20 Fishers Indiana Hotel with Pool | & Indoor Swim

Searching for a Fishers Indiana hotel with a pool means finding a spot that works for downtime after work or play. Here are the top picks ranked by guest reviews.

Why Trust This Guide

I analyzed 20 properties and over 5,700 total verified guest reviews to compile this list, prioritizing cleanliness scores and location ratings for an average guest score of 8.2/10.

Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.

Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay

Property Rating Gallery Best For Book
1. Drury Plaza Hotel Indianapolis Carmel 9.2/10 – Wonderful
(1000+ Reviews)
Indoor/Outdoor Pool & Staff Check Rates
2. Drury Inn & Suites Indianapolis Northeast 9.0/10 – Wonderful
(900+ Reviews)
Outdoor Pool & Pet Friendly Check Rates
3. Candlewood Suites Indianapolis Northeast by IHG 7.3/10 – Good
(400+ Reviews)
Kitchen & Indoor Pool Check Rates
4. Baymont by Wyndham Noblesville 7.0/10 – Good
(350+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & Jacuzzi Rooms Check Rates
5. Comfort Inn & Suites Fishers – Indianapolis 8.2/10 – Very Good
(300+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & Location Check Rates
6. Comfort Inn Indianapolis East 7.6/10 – Good
(200+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & Quiet Area Check Rates
7. Indianapolis Marriott East 7.7/10 – Good
(200+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & Restaurant Check Rates
8. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Indianapolis North – Carmel by IHG 8.7/10 – Excellent
(200+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & Cleanliness Check Rates
9. Holiday Inn Express Indianapolis – Fishers by IHG 7.4/10 – Good
(150+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & Balcony Rooms Check Rates
10. SpringHill Suites Indianapolis Carmel 7.8/10 – Good
(150+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & Free Bikes Check Rates
11. Renaissance Indianapolis North Hotel 8.7/10 – Excellent
(150+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & On-Site Starbucks Check Rates
12. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Indianapolis – East by IHG 8.9/10 – Excellent
(150+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & Exceptional Breakfast Check Rates
13. Hampton Inn and Suites Indianapolis-Fishers 8.3/10 – Very Good
(150+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & Location Check Rates
14. Hilton Garden Inn Indianapolis Northeast/Fishers 8.5/10 – Very Good
(150+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & On-Site Bar Check Rates
15. Hampton Inn Indianapolis Northeast/Castleton 7.3/10 – Good
(150+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & Pet Friendly Check Rates
16. Courtyard by Marriott Indianapolis Castleton 8.3/10 – Very Good
(150+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & On-Site Bar Check Rates
17. Hampton Inn & Suites Indianapolis-Keystone, IN 9.0/10 – Wonderful
(100+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & Keystone Location Check Rates
18. Fairfield Inn & Suites Indianapolis East 8.1/10 – Very Good
(100+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & Hot Tub Check Rates
19. Best Western Fishers Indianapolis Area 8.0/10 – Very Good
(100+ Reviews)
Kitchenette & Fishers Location Check Rates
20. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Westfield – Indianapolis by IHG 8.8/10 – Excellent
(50+ Reviews)
Indoor Pool & Facilities Check Rates

Detailed Reviews: 20 Fishers Indiana Hotels with Pool: The Full Review

1. Drury Plaza Hotel Indianapolis Carmel

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: North Meridian St, near the Children’s Museum of Indianapolis 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 9.2/10 – Wonderful (1000+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Staff 9.6/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type – check conditions
  • Standout: Indoor/outdoor pool plus whirlpool

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness9.5
  • Location9.4
  • Comfort9.5
  • Staff9.6
  • Value9.1
  • Facilities9.5
  • Wi-Fi9.4

The Vibe

This 3-star property tops the list with a 9.2/10 rating and scores of 9.5 for both cleanliness and comfort. Guests rave about the friendly professional staff (9.6) and the spacious, well-maintained rooms. The indoor/outdoor pool and whirlpool are a standout feature, open year-round for families and solo travelers alike.

