Agriturismo Incanto della Natura leads with a flawless 10.0 staff and Wi-Fi score. For a converted monastery experience, Convento di Acqua Premula’s 9.9 staff rating and 9.8 cleanliness make it a close second. Both redefine Umbrian luxury.
Forget Tuscany’s crowds — Umbria’s hilltop monasteries and farmhouse stays deliver better scores and deeper silence.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 3800+ verified guest reviews across 7 Umbrian properties to compile this list, prioritizing those with an average 9.0/10 guest score and 10+ verified reviews minimum.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Best overall score: #7 Agriturismo Incanto della Natura→ Rates
- Best for castle vibes: #2 Castello di Baccaresca→ Rates
- Best value: #1 Hotel Del Lago 1934 & SPA→ Rates
#4 La Chiusetta→ Rates - Best for families: #6 Casale Rancaglia→ Rates
- Cleanest stays: #5 Convento di Acqua Premula→ Rates
#7 Agriturismo Incanto della Natura→ Rates - Pet-friendly (free): #6 Casale Rancaglia→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Hotel Del Lago 1934 & SPA | (900+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. Castello di Baccaresca | (750+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Abbazia Collemedio Resort & Spa | (700+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. La Chiusetta | (500+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Convento di Acqua Premula | (450+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Casale Rancaglia | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. Agriturismo Incanto della Natura | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Umbria’s Best Hotels: Full Reviews with Guest Scores
1. Hotel Del Lago 1934 & SPA
The Vibe
This 3-star lakeside property delivers an 8.1 overall with a standout 9.1 location score on the shores of Piediluco. Guests rave about the “romantic view of the lake” and the Mount Terminillo backdrop from the terrace. It’s the budget-friendly base for exploring the Basilica di San Francesco, just nearby, with free parking to boot.
What You Actually Get
Rooms are non-smoking with family-sized options, and the free private parking is a major plus for road-trippers. The on-site restaurant serves breakfast included in bookings, and the private beach area provides direct lake access — rare at this price point. The wellness path (90-minute spa session) is included per room, though you’ll want to book ahead since access is shared. Cleanliness scores 8.4, adequate for a quick stop. Note: no pets allowed, and check-in runs until 10:30 PM only.
Choose this if: You want lakefront access and included spa perks without paying 4-star prices.
2. Castello di Baccaresca
The Vibe
A 14th-century castle with a 9.1 staff score and 9.3 cleanliness rating — this is Umbrian history done right. The pool overlooks the valley, and guests call the property “magical with breathtaking views.” It’s a 10-minute taxi from Fossato di Vico/Gubbio station, but you’ll want a car for exploring.
What You Actually Get
This 4-star property features an extensive garden, outdoor swimming pool, and an excellent breakfast (included). Rooms combine stone walls with modern comforts, scoring 9.1 on comfort. The on-site restaurant serves dinner, and room service is available. Pets are allowed on request with charges. Staff speaks English, Spanish, and French — useful for international guests. The castle even has a resident donkey and Bruno the dog, as guests note. Cleanliness at 9.3 is the top score here, above even the 8.7 location.
Choose this if: You want a castle stay with 9.0+ cleanliness and valley pool views near Gubbio.
3. Abbazia Collemedio Resort & Spa
The Vibe
A converted Franciscan monastery sitting on a hilltop in Collazzone. Scores are uniformly excellent: staff at 9.3, facilities at 9.1, and cleanliness at 9.4. Guests describe it as “a real luxury retreat” surrounded by forest. The location score of 9.0 confirms its perch above the Umbrian countryside.
What You Actually Get
The outdoor pool, fitness center, and spa (by reservation only) make this a wellness destination. Rooms are non-smoking with tea/coffee makers, and the very good breakfast is included. Free private parking is available on-site, and the property accepts pets on request at €10 per day. The nearest train station is Perugia Fontivegge — a private transfer or taxi is recommended from there. Unlike #2, which uses original castle architecture, Abbazia leans into monastic serenity with forest trails right outside. Solo travelers rate this place highly.
