The Edgewater leads with a 9.8 location score right on Avalon’s beachfront. For value-conscious stays, Hotel Mac Rae delivers a 9.8 location and continental breakfast, while Catalina Canyon Inn offers the only private parking and a pool.
Finding a **top rated hotel in Catalina Island** that matches your budget and style takes more than a quick search — these six properties made the cut based on real guest scores and data.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 6 properties and 2000+ total verified guest reviews to compile this list, which averages an 8.2/10 guest score across all hotels.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Best Location: #2 The Edgewater→ Rates
#3 Hotel Mac Rae→ Rates - Cleanest Rooms: #2 The Edgewater→ Rates
- Best Value: #3 Hotel Mac Rae→ Rates
- With a Pool & Parking: #1 Catalina Canyon Inn→ Rates
- Best Staff Scores: #3 Hotel Mac Rae→ Rates
#5 Bellanca Hotel→ Rates - Best for Wi-Fi: #3 Hotel Mac Rae→ Rates
#5 Bellanca Hotel→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Catalina Canyon Inn | (500+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. The Edgewater | (400+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Hotel Mac Rae | (350+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Catalina Island Inn | (300+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Bellanca Hotel | (250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Glenmore Plaza Hotel | (100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Top Rated Hotels in Catalina Island Reviewed: The Full Breakdown
1. Catalina Canyon Inn
The Vibe
Perched in the foothills above Avalon, Catalina Canyon Inn trades beachfront for peace and perks. Guests rate the staff 9.2 — the highest in this list — and the shuttle service earns constant praise for meeting every boat. The pool stays heated and the on-site restaurant means you don’t need to walk back into town for dinner.
What You Actually Get
This is the only property in our list with private parking (a huge win on Catalina, where cars are scarce) plus a fitness center and an outdoor swimming pool. The free shuttle runs continuously from the boat landing, covering the 0.75-mile uphill walk. Wi-Fi scores a solid 8.1, and the restaurant takes reservations. Cleanliness hits 9.0 and comfort matches at 9.0 — consistent across 500+ reviews. Note: breakfast isn’t included, and children 18+ are charged as adults.
Choose this if: You want a pool, private parking, and a quieter hillside setting (location score 8.5).
2. The Edgewater
The Vibe
The Edgewater earns the highest overall rating in this list at 8.9, driven by a Location score of 9.8 — the highest possible on Catalina. It’s right on the beachfront, a 10-minute walk from Descanso Beach, and every oceanfront suite has panoramic views of the bay. Cleanliness scores 9.4, second only to comfort at 9.3.
What You Actually Get
This is a self-check-in property, so your arrival is smooth even if the ferry runs late. Rooms don’t have balconies you can walk out on, but those panoramic bay windows make up for it. Staff score 9.1, and the Wi-Fi is 8.3. It’s a smaller property — no pool or parking — but the location means you’re steps from restaurants and the Green Pleasure Pier. Guests consistently call it “perfectly clean” and “incredible view.” Pets are not allowed, and children 15+ are charged as adults.
Choose this if: Location matters most — you want to walk out the door onto the beach (location 9.8).
3. Hotel Mac Rae
The Vibe
Hotel Mac Rae shares the 9.8 Location crown with The Edgewater but at a more accessible price point. It’s literally in front of the beach, with easy access to everything on Crescent Avenue. The inner courtyard provides a quiet escape from the street bustle, and the continental breakfast is a simple bonus that guests consistently note as a value-add.
What You Actually Get
Staff score 9.3 — the second highest in this list — and Wi-Fi hits 9.0, the joint best in this guide. Cleanliness is 8.9, comfort 8.9, and every room has its own private bathroom (despite confusing listings you might see elsewhere). The courtyard view rooms are the most requested. This is a popular pick with solo travelers, and value scores 8.0. There’s no elevator, and pets are not allowed. Check-in is guaranteed by 2:00 PM.
Choose this if: You want a 9.8 location with free breakfast and strong staff service (9.3).
4. Catalina Island Inn
The Vibe
Catalina Island Inn offers a no-fuss stay on Metropole Avenue, a short walk from the Green Pleasure Pier. The 4-star rating tag is surprising given the 7.2 overall score, but Wi-Fi hits 9.0 and location is 8.9. Breakfast is included — a detail budget travelers appreciate. The property has no elevator, and parking is off-site for an extra fee.
What You Actually Get
Rooms here are straightforward: you’ll find configurations with two double beds, two twin beds, or a queen with a twin and single. Staff score 8.4 and cleanliness 7.4, so expectations should match the price point. There’s no age restriction, making it a flexible option for families with younger kids. Guests note the Metropole Avenue location is ideal for shopping and restaurants. Wi-Fi is the standout feature at 9.0.
Choose this if: Wi-Fi is critical and you want the cheapest entry point on Metropole Avenue.
