Chautauqua Harbor Hotel tops our list with a 9.3 rating and lake views from private balconies. For walkability to the Lucille Ball Museum, La Quinta by Wyndham delivers an 8.7 location score and free parking. Both anchor Jamestown stays done right.
Jamestown packs in the Comedy Center, Chautauqua Lake, and solid hotel options — you just need to know which fits your trip.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 6 properties across 1800+ total verified guest reviews to compile this list, prioritizing properties with an average guest score of 8.4/10 for quality assurance.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Best Overall: #2 Chautauqua Harbor Hotel→ Rates
- Best Walkability to Comedy Center: #1 La Quinta by Wyndham→ Rates
#3 Doubletree by Hilton→ Rates - Best for Cleanliness: #2 Chautauqua Harbor Hotel→ Rates
#5 Hampton Inn and Suites→ Rates - Top Pet-Friendly Pick: #1 La Quinta by Wyndham→ Rates
- Budget-Friendly (7.0+ Rating): #4 Clarion Pointe Jamestown→ Rates
- Best Breakfast Included: #5 Hampton Inn and Suites→ Rates
#6 Holiday Inn Express→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. La Quinta by Wyndham Jamestown | (550+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. Chautauqua Harbor Hotel – Jamestown | (450+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Doubletree By Hilton Jamestown, Ny | (250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Clarion Pointe Jamestown – Falconer | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Hampton Inn and Suites Jamestown | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Jamestown by IHG | (100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Detailed Reviews: Hotels in Jamestown, NY 14701 Reviewed: The Full Breakdown
1. La Quinta by Wyndham Jamestown
The Vibe
This is the downtown walkability champion — the Comedy Center is four minutes on foot. Guests rave about the waffles at breakfast and the 8.5 cleanliness score holds steady. Location and staff both hit 8.7, making it a solid base for exploring downtown Jamestown without a car.
What You Actually Get
Rooms come with a fridge, microwave, and coffee setup — useful for late-night snacks after the show. The indoor pool and fitness center are open year-round. Pets are welcome (two max, 75lbs each, $25/night), which is rare in downtown Jamestown. Stand-up showers only, no bathtubs. The free parking lot saves you from garage fees.
Choose this if: you want a pet-friendly downtown base with free parking and short walks to museums.
2. Chautauqua Harbor Hotel – Jamestown
The Vibe
This is Jamestown’s premium stay. The 9.6 comfort score is backed by lake-facing balconies, plush beds, and a 9.5 cleanliness rating. Staff and facilities both hit 9.5. If you’re after a getaway that feels resort-level while still being close to downtown attractions, this is it.
What You Actually Get
Balcony rooms overlook either the lake or the parking lot — request lake side. The indoor pool runs 6am-10pm (capacity-limited at 10 people), and the outdoor pool operates seasonally through September. On-site restaurant handles dinner. Rooms include ironing boards, and elevator access covers upper floors. No pets allowed. Free private parking is included.
Choose this if: you’re celebrating something or just want the nicest hotel experience in the Jamestown area.
Check Tonight’s Price for Chautauqua Harbor Hotel – Jamestown →
3. Doubletree By Hilton Jamestown, Ny
The Vibe
The Hilton brand reliability meets Jamestown charm. Staff scores 9.0, cleanliness hits 8.9, and the location is just as central as La Quinta. Guests love the warm cookie greeting — it’s a small gesture that lands big. The on-site bar and restaurant save you from hunting for dinner after a long drive.
What You Actually Get
Suite rooms include pull-out sleeper sofas — useful for families. Free parking is available in the hotel lot, plus a validated garage next door. The indoor pool and fitness center are standard but well-maintained. Breakfast is rated “Very Good” by guests. Check-out is generous: as late as 12:00 PM. No pets allowed. Groups booking 10+ rooms face different policies.
Choose this if: you want Hilton consistency with a downtown location steps from the Comedy Center.
Check Tonight’s Price for Doubletree By Hilton Jamestown, Ny →
4. Clarion Pointe Jamestown – Falconer
The Vibe
The budget king of this list. The 7.0 overall score is honest — you get what you pay for, and what you get is blazing 9.4 Wi-Fi and first-floor jacuzzi rooms. Staff scores a respectable 8.1. It’s north of downtown about two miles, so you’ll need a car to reach the Comedy Center or lake.
What You Actually Get
First-floor rooms with jacuzzi tubs exist — request them specifically. Pets are allowed with a $25 fee and 50lb weight limit. Breakfast is included in the price, which helps the value argument. The fitness center is basic. Cleanliness scores 7.2, so manage expectations on room condition. Free private parking is straightforward.
Choose this if: you need to save money but still want solid Wi-Fi and a jacuzzi option.