Choose this if: You value 9.4 cleanliness and want a spa retreat in a former monastery.
4. La Chiusetta
The Vibe
Guests call this “magical” — the garden filled with lemon and orange trees sets a romantic scene. With an 8.8 overall and a 9.1 staff score, La Chiusetta sits in the countryside 10 minutes from Orvieto’s famed Duomo. The 9.1 comfort score means beds and rooms deliver beyond its 3-star rating.
What You Actually Get
This 3-star property punches above its class with an outdoor pool, free parking, and family rooms. The restaurant offers Italian, gluten-free, and buffet options — book in advance by phone. Rooms are non-smoking with free WiFi (7.7, adequate for basic use). There’s a good breakfast included, and the property accommodates guests with disabilities. No pets allowed here. The key catch: you need a private car or taxi — no public transport serves this location. Check-in stretches until 11:30 PM, rare flexibility for late arrivals.
Choose this if: You want a romantic countryside stay near Orvieto with a pool and late check-in.
5. Convento di Acqua Premula
The Vibe
Near-perfect scores everywhere: 9.8 cleanliness, 9.7 comfort, 9.6 facilities. The staff hit 9.9, and guests specifically name Giuseppe as “enthusiastically accommodating.” This converted convent in Sellano offers “supremely peaceful” stays with a seasonal pool. The 9.5 location score confirms it’s fully immersed in Umbrian hills.
What You Actually Get
Rooms come with air conditioning (confirmed in guest Q&A) and tea/coffee makers. The outdoor swimming pool allows children only with parents present. Free parking is on-site, and room service is available. Pets are allowed on request with charges. The restaurant serves wonderful breakfasts included in the rate. Wi-Fi scores 8.0 — usable but not streaming-grade. The property provides wellness packages and a solarium, and all rooms have tea/coffee makers. Unlike #7’s private-suite pools, this pool is shared — but the peace and staff attention are unmatched.
Choose this if: You prioritize staff warmth and near-perfect cleanliness — this scores 9.8, matching the top in this best hotel in Umbria list.
6. Casale Rancaglia
The Vibe
Andrea and his mother run this Gubbio farmhouse with a 9.9 staff score and guests raving about “delicious food” and helpful area tips. The 9.6 cleanliness and 9.6 comfort scores make it one of the top-performing properties here. It’s family-run, and it shows in every review.
What You Actually Get
The 4-star property features an outdoor seasonal pool, restaurant open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and a garden. Free private parking is on-site. The standout policy: pets stay free with no extra charges — unique among this entire list. Family rooms are available, and the wonderful breakfast is included. Wi-Fi scores 7.0 — expect adequate speeds for messaging but not video calls. A washing machine is available in a common area for guests, a huge plus for longer stays. Note: when booking 3+ rooms, different policies apply.
Choose this if: You’re traveling with pets and want family-run warmth with 9.6 comfort scores.
7. Agriturismo Incanto della Natura
The Vibe
The top-scoring property in Umbria: 9.7 overall with perfect 10.0 scores in staff, Wi-Fi, and value. Guests call it the “perfect place to disconnect” with extremely comfortable beds and a relaxing pool. The 9.6 location score places it near Assisi with landmark and garden views from the suites.
What You Actually Get
This 4-star agriturismo offers 5 suites, each with a private pool — confirmed in guest Q&A. The term “private pool” means exclusive use per suite, not a shared facility. Air conditioning is in all rooms. The wonderful breakfast includes Italian and American options. Free parking and airport shuttle are available. Family rooms accommodate children (18+ charged as adults). Wi-Fi at 10.0 means reliable remote work capability — unique in Umbria. No pets allowed. The solarium and wellness packages add extra relaxation. Note the tight check-in window (3:00 PM–6:00 PM) — plan your arrival carefully.
Choose this if: You want Umbria’s highest-rated best hotel in Umbria experience with a private pool and flawless staff.
