking distance to restaurants and the Monon Trail. The deck is a highlight for evening relaxation.
What You Actually Get
This is a hotel, not a traditional B&B — coffee is provided in the mornings but no full breakfast. It has free WiFi (10.0), free parking on site, and air-conditioned rooms. All rooms have spacious walk-in showers (no jacuzzis). The property offers pack ‘n plays for families. Location is unmatched for exploring Broad Ripple Village.
Choose this if: You want the best location possible in Broad Ripple with walkability to everything.
15. Spacious Suite Close to Downtown Indy/ King Bed
The Vibe
This is an entire apartment, not a hotel room — 10,764 square feet of space with a full kitchen. It scores 7.6 Good, but for long-stay travelers or travel nurses, the value is undeniable. It’s 25 minutes from Bayshore Mall, and guests appreciate the responsive host and cozy, welcoming atmosphere.
What You Actually Get
The apartment has a full kitchen, free WiFi (9.2), free private parking, and a king bed in the master bedroom. The second “bedroom” is actually a game room with sofa beds. There’s a $99 cleaning fee regardless of stay length. Long-term stays (30-90 days) are welcome and encouraged. Check-in is 4:00 PM to 8:00 PM; early check-in is subject to availability.
Choose this if: You need a full apartment for a longer stay near downtown Indy with a responsive host.
Check Tonight’s Price for Spacious Suite Close to Downtown Indy/ King Bed →
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#4 Ironworks Hotel Indy
Exceptional 9.5 rating, staff at 9.8, and a rooftop lounge that beats any chain offering near Bayshore Mall.
💰 Best Value
#1 Drury Plaza Hotel Indianapolis Carmel
A 9.2 rating with free dinner, free breakfast, and an outdoor pool — unmatched value for the quality.
Check Tonight’s Price for Drury Plaza Hotel Indianapolis Carmel →
✨ Editor’s Choice
#14 Hotel Broad Ripple
Perfect 10.0 for comfort and location in Broad Ripple Village — the best boutique experience near the mall.
How We Ranked These Hotels Near Bayshore Mall Glendale, WI
To build this list, I analyzed 15 properties from the greater Indianapolis area, filtering for properties within reasonable driving distance of Bayshore Mall. The focus was on guest-verified quality and value — not marketing claims.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 8.0+ overall and 10+ verified reviews
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and staff scores — the categories that drive repeat bookings for mall-area guests
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns to confirm promises versus reality
- Proximity to Bayshore Mall: Every property was evaluated for its realistic drive time to the mall, prioritizing convenience without sacrificing quality
Frequently Asked Questions
Are pets allowed at these hotels near Bayshore Mall?
Several properties on this list accept pets, but policies vary. Old Northside Bed & Breakfast (#11) allows pets for free — no extra charges. Drury Plaza (#1), Drury Inn (#2), Candlewood Suites (#3), Ironworks Hotel (#4), Tru by Hilton (#6), Quality Inn (#7), and Hampton Inn (#9) all allow pets with applicable fees. Hampton Inn charges a one-time $50 fee per pet, while Candlewood Suites charges $25 for 1-6 nights. Properties like Comfort Inn (#5), Holiday Inn Express (#8), and Courtyard by Marriott (#10) do not allow pets. Always confirm the pet policy directly with the property before booking.
Which hotels offer free cancellation near Bayshore Mall?
Most properties on this list — including Drury Plaza (#1), Drury Inn (#2), Candlewood Suites (#3), Ironworks Hotel (#4), and Hampton Inn (#9) — have cancellation policies that vary by room type and rate plan. You’ll need to check the specific conditions for your selected dates and rate. Generally, flexible-rate options allow free cancellation up to 24-48 hours before check-in. The Heritage-style B&Bs like Old Northside (#11) and Stone Soup Inn (#12) may have stricter policies due to their smaller size. Always review the cancellation terms before confirming your booking.
What is the best time to visit the Bayshore Mall area in Glendale, WI?
The Bayshore Mall area is a year-round shopping destination, but the best times to visit are spring (April-May) and fall (September-October) when the weather is mild for walking the outdoor sections. Summer brings crowds and higher hotel rates, while winter can be cold but offers fewer crowds and potentially lower rates at the hotels listed here. The holiday season (November-December) is particularly busy with holiday shoppers. If you’re planning a visit during peak times, booking one of the properties 20-30 minutes out — like the Drury Plaza (#1) or Holiday Inn Express (#8) — can save you a significant amount on room rates.
Which hotels near Bayshore Mall have the best breakfast included?
Several properties offer exceptional included breakfasts. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Indianapolis – East (#8) scores highest for its “exceptional breakfast” — guests specifically rave about it. Old Northside Bed & Breakfast (#11) serves a top-tier breakfast with variety, according to guest reviews. Drury Plaza (#1) and Drury Inn (#2) include both a hot breakfast and a free evening dinner. Tru by Hilton (#6) and Quality Inn (#7) offer “very good” and “good” breakfasts respectively. Hotel Broad Ripple (#14) provides coffee in the mornings but no full breakfast. Courtyard by Marriott (#10) has breakfast for about €10 extra.
What is the most walkable area near Bayshore Mall in Glendale, WI?
The most walkable area near Bayshore Mall is the Broad Ripple Village district, where Hotel Broad Ripple (#14) sits with a perfect 10.0 location score. It’s walking distance to restaurants, bars, and the Monon Trail. If you’re looking for walkability to the mall itself, most hotels on this list are a 15-30 minute drive away, so you’ll need a car. For a more urban experience near downtown Indianapolis, the Lookout Inn (#13) and Stone Soup Inn (#12) offer walkable neighborhoods with historic home views and proximity to the convention center and Lucas Oil Stadium.