What You Actually Get

Every room includes free WiFi rated 9.4, and the property offers free private parking, a fitness center, and a very good breakfast included in the rate. Upper floors are accessible by elevator, and the on-site restaurant takes reservations for dinner. The 9.5 facilities score reflects the quality of the pool area and common spaces. Unlike some nearby hotels, the Drury also provides complimentary evening snacks and drinks, which guests frequently highlight.

💡 Insider Tip: Request a top-floor room facing away from Meridian Street for the quietest stay – these rooms are quieter despite the pool area.
Why We Love It: The indoor/outdoor pool setup works in any Indiana weather.

Choose this if: You want a reliable, staff-driven experience with a unique pool – the 9.4 location score puts the Children’s Museum nearby.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Drury Plaza Hotel Indianapolis Carmel

2. Drury Inn & Suites Indianapolis Northeast

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: North Shadeland Avenue, near I-465 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 9.0/10 – Wonderful (900+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Staff 9.4/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Outdoor swimming pool & pet-friendly policy

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness9.3
  • Location8.9
  • Comfort9.2
  • Staff9.4
  • Value8.9
  • Facilities9.2
  • Wi-Fi9.3

The Vibe

Another strong performer from the Drury chain, this location scores 9.3 for both cleanliness and WiFi, with staff earning 9.4. The outdoor swimming pool is the main draw for warmer months, complemented by an excellent breakfast included in the rate. Free on-site parking sweetens the deal for road-trippers.

What You Actually Get

Rooms come with private bathrooms and the hotel features a fitness center. The 8.9 value score is fair given the included breakfast and pet-friendly policy (dogs under 35 lbs accepted with a fee). WiFi is strong at 9.3, and the location puts you 15 miles from the Indianapolis Motor Speedway. A damage deposit of $50 applies at check-in, refundable upon inspection.

💡 Insider Tip: Book the Kickback reception for complimentary drinks and snacks – it’s included but often overlooked.
Why We Love It: That 9.4 staff score means real service, not just check-in pleasantries.

Choose this if: You’re bringing a dog and want an outdoor pool – this is one of the few pet-friendly pool hotels in the area.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Drury Inn & Suites Indianapolis Northeast

3. Candlewood Suites Indianapolis Northeast by IHG

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: Bash Street, off I-69 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 7.3/10 – Good (400+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Staff 8.6/10
  • Check-in: From 4:00 PM to 12:00 AM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Full kitchen in suites

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness7.9
  • Location8.2
  • Comfort8.0
  • Staff8.6
  • Value7.8
  • Facilities7.4
  • Wi-Fi6.2

The Vibe

This all-suite hotel scores 8.6 for staff and 8.2 for location, with an indoor swimming pool available year-round. The kitchen-equipped suites (microwave, mini-fridge, and stovetop) make longer stays practical. Value sits at 7.8, reasonable for the amenities offered.

What You Actually Get

Every room includes a full kitchen with an oven and fridge – the data confirms “just an oven, no stove.” Free parking and a fitness center are on-site. The indoor pool is a plus for winter visits. Note that WiFi scores 6.2, which is lower than other properties here. Pets are allowed for an extra fee ($25 for 1-6 nights, $75 for 7+). One-bedroom suites have a separate living area with a sofa bed.

💡 Insider Tip: The 24-hour guest laundry means you can pack light – useful for multi-week stays.
Why We Love It: Kitchen-equipped suites at this price point are a rarity near Fishers.

Choose this if: You need a kitchen for extended stays and want a budget-friendly indoor pool option.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Candlewood Suites Indianapolis Northeast by IHG

4. Baymont by Wyndham Noblesville

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: Prosperity Drive, Noblesville 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 7.0/10 – Good (350+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Location 8.1/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Jacuzzi tubs available in deluxe rooms

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness7.6
  • Location8.1
  • Comfort7.5
  • Staff7.6
  • Value7.2
  • Facilities7.3
  • Wi-Fi8.0

The Vibe

Located in Noblesville (just north of Fishers), this 2-star property scores 8.0 for WiFi and 8.1 for location. The indoor swimming pool is open to guests, and some rooms feature jacuzzi tubs – ask for the deluxe category. Staff scores 7.6, and cleanliness is 7.6, meaning expectations should be calibrated to “budget-friendly.”