Check Tonight’s Price for Agriturismo Incanto della Natura →
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#7 Agriturismo Incanto della Natura
Perfect 10.0 in staff, Wi-Fi, and value, plus a private pool per suite — nothing in Umbria scores higher.
Check Tonight’s Price for Agriturismo Incanto della Natura →
💰 Best Value
#1 Hotel Del Lago 1934 & SPA
Private beach access and included spa at a 3-star price — unmatched value on the lake.
👨👩👧 Best for Families
#6 Casale Rancaglia
Free pet stays, family rooms, a washing machine, and a 9.6 comfort score for everyone.
How We Ranked These Umbria Hotels
To find the best hotel in Umbria, I evaluated 7 properties using 3800+ verified guest reviews, filtering for properties with an 8.0+ overall score and 10+ reviews minimum. The criteria prioritize the scores that matter most to repeat bookers.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 8.0+ overall and 10+ verified reviews
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and value — the categories that drive repeat bookings
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns
- Location signals: Proximity to Assisi, Gubbio, Orvieto, and the Basilica di San Francesco — Umbria’s key destinations
Frequently Asked Questions
Are pets allowed at these Umbria hotels?
Yes, but policies vary. Casale Rancaglia (#6) stands out with free pet stays and no extra charges. Castello di Baccaresca (#2), Abbazia Collemedio Resort & Spa (#3), and Convento di Acqua Premula (#5) allow pets on request with applicable fees (€10/day at Abbazia). Hotel Del Lago, La Chiusetta, and Agriturismo Incanto della Natura do not permit pets. Always confirm pet policies directly when booking.
Which hotels offer free cancellation in Umbria?
Cancellation policies vary by accommodation type and date for all properties on this list. Hotel Del Lago (#1), Castello di Baccaresca (#2), and Abbazia Collemedio (#3) require you to check conditions for each room option during booking. Agriturismo Incanto della Natura (#7) and La Chiusetta (#4) also vary by stay dates. Always review the specific cancellation terms before confirming your reservation — many offer free cancellation within a window.
What’s the best time to visit Umbria?
Late spring (May–June) and early autumn (September–October) are ideal for Umbria. Temperatures range 20–28°C, perfect for outdoor pools at properties like Castello di Baccaresca (#2) and Convento di Acqua Premula (#5). July and August bring heat and more tourists, though the hilltop locations of Abbazia Collemedio (#3) and Agriturismo Incanto della Natura (#7) remain cooler. Winter visits offer solitude but many pools close seasonally.
How do I get to Umbria from Rome’s airports?
Most properties recommend flying into Rome (FCO or CIA) or Perugia Airport. Hotel Del Lago (#1) is closest to Rome’s airports at 83 km from CIA. For Abbazia Collemedio (#3), take a train to Perugia Fontivegge station, then a private transfer or taxi. Castello di Baccaresca (#2) is 10 minutes from Fossato di Vico/Gubbio station by taxi. La Chiusetta (#4) requires a private car — no public transport serves it. Renting a car is strongly recommended for exploring Umbria’s countryside properties.
Which Umbria hotels have private pools?
Agriturismo Incanto della Natura (#7) offers a private pool for each of its 5 suites — confirmed in guest Q&A. Other properties feature shared outdoor pools: Castello di Baccaresca (#2), Abbazia Collemedio Resort & Spa (#3), La Chiusetta (#4), Convento di Acqua Premula (#5), and Casale Rancaglia (#6) all have seasonal outdoor swimming pools. Hotel Del Lago (#1) provides lake access via a private beach instead of a pool.
Which Umbria hotel is best for remote work?
Agriturismo Incanto della Natura (#7) leads with a perfect 10.0 Wi-Fi score — reliable enough for video calls and streaming. Abbazia Collemedio (#3) follows with 8.2 Wi-Fi, suitable for basic tasks. Convento di Acqua Premula (#5) scores 8.0 Wi-Fi. For the most consistent connection, book Agriturismo Incanto della Natura, but note the tight 3:00 PM–6:00 PM check-in window requires planning arrival times carefully.