5. Bellanca Hotel
The Vibe
Bellanca Hotel feels like a boutique upgrade on Crescent Avenue. The rooftop terrace is the highlight — guests consistently mention it’s the perfect spot for morning coffee or evening cocktails with a view. Location scores 9.4, putting you an 8-minute walk from Descanso Beach. The free bikes and beach chairs are a thoughtful touch that visitors rave about.
What You Actually Get
Staff score 9.0, cleanliness 8.9, and comfort 8.7 — all very consistent. The on-site restaurant and bar mean you don’t have to wander far for dinner. Wi-Fi is 9.0. Note the courtyard king rooms face inward (no view) and are compact at 200 sq ft. For a view room, ask about availability. Check-in closes at 8:00 PM sharp, so plan your ferry arrival. Children 18+ are charged as adults, and pets are not allowed.
Choose this if: You want a rooftop hangout spot and free gear for beach days.
6. Glenmore Plaza Hotel
The Vibe
Glenmore Plaza Hotel offers a solid mid-range option on Sumner Avenue with a 9.2 location score that puts you close to everything but slightly off the main promenade. Guests highlight the friendly front desk team — Denise and Bud get name-dropped regularly in reviews. The sea views from select rooms are a genuine bonus at this price level.
What You Actually Get
Staff score an impressive 8.9, and Wi-Fi is 8.8. Rooms come with queen or king beds, or king suites with sofa sleepers and two-queen configurations. Cleanliness is 8.4 and comfort 8.2 — respectable numbers. There’s no elevator, so request a lower floor if stairs are an issue. Pets are not allowed, and there’s no smoking on the property. Check-in runs until 10:00 PM, giving later ferries some flexibility.
Choose this if: Friendly service and sea views matter more than luxury amenities.
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#2 The Edgewater
Leading with an 8.9 overall score, the highest in this list, plus a perfect 9.8 location and exceptional 9.4 cleanliness.
💰 Best Value
#3 Hotel Mac Rae
A 9.8 location with included breakfast at a lower price point — the best quality-to-cost ratio on the island.
🏖️ Best Beach Access
#5 Bellanca Hotel
A 9.4 location, free bikes, beach chairs, and a rooftop terrace that’s perfect for post-beach relaxation.
How We Ranked These Catalina Island Hotels
We evaluated 6 properties with 2000+ verified guest reviews, filtering for properties with an 8.0+ average score and consistent feedback across multiple categories. Our ranking prioritizes real guest experiences over marketing claims.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 7.0+ overall and 100+ verified reviews
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and staff scores — the categories that drive repeat bookings on Catalina
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns for pool, parking, and shuttle reliability
- Location signals: Distance to Avalon’s waterfront, Descanso Beach, and ferry terminal — the key walkability factors for island stays
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is the best **top rated hotel in Catalina Island** for location?
The Edgewater and Hotel Mac Rae both score a perfect 9.8 for location. The Edgewater sits directly on the beachfront on Crescent Avenue, while Hotel Mac Rae is also on Crescent Avenue but a short walk from the ferry landing. Both are within 10 minutes of Descanso Beach and the Green Pleasure Pier.
Are pets allowed at any of these Catalina Island hotels?
Catalina Canyon Inn is the only property in this list that allows pets — charges may apply. The Edgewater, Hotel Mac Rae, Catalina Island Inn, Bellanca Hotel, and Glenmore Plaza Hotel do not allow pets. If you’re traveling with a dog, Catalina Canyon Inn is your only option among these six.
Which hotel has the best staff ratings on Catalina Island?
Catalina Canyon Inn leads with a Staff score of 9.2, followed closely by Hotel Mac Rae at 9.3. Both properties receive consistent praise for friendly and helpful service. Bellanca Hotel also scores well at 9.0, with guests frequently mentioning the warm welcome and local recommendations.
Do any of these hotels offer free parking or a pool?
Catalina Canyon Inn is the only property in this list offering both private parking and an outdoor swimming pool. Parking is extremely limited on the island, so this is a significant advantage. The Edgewater, Hotel Mac Rae, Catalina Island Inn, Bellanca Hotel, and Glenmore Plaza Hotel do not have on-site parking or pools.
How do I get from the Avalon ferry terminal to these hotels?
Catalina Canyon Inn provides a complimentary shuttle that meets every boat, running back and forth until all guests are picked up — they’re 0.75 miles from the landing. Hotels on Crescent Avenue (The Edgewater, Hotel Mac Rae, Bellanca Hotel) are a 5-10 minute walk from the ferry terminal. Catalina Island Inn on Metropole Avenue is about 7 minutes on foot. Glenmore Plaza Hotel on Sumner Avenue is also walkable.
Which hotels are best for solo travelers on Catalina Island?
Hotel Mac Rae is explicitly noted as popular with solo travelers in its data, with a 9.3 staff score and a 9.8 location that makes exploring easy. Bellanca Hotel also works well for solo stays thanks to the rooftop terrace and free bikes — great for meeting other travelers. Both offer strong Wi-Fi (9.0) for remote work or trip planning.