What You Actually Get

All rooms include a microwave and refrigerator (confirmed by guest Q&A), a good breakfast included in the rate, and free WiFi. The hotel offers a shuttle service to concerts via a third-party provider ($20 per person round trip). Pets are allowed on request with potential fees. A $150 refundable deposit is required at check-in.

💡 Insider Tip: Sign up for the concert shuttle early – it’s independent of the hotel and fills up fast for Klipsch Music Center events.
Why We Love It: Jacuzzi tubs for under $100? Yes, they exist in the deluxe rooms.

Choose this if: You’re on a strict budget but still want an indoor pool and jacuzzi option in Noblesville.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Baymont by Wyndham Noblesville

5. Comfort Inn & Suites Fishers – Indianapolis

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: North by Northeast Boulevard, Fishers 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 8.2/10 – Very Good (300+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Location 8.9/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Indoor swimming pool & newly remodeled

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness8.7
  • Location8.9
  • Comfort8.8
  • Staff8.7
  • Value8.2
  • Facilities8.4
  • Wi-Fi8.7

The Vibe

A solid mid-range pick with 8.2/10 overall and 300+ reviews. The location scores 8.9, putting it close to dining and the Ruoff Music Center (12 minutes away). The indoor pool, fitness center, and complimentary breakfast make it a comfortable base for exploring Fishers. Guests specifically praise the walk-in showers and quiet rooms.

What You Actually Get

This 4-star property was remodeled in 2022 and reopened early 2023. Rooms feature key card access, free WiFi (8.7), and free private parking. An indoor swimming pool is available year-round. Pets are not allowed here – a common restriction among the Fishers properties. Seniors love the walk-in showers, and the 8.7 staff score suggests attentive service. A $200 refundable deposit is required at check-in.

💡 Insider Tip: Book a room on the north side for the quietest experience – it faces the business park, not the highway.
Why We Love It: The combination of a recent remodel, indoor pool, and strong location score makes this a reliable choice.

Choose this if: You’re looking for a Fishers Indiana hotel with a pool that’s clean, quiet, and within driving distance to the Ruoff Music Center.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Comfort Inn & Suites Fishers – Indianapolis

6. Comfort Inn Indianapolis East

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: North Shadeland Avenue, Indianapolis East 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 7.6/10 – Good (200+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Cleanliness 8.6/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Enter dates for conditions
  • Standout: Indoor swimming pool & quiet location

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness8.6
  • Location8.1
  • Comfort8.5
  • Staff8.2
  • Value8.0
  • Facilities8.1
  • Wi-Fi8.5

The Vibe

This 4-star property scores 8.6 for cleanliness and 8.5 for WiFi – both above average for the price point. Guests consistently note how quiet the hotel is despite being near major highways. The indoor pool is open, but there’s no hot tub (confirmed in guest Q&A). A solid option for rest stops or short stays.

What You Actually Get

Free on-site parking, fitness center, and a good breakfast included in the rate. The hotel has no age restriction for check-in, which is helpful for younger travelers (a parent consent form required under 21). Rollaway beds are available in limited quantities. The 8.2 staff score reflects early check-in flexibility mentioned by guests. Pets are not allowed.

💡 Insider Tip: Request a top-floor room to minimize any highway noise – guests confirm the upper floors are quietest.
Why We Love It: Cleanliness score of 8.6 at this price is rare – housekeeping clearly prioritizes thorough work.

Choose this if: You need a quiet, clean room near I-70 with an indoor pool and no age minimum.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Comfort Inn Indianapolis East

7. Indianapolis Marriott East

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: East 21st Street, Indianapolis East 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 7.7/10 – Good (200+ reviews)
  • Top Score: WiFi 8.5/10
  • Check-in: From 4:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Enter dates for conditions
  • Standout: Indoor pool & on-site restaurant

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness8.4
  • Location7.9
  • Comfort8.3
  • Staff8.4
  • Value7.4
  • Facilities7.8
  • Wi-Fi8.5

The Vibe

This 3-star Marriott scores 8.5 for WiFi and 8.4 for staff, with an indoor swimming pool that guests seem to enjoy. The on-site restaurant and very good breakfast add convenience. Rooms are clean (8.4), and the 8.3 comfort score suggests solid bedding and furnishings. A solid option for business travelers or families wanting a familiar brand.

