The Old Colorado Inn tops Stuart’s luxury scene with a 9.6 rating, a 9.9 location score, and free private parking. For resort-style living, the Marriott Hutchinson Island Resort offers ocean views, a golf course, and a full marina. Both deliver on comfort and location in their own way.
Stuart’s luxury hotel scene blends historic inns with modern resorts, all within reach of the Treasure Coast’s best beaches and marinas.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 9 properties and over 2800+ total verified guest reviews to compile this list, with the average guest score sitting at 8.6/10 across the board.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Best overall luxury: #6 Old Colorado Inn→ Rates
- Top-rated modern: #4 Home2 Suites By Hilton Stuart→ Rates
#2 Comfort Suites Stuart-Hutchinson Island→ Rates - Best for resort amenities: #3 Marriott Hutchinson Island Resort→ Rates
- Best value luxury: #1 Best Western Downtown Stuart→ Rates
- Best waterfront vibe: #7 Pirate’s Cove Resort and Marina→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Best Western Downtown Stuart | (600+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. Comfort Suites Stuart-Hutchinson Island | (600+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Marriott Hutchinson Island Resort | (400+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Home2 Suites By Hilton Stuart | (300+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Hampton Inn & Suites Stuart-North | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Old Colorado Inn | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. Pirate’s Cove Resort and Marina | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 8. Holiday Inn Express Stuart by IHG | (100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 9. Courtyard by Marriott Stuart | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Detailed Reviews: Top Luxury Hotels in Stuart, FL
1. Best Western Downtown Stuart
The Vibe
This three-star hotel sits in the historic town center, just 15 minutes from the beach. Guests consistently praise the clean, spacious rooms and the breakfast that keeps getting refilled. The staff scores an 8.9, one of the highest for staff ratings on this list.
What You Actually Get
The outdoor swimming pool and fitness center are open seasonally. Free parking is included, which saves you at least $20 a night compared to beachfront properties. The complimentary breakfast is rated “very good” by guests. Wi-Fi scores an 8.9, so remote work is reliable. Pets are allowed with charges — call ahead to confirm fees. The restaurant on-site takes reservations, handy after a day exploring downtown Stuart. Check-in is from 4:00 PM, and you’ll need a photo ID and credit card upon arrival.
Choose this if: You want a central base with free parking and a solid breakfast, not beachfront views.
2. Comfort Suites Stuart-Hutchinson Island
The Vibe
A five-star-rated property (by guest scores) that earns a 9.6 for cleanliness and 9.4 for staff. The suites are well-designed, and the free American breakfast gets consistent praise. It’s a 15-minute drive to Stuart Beach.
What You Actually Get
The outdoor swimming pool is open and follows CDC guidelines. Free private parking is available on-site. Wi-Fi scores a 9.3, making it easy to stream or work. Each room includes a bathtub and air conditioning. The fitness center is open for guests. Note that pets are not allowed. Children 18 and over are charged as adults. Check-in starts at 4:00 PM. The property also offers multi-night stay discounts on occasion — ask at the front desk.
Choose this if: Cleanliness is your top priority — this scores 9.6, the second-highest on the list.
Check Tonight’s Price for Comfort Suites Stuart-Hutchinson Island →
3. Marriott Hutchinson Island Resort & Beach Villas, Golf & Marina
The Vibe
A full-scale resort on Hutchinson Island with direct ocean views, a golf course, and a marina. Staff score an 8.7, and the location is the property’s standout at 8.9. The rooms are spacious with big TVs and comfortable beds.
What You Actually Get
This is the only property on this list with an on-site golf course and marina. The 1 Bedroom Premium Condo offers direct oceanfront views. The Studio Suite Ocean View with 2 Queens is popular for families. There’s a restaurant open for breakfast, brunch, and lunch. Private parking is available for a fee. Pets are allowed with charges. Wi-Fi scores a 7.0 — weaker than most on this list, so plan for streaming needs. The fitness center is open. Check-out is until 11:00 AM.
Choose this if: You want a full resort experience with golf, marina, and ocean views — not just a hotel room.