Check Tonight’s Price for Clarion Pointe Jamestown – Falconer →
5. Hampton Inn and Suites Jamestown
The Vibe
Second-highest rated on this list at 8.9, and the staff score of 9.4 is the best in Jamestown. Cleanliness hits 9.2, comfort runs even. The indoor pool earns positive guest mentions — “clean and nice” is the consistent feedback. Breakfast is “Very Good” per reviews. A bit off the main downtown strip, but close enough to drive in minutes.
What You Actually Get
Every room includes a small fridge — confirmed by guest Q&A. Check-in requires you to be 21+. The indoor pool and fitness center are open standard hours. There’s a gas station with decent pizza and a McDonald’s right nearby for quick meals. Free parking is ample. No pets allowed. The location offers a nice view per guest feedback.
Choose this if: great service and a spotlessly clean room matter more than being right downtown.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hampton Inn and Suites Jamestown →
6. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Jamestown by IHG
The Vibe
IHG’s reliable Express brand delivers a comfortable 8.5 overall. The location scores 9.2, which is the best in this list for the north side — close to the highway and main routes without feeling remote. Guests call out the full breakfast and the comfort of the beds (9.1). It’s a straightforward, quality stay.
What You Actually Get
Rooms come with TV, fridge, microwave, and air conditioning. The indoor pool runs 7am-10pm with capacity limits. Free parking is right in front of the hotel. Breakfast is rated “Excellent” — above the typical Express standard. No pets allowed. The property accepts group bookings over 6 rooms with different policies. No age restriction for check-in.
Choose this if: you want a reliable IHG stay with excellent breakfast and easy highway access.
Check Tonight’s Price for Holiday Inn Express & Suites Jamestown by IHG →
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#2 Chautauqua Harbor Hotel – Jamestown
A 9.3 rating, 9.6 comfort score, and lake-view balconies make this the top-tier Jamestown experience.
Check Tonight’s Price for Chautauqua Harbor Hotel – Jamestown →
💰 Best Value
#5 Hampton Inn and Suites Jamestown
8.9 rating with 9.4 staff scores and clean rooms at a price well below the lakefront option.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hampton Inn and Suites Jamestown →
🏖️ Best Walkability
#1 La Quinta by Wyndham Jamestown
A 4-minute walk to the Comedy Center plus free parking and pet-friendly policy — unmatched convenience.
How We Ranked These Jamestown Hotels
I evaluated 6 properties from Booking.com with 1800+ verified reviews, filtering for properties scoring 8.0+ overall with at least 100 reviews. Location, cleanliness, and value scores were weighted most heavily since those drive repeat bookings in destinations like Jamestown.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 7.0+ overall and 100+ verified reviews
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and staff scores — the categories that determine real guest satisfaction
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns (free parking, breakfast quality, pool availability)
- Location signals: Distance to the Lucille Ball Desi Arnaz Center and Chautauqua Lake access
Frequently Asked Questions
Which hotels are closest to the Lucille Ball Comedy Center?
La Quinta by Wyndham (4-minute walk) and Doubletree by Hilton (less than 5-minute walk) are the closest. Both sit right downtown on West 3rd and 4th Streets respectively. Chautauqua Harbor Hotel is 2.8 miles away — you’ll need to drive or take a short taxi to the Comedy Center from there.
Are there pet-friendly hotels in Jamestown?
Yes — two properties on this list accept pets. La Quinta by Wyndham allows up to 2 pets (cats or dogs, 75lbs max each) for a $25/night nonrefundable fee. Clarion Pointe Jamestown also allows pets with a $25 fee and 50lb weight limit. All other hotels on this list do not allow pets.
Which Jamestown hotels offer free parking?
All six hotels on this list offer free parking. La Quinta, Chautauqua Harbor Hotel, Doubletree, Clarion Pointe, Hampton Inn, and Holiday Inn Express all include complimentary parking. Doubletree also validates for a parking garage next door if the main lot fills up. No need to budget for parking fees in Jamestown.
What’s the best time to visit Jamestown, NY?
Summer (June-August) is peak season — Chautauqua Lake is warm for swimming, and the outdoor pools at Chautauqua Harbor Hotel operate through September. Fall offers beautiful foliage and lower rates. Winter is quieter but the Comedy Center runs year-round. If you’re visiting for the Lucille Ball Festival (usually August), book months ahead.
Do these hotels have indoor pools?
Four out of six have indoor pools: La Quinta by Wyndham, Chautauqua Harbor Hotel (plus seasonal outdoor pool through September), Doubletree by Hilton, Hampton Inn and Suites, and Holiday Inn Express. Clarion Pointe does not list a pool. Pool hours vary — Holiday Inn Express runs 7am-10pm, Chautauqua Harbor runs 6am-10pm with capacity limits.
What’s the check-in age requirement in Jamestown?
Most hotels in Jamestown require guests to be 18 or older to check in. Hampton Inn and Suites specifically requires a minimum age of 21. Holiday Inn Express has no age restriction. Always carry a valid photo ID and credit card — all properties require both at check-in for incidentals.