What You Actually Get

All rooms have air conditioning and private bathrooms. The property offers a fitness center, bar, and very good breakfast. Pets are allowed with possible fees – call ahead to confirm. There are no jacuzzi tubs in any rooms (confirmed in guest Q&A). The location is 9 miles from Lucas Oil Stadium and the Children’s Museum. Check-in starts at 4:00 PM, later than many competitors.

💡 Insider Tip: The restaurant server Kelly gets rave reviews – sit in her section if you can.
Why We Love It: A full-service hotel with an indoor pool and restaurant means you don’t have to leave the property.

Choose this if: You want a Marriott-standard indoor pool and full dining options without leaving the hotel.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Indianapolis Marriott East

8. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Indianapolis North – Carmel by IHG

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: North Michigan Road, Carmel 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 8.7/10 – Excellent (200+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Cleanliness 9.1/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Enter dates for conditions
  • Standout: Indoor pool & top-tier breakfast

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness9.1
  • Location8.7
  • Comfort9.0
  • Staff8.7
  • Value8.5
  • Facilities8.8
  • Wi-Fi9.0

The Vibe

Scoring 8.7/10 with 200+ reviews, this property excels in cleanliness (9.1) and comfort (9.0). Guests call the breakfast the “best hotel breakfast” they’ve ever had. The indoor pool is a key feature, and the WiFi scores 9.0 – strong enough for streaming. A clear step up from typical Holiday Inn Express standards.

What You Actually Get

Free parking, fitness center, and included breakfast. Some rooms have pullout sofa beds for kids. Service animals are allowed but pets are not. Note that the property is undergoing renovation and guests may experience noise during daytime hours. The 8.7 location score places you near the Indianapolis Motor Speedway (11 miles) and Lucas Oil Stadium (13 miles).

💡 Insider Tip: Check for noise if the renovation is ongoing – request a room away from any construction zones.
Why We Love It: A 9.1 cleanliness score and breakfast guests gush about – hard to beat at this price.

Choose this if: You prioritize an immaculate room and a standout breakfast, with an indoor pool as the cherry on top.

9. Holiday Inn Express Indianapolis – Fishers by IHG

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: North by Northeast Boulevard, Fishers 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 7.4/10 – Good (150+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Location 8.6/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Indoor pool & balcony suites

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness7.9
  • Location8.6
  • Comfort7.9
  • Staff8.2
  • Value7.4
  • Facilities7.5
  • Wi-Fi6.7

The Vibe

This 3-star property scores 8.6 for location and 8.2 for staff, with an indoor pool that guests confirm is open even in October. The hotel features a fitness center and good breakfast included. Some suites offer balcony spaces – a nice touch for fresh Indiana air. Staff friendliness is above average at 8.2.

What You Actually Get

Free private parking, elevator access to upper floors, and WiFi (6.7 – weaker than competitors). The 7.5 facilities score reflects the pool and gym setup. All rooms are non-smoking. Pets are not allowed. The 7.9 cleanliness score is decent, and the location makes it easy to reach downtown Indianapolis or the Ruoff Music Center.

💡 Insider Tip: Request a balcony suite on check-in – they’re limited and not bookable online, but available first-come.
Why We Love It: Balcony rooms are a rarity in the Fishers hotel scene – great for fresh air.

Choose this if: You want an indoor pool in Fishers and prefer a room with outdoor balcony access.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Holiday Inn Express Indianapolis – Fishers by IHG

10. SpringHill Suites Indianapolis Carmel

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: North Meridian Street, Carmel 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 7.8/10 – Good (150+ reviews)
  • Top Score: WiFi 9.4/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Free bikes & indoor pool

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness8.3
  • Location8.9
  • Comfort8.3
  • Staff8.8
  • Value8.0
  • Facilities8.2
  • Wi-Fi9.4

The Vibe

This 3-star property scores 8.9 for location and 8.8 for staff, with an indoor swimming pool and free bikes for guests. The WiFi score of 9.4 is the highest among these properties – perfect for remote work. Rooms are large and clean, with separate sink areas outside the bathroom. A solid choice for travelers who want to explore Carmel’s trails.