Check Tonight’s Price for Marriott Hutchinson Island Resort & Beach Villas, Golf & Marina →
4. Home2 Suites By Hilton Stuart
The Vibe
This three-star property punches way above its weight with a 9.5 overall rating. Exceptional scores across the board — staff at 9.6, cleanliness at 9.8, and a perfect 10.0 for Wi-Fi. Guests rave about the huge, clean rooms and attentive staff.
What You Actually Get
Each room includes a kitchen with a microwave and apartment-sized refrigerator. Complimentary induction cooktops can be signed out from the front desk — great for cooking your own meals. The outdoor swimming pool is open. Free on-site parking is included. Pets are allowed with a one-time fee: $75 for 1-4 nights, $125 for 5+ nights. The complimentary breakfast is rated “excellent” by guests. There’s a fitness center and air conditioning. No age restriction for check-in. Check-in starts at 3:00 PM, earlier than most on this list.
Choose this if: You need reliable Wi-Fi and a kitchen — this property scores a perfect 10.0 in both categories.
5. Hampton Inn & Suites Stuart-North
The Vibe
A quiet, clean, and comfortable option in north Stuart. Guests mention how quiet the property is, and the staff scores an 8.6. Breakfast is polarizing — some love it, some find it limited. Location scores an 8.6, with easy access to the highway.
What You Actually Get
The outdoor swimming pool is heated in the winter. Free parking is available on-site. Pets are allowed with charges. There’s a restaurant on the property. The 24-hour front desk makes late check-ins easy. The complimentary breakfast is rated “very good” by the majority of guests, though some wish for more variety. Wi-Fi scores a 7.5 — functional but not as fast as the top properties. Check-in is from 3:00 PM. Children’s amusements like the Children’s Museum and Sailfish Splash Waterpark are about 10 minutes away.
Choose this if: You’re traveling with pets and need a quiet hotel with easy highway access.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hampton Inn & Suites Stuart-North →
6. Old Colorado Inn
The Vibe
The highest-rated property on this list at 9.6 overall. Staff scores a near-perfect 9.9, and location is also 9.9. This historic hotel offers a garden view, a terrace, and a pool with a view. Guests walk everywhere downtown.
What You Actually Get
Free private parking is a huge perk in downtown Stuart. There’s a common laundry room with washer and dryer — free for guests. The terrace and pool area offer garden and pool views. The on-site restaurant and bar are open. Wi-Fi scores a perfect 10.0. Pets are not allowed. Check-in is from 3:00 PM to 10:00 PM — note the 10:00 PM cutoff. There’s no extra charge for a second guest in the same suite. Beach chairs and towels are provided. Easy parking and walkable to downtown shops and dining.
Choose this if: You value historic character and top-tier service — this has the highest staff score on the list.
7. Pirate’s Cove Resort and Marina – Stuart
The Vibe
Located on the Manatee Pocket waterway, 10 miles from Bathtub Reef. This resort offers river views, a terrace, and free private parking. Wi-Fi scores a 9.5, and staff is at 8.8. Guests love the recent updates and the on-site restaurant and bar.
What You Actually Get
The outdoor swimming pool is open. The on-site restaurant and bar serve food. Free private parking is available. Pets are allowed on request — only a limited number of pet-friendly rooms exist, and there’s only one set of adjoining pet-friendly rooms (a king and a double queen). Fishing charters operate from the marina. Wi-Fi scores a 9.5. No age restriction for check-in. Check-out starts as early as 6:00 AM — handy for early departures. The property has been recently updated, according to guest feedback.
Choose this if: You want a waterfront resort vibe with marina access and river views.
Check Tonight’s Price for Pirate’s Cove Resort and Marina – Stuart →
8. Holiday Inn Express Stuart by IHG
The Vibe
Sitting right off I-95, this three-star hotel is convenient for travelers passing through or stopping for the night. Cleanliness scores an 8.6, and the location is also 8.6. Guests mention feeling safe traveling alone here.
What You Actually Get
Free parking is available on-site. The outdoor swimming pool is open. The fitness center is available for guests. A “good breakfast” is included. Note that gluten-free options are limited, per guest feedback. Pets are not allowed. Groups booking more than 6 rooms have different policies. A damage deposit of $100 is required at check-in. The property is located 28 miles from Rapids Water Park and 30 miles from Fort Pierce City Marina. Check-out is until 11:00 AM.