What You Actually Get

Free parking, fitness center, and very good breakfast included. Air conditioning and bathtubs are available in select rooms. The hotel offers both two-queen and one-king room configurations. The 8.2 facilities score includes the pool and gym. Pets are not allowed. The location north of downtown makes it easy to access both Fishers and Carmel dining.

💡 Insider Tip: Use the free bikes to ride the Monon Trail – it connects Carmel to Fishers directly.
Why We Love It: Free bikes plus an indoor pool means you can swim or ride on the same trip.

Choose this if: You want fast WiFi (9.4) and an indoor pool with free bike access for exploring.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for SpringHill Suites Indianapolis Carmel

11. Renaissance Indianapolis North Hotel

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: North Meridian Street, Carmel 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 8.7/10 – Excellent (150+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Cleanliness 9.3/10
  • Check-in: From 4:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Enter dates for conditions
  • Standout: On-site Starbucks & indoor pool

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness9.3
  • Location9.2
  • Comfort9.1
  • Staff9.0
  • Value8.5
  • Facilities9.1

The Vibe

A 4-star property scoring 8.7 overall with top marks for cleanliness (9.3) and facilities (9.1). The indoor pool is open year-round, and the on-site Starbucks is a major convenience. Staff score 9.0, and the 9.2 location score reflects easy access to both Carmel and Fishers. Elevators are fast, and rooms include refrigerators with small freezer sections.

What You Actually Get

Free private parking, fitness center, and wonderful breakfast available. The hotel’s restaurant is open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. All rooms include a refrigerator – confirmed by guest Q&A. Handicap accessible rooms with roll-in showers are available. The 8.5 value score is fair for a 4-star property with these amenities. Pets are not allowed.

💡 Insider Tip: Grab a Starbucks before hitting the pool – the location inside the lobby opens early.
Why We Love It: Starbucks on-site plus a 9.3 cleanliness score makes mornings smoother.

Choose this if: You want a premium 4-star experience with an indoor pool and hot coffee steps from your room.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Renaissance Indianapolis North Hotel

12. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Indianapolis – East by IHG

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: Western Select Drive, Indianapolis East 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 8.9/10 – Excellent (150+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Comfort 9.4/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Indoor pool & exceptional breakfast

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness9.3
  • Location8.9
  • Comfort9.4
  • Staff9.3
  • Value8.8
  • Facilities9.2

The Vibe

Scoring 8.9 overall with 150+ reviews, this property tops the comfort category at 9.4. Staff (9.3), cleanliness (9.3), and facilities (9.2) all rate excellent. The indoor pool is listed, though state guidelines may affect availability – check during booking. The exceptional breakfast is a major draw, with guests praising the variety.

What You Actually Get

Free parking, fitness center, and an exceptional breakfast included. Available rooms include options with two queen beds. The 8.8 value score is strong. The location is 12 miles from Indianapolis Motor Speedway and convenient to the Children’s Museum. Pets are not allowed. Note that the pool may be closed depending on local health guidelines.

💡 Insider Tip: The exceptional breakfast includes make-your-own pancakes and fresh fruit – fuel up before heading to the pool.
Why We Love It: A 9.4 comfort score means the beds are genuinely great for sleeping.

Choose this if: You want top-tier comfort and an indoor pool with a breakfast that rivals Sunday brunch.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Holiday Inn Express & Suites Indianapolis – East by IHG

13. Hampton Inn and Suites Indianapolis-Fishers

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: Commercial Drive, Fishers 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 8.3/10 – Very Good (150+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Location 9.3/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Indoor pool & highway access

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness8.6
  • Location9.3
  • Comfort8.9
  • Staff9.0
  • Value7.9
  • Facilities8.2

The Vibe

This 3-star Hampton Inn scores 9.3 for location – tied for the best in this guide. Guests love the easy highway access and proximity to restaurants. The indoor pool is available, and the exceptional breakfast is included. Staff score 9.0, and comfort is rated 8.9. A reliable pick for Fishers visitors who prioritize convenience.

What You Actually Get

Free parking, fitness center, and exceptional breakfast included. WiFi scores 10.0 according to the data – the fastest in this roundup. Pets are allowed with a non-refundable fee ($75 for 1-4 nights, $125 for 5+). Note that the entire property is scheduled for renovation from February to June 2026, with work done from 8 AM to 6 PM daily.

💡 Insider Tip: Book early for the renovation period – rates may drop, but call ahead to confirm access to the pool.
Why We Love It: A 9.3 location score with an indoor pool, plus pet-friendly policy in Fishers.

Choose this if: You want an indoor pool and top-rated location in Fishers – the 9.3 location score is the best in town.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Hampton Inn and Suites Indianapolis-Fishers

14. Hilton Garden Inn Indianapolis Northeast/Fishers

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: North by Northeast Boulevard, Fishers 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 8.5/10 – Very Good (150+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Staff 9.3/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM to 11:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Indoor pool & on-site bar

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness9.0
  • Location9.1
  • Comfort8.9
  • Staff9.3
  • Value8.3
  • Facilities8.8

The Vibe

Scoring 8.5 overall, this Hilton Garden Inn excels in staff (9.3) and location (9.1). The indoor pool is confirmed open and ready for swimming. The on-site restaurant and bar make it easy to dine without leaving the hotel. Guests love the location near Fishers restaurants and the short drive to downtown Indianapolis (10 minutes).

What You Actually Get

Free parking, fitness center, and very good breakfast included (or available for €10). The hotel’s restaurant serves breakfast and dinner. WiFi scores 10.0. Pets are allowed with possible fees. Check-in requires a 21+ age with photo ID. The 9.0 cleanliness score is above average for this price tier. The 8.3 value score reflects the added restaurant and bar amenities.

💡 Insider Tip: The bar serves dinner nightly – perfect if you arrive after a long drive and don’t want to head back out.
Why We Love It: A 9.3 staff score plus an indoor pool and bar – everything you need in one spot.

Choose this if: You want a Fishers Indiana hotel with a pool, plus an on-site bar and staff that consistently deliver great service.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Hilton Garden Inn Indianapolis Northeast/Fishers

15. Hampton Inn Indianapolis Northeast/Castleton

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: East 82nd Street, Castleton 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 7.3/10 – Good (150+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Staff 8.7/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM to 11:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Enter dates for conditions
  • Standout: Indoor pool & pet-friendly

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness8.3
  • Location8.5
  • Comfort8.2
  • Staff8.7
  • Value8.1
  • Facilities7.5
  • Wi-Fi8.5

The Vibe

This 3-star Hampton Inn scores 8.7 for staff – a highlight for this property. The indoor pool is available, and the hotel is pet-friendly with a $50 one-time fee. WiFi scores 8.5, and the location is rated 8.5. A budget-friendly option for travelers bringing their dogs.

What You Actually Get

Free on-site parking, fitness center, and breakfast included. Note that standard rooms do not include a microwave and refrigerator – check your specific room type. The hotel requires a 21+ age for check-in. Pets are allowed with a $50 fee. The 7.5 facilities score suggests the pool and gym are functional but not luxurious.

💡 Insider Tip: Standard rooms lack microwaves – if you need one, request a room upgrade or book a suite.
Why We Love It: A pet-friendly indoor pool hotel with a $50 one-time fee is hard to beat in this market.

Choose this if: You’re traveling with a dog and need an indoor pool in the Castleton area.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Hampton Inn Indianapolis Northeast/Castleton

16. Courtyard by Marriott Indianapolis Castleton

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: Allisonville Road, Castleton 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 8.3/10 – Very Good (150+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Location 9.1/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Indoor pool & on-site restaurant

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness8.9
  • Location9.1
  • Comfort8.8
  • Staff8.8
  • Value8.2
  • Facilities8.8

The Vibe

This 3-star Marriott scores 8.3 overall with a 9.1 location score – excellent for Castleton shopping and dining. The indoor pool is available, though some guests noted it was out of service during their stay. Staff (8.8), facilities (8.8), and cleanliness (8.9) all rate well. The on-site restaurant and bar add convenience.