Choose this if: You need a safe, convenient stop right off the highway with free parking and breakfast.
Check Tonight’s Price for Holiday Inn Express Stuart by IHG →
9. Courtyard by Marriott Stuart
The Vibe
A comfortable Marriott off I-95 with an 8.8 staff score. Guests praise the exceptional breakfast and the pleasant, helpful staff. The location is rated 8.3, and the property offers outdoor swimming and BBQ facilities.
What You Actually Get
The outdoor swimming pool is open. There are BBQ facilities on-site — rare for a chain hotel. Pets are allowed on request with a $75 non-refundable fee charged every seven days; stays under seven days pay a single $75 fee. Long-term stay discounts are available — ask at check-in. Free parking is included. There’s a restaurant on the property. No penthouse suites are available. No age restriction for check-in. Check-out is until 12:00 PM — later than most properties on this list. Wi-Fi is not scored in the data, so plan accordingly.
Choose this if: You’re planning a long stay with a pet and want BBQ facilities and a later check-out.
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#6 Old Colorado Inn
Near-perfect 9.6 rating with a 9.9 staff score and free downtown parking — luxury meets historic character.
💰 Best Value
#4 Home2 Suites By Hilton Stuart
9.5 overall rating, full kitchen, perfect Wi-Fi, and free parking — all at a three-star price point.
🏖️ Best Resort Experience
#3 Marriott Hutchinson Island Resort
Oceanfront villas, on-site golf course, and a full marina — the most amenities of any property here.
Check Tonight’s Price for Marriott Hutchinson Island Resort & Beach Villas, Golf & Marina →
How We Ranked These Luxury Hotels in Stuart, FL
We evaluated 9 properties and over 2,800 verified guest reviews from the Stuart area, focusing on properties with guest scores above 7.5 and at least 50 reviews. Our ranking prioritizes real traveler feedback over marketing claims.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 7.5+ overall and 50+ verified reviews
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and staff scores — the categories that drive luxury repeat bookings
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns for accuracy
- Location signals: Distance to Hutchinson Island beaches, downtown Stuart walkability, and marina access
Frequently Asked Questions
Which luxury hotels in Stuart, FL have the highest guest ratings?
The Old Colorado Inn leads with a 9.6 rating, followed by Home2 Suites By Hilton Stuart at 9.5 and Comfort Suites Stuart-Hutchinson Island at 9.3. All three have 200+ reviews, so the scores are statistically reliable.
Are pets allowed at these Stuart luxury hotels?
Yes, several properties allow pets. Best Western Downtown Stuart, Marriott Hutchinson Island Resort, Home2 Suites By Hilton Stuart, Hampton Inn & Suites Stuart-North, Pirate’s Cove Resort and Marina, and Courtyard by Marriott Stuart all accept pets, typically with additional fees. Comfort Suites and Old Colorado Inn do not allow pets.
What’s the best time to visit Stuart, Florida?
Winter and spring (December through April) offer the most comfortable temperatures, with highs in the 70s. Summer can be hot and humid, but it’s also the off-season with lower rates. Hurricane season runs from June through November.
Which Stuart hotels offer the best beach access?
The Marriott Hutchinson Island Resort sits closest to the ocean on Hutchinson Island itself. Comfort Suites is about a 15-minute drive from Stuart Beach. Old Colorado Inn provides beach chairs and towels but isn’t within walking distance — the closest beach requires a short drive.
How do I get from Palm Beach International Airport to Stuart?
Palm Beach International Airport (PBI) is about 37 miles from most Stuart properties. A rental car is the most convenient option — all hotels on this list offer free or paid on-site parking. Rideshare services like Uber and Lyft are available but can cost $60-$90 each way.
Which Stuart hotels have the best cancellation policies?
Cancellation and prepayment policies vary by accommodation type and season at all properties. Generally, booking directly or through flexible-rate options gives you more cancellation freedom. The Old Colorado Inn and Home2 Suites typically offer more lenient policies than the resort properties.