What You Actually Get

Free on-site parking, fitness center, and a good breakfast included (or available for €10). The hotel features a garden and shared lounge area. Air conditioning is standard in all rooms. Pets are not allowed. The 8.2 value score reflects the restaurant and pool amenities. Check-out is at 12:00 PM – later than many competitors.

💡 Insider Tip: Call ahead to confirm pool availability – guest reviews mention occasional maintenance closures.
Why We Love It: The 9.1 location score puts you in the center of Castleton’s shopping scene.

Choose this if: You want an indoor pool walking distance to Castleton restaurants and the fashion mall.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Courtyard by Marriott Indianapolis Castleton

17. Hampton Inn & Suites Indianapolis-Keystone, IN

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: River Crossing Boulevard, Keystone 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 9.0/10 – Wonderful (100+ reviews)
  • Top Score: WiFi 9.5/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Indoor pool & Keystone location

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness9.3
  • Location9.3
  • Comfort9.3
  • Staff9.2
  • Value8.4
  • Facilities9.1
  • Wi-Fi9.5

The Vibe

Scoring 9.0/10 with 100+ reviews, this is one of the highest-rated properties in the guide. Cleanliness (9.3), comfort (9.3), and facilities (9.1) all rate excellent. The indoor pool is available, and the WiFi scores 9.5. Guests describe it as one of the “nicest Hamptons” they’ve stayed at – a testament to the 9.2 staff score.

What You Actually Get

Free private parking, fitness center, and good breakfast included. The location is 11 miles from downtown Indianapolis (30 minutes by car) and 10 miles from the airport. No shuttle from the airport is available. Pets are allowed on request with potential fees. There are no rooms with jacuzzi tubs. The 8.4 value score reflects the premium Hampton Inn experience.

💡 Insider Tip: Parking is free and abundant – perfect if you’re driving in and exploring Keystone at the Crossing.
Why We Love It: A 9.0 rating with a 9.5 WiFi score and indoor pool – everything works well here.

Choose this if: You want a top-rated indoor pool experience in the Keystone area with fast WiFi for work.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Hampton Inn & Suites Indianapolis-Keystone, IN

18. Fairfield Inn & Suites Indianapolis East

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: East 21st Street, Indianapolis East 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 8.1/10 – Very Good (100+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Staff 8.7/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Indoor pool & hot tub

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness8.4
  • Location8.7
  • Comfort8.5
  • Staff8.7
  • Value8.3
  • Facilities8.2

The Vibe

This 3-star Fairfield Inn scores 8.1 overall with a standout 8.7 staff score. Guests specifically mention the “awesome” hot tub – a rare amenity in this guide. The indoor pool is available, and the hotel offers a good breakfast included. A great pick for families who want both a pool and hot tub after a day of exploring.

What You Actually Get

Free on-site parking, fitness center, and good breakfast included. The hotel has facilities for disabled guests and non-smoking rooms. WiFi scores 7.5 – lower than some competitors. Pets are not allowed. The 8.3 value score is reasonable given the hot tub and pool access. Check-out is at 12:00 PM.

💡 Insider Tip: The hot tub is a guest favorite – head down early evening before families take over.
Why We Love It: An indoor pool AND a hot tub at this price point is a rare find near Indianapolis.

Choose this if: You want an indoor pool plus a hot tub – the best combo for relaxation on this list.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Fairfield Inn & Suites Indianapolis East

19. Best Western Fishers Indianapolis Area

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: North By Northeast Blvd, Fishers 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 8.0/10 – Very Good (100+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Location 8.8/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Kitchenette & outdoor pool

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness8.5
  • Location8.8
  • Comfort8.4
  • Staff8.5
  • Value7.9
  • Facilities8.0
  • Wi-Fi8.3

The Vibe

This 3-star Best Western scores 8.0 overall with an 8.8 location score – prime Fishers location off I-69. The outdoor pool is temporarily closed (verify at booking). Rooms in the king suite include a kitchenette with sink and microwave. Guests praise the wonderful pillows and fast check-in process.

What You Actually Get

Free parking, fitness center, and continental breakfast included. All rooms offer a microwave and mini-fridge. The king suite adds a kitchenette with a sink. WiFi scores 8.3. Pets are allowed – dogs under 45 pounds only, with a $30 per night fee. The 8.5 staff and cleanliness scores reflect good housekeeping and friendly service.

💡 Insider Tip: The king suite with a kitchenette is worth the upgrade for longer stays – you can prep meals and save on dining.
Why We Love It: A kitchenette in Fishers with an outdoor pool and pet-friendly policy – versatility at a fair price.

Choose this if: You need a kitchenette and prefer an outdoor pool, plus you’re traveling with a small dog.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Best Western Fishers Indianapolis Area

20. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Westfield – Indianapolis by IHG

At a Glance

  • Type: Hotel
  • Area: Sunny Drive, Westfield 📍 View on map
  • Rating: 8.8/10 – Excellent (50+ reviews)
  • Top Score: Facilities 9.4/10
  • Check-in: From 3:00 PM
  • Cancellation: Varies by room type
  • Standout: Indoor pool & spotless facilities

Guest Scores

  • Cleanliness9.2
  • Location9.1
  • Comfort9.2
  • Staff9.2
  • Value8.6
  • Facilities9.4

The Vibe

A newer 2-star property (50+ reviews) scoring 8.8/10 – the highest-rated among the budget-tier properties. Facilities (9.4), cleanliness (9.2), and comfort (9.2) all rate excellent. The indoor pool is a key feature, and guests love the “amazing smell” and cleanliness throughout the hotel. Staff score 9.2 as well.

What You Actually Get

Free private parking, fitness center, and buffet breakfast included. Upper floors accessible by elevator. The location is 23 miles from Lucas Oil Stadium – best for travelers exploring the Westfield area. The 8.6 value score reflects the high quality for the price. No pet or age restrictions according to the data. A solid choice farther north of Indianapolis.

💡 Insider Tip: Book directly for the best value – as a newer property, rates are competitive and quality is still peak.
Why We Love It: A 9.4 facilities score and indoor pool in a budget property – exceptional value.

Choose this if: You want a pristine indoor pool experience in the Westfield area with top scores for facilities and cleanliness.

✓ Live rate check across booking sites✓ No signup needed

Check Tonight’s Price for Holiday Inn Express & Suites Westfield – Indianapolis by IHG

Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks

🏆 Best Overall

#1 Drury Plaza Hotel Indianapolis Carmel

The 9.2/10 rating, unique indoor/outdoor pool with whirlpool, and 9.6 staff score make this the clear winner for families and couples alike.

Check Tonight’s Price for Drury Plaza Hotel Indianapolis Carmel

💰 Best Value

#5 Comfort Inn & Suites Fishers – Indianapolis

An 8.2/10 rating with a newly remodeled indoor pool, 8.9 location score in Fishers, and included breakfast at a mid-range price point.

Check Tonight’s Price for Comfort Inn & Suites Fishers – Indianapolis

🏖️ Best Pool & Hot Tub Combo

#18 Fairfield Inn & Suites Indianapolis East

One of the few properties with both an indoor pool AND a hot tub, plus an 8.7 staff score and included breakfast.

Check Tonight’s Price for Fairfield Inn & Suites Indianapolis East

How We Ranked These Hotels

I evaluated 20 properties with over 5,700 total verified guest reviews, focusing on properties that clearly feature an indoor or outdoor swimming pool. The average guest score across all properties is 8.2/10, ensuring quality across the board.

  • Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 7.0+ overall and 50+ verified reviews
  • Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and staff scores – the categories that define the pool experience
  • Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised pool access against guest review patterns to confirm availability
  • Location signals: Proximity to Fishers town center, Interstate 69, and major attractions like the Ruoff Music Center

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Fishers Indiana hotels have an indoor pool open year-round?

Several properties feature indoor pools open year-round. Comfort Inn & Suites Fishers (H5) has an indoor pool and was remodeled in 2022. Hampton Inn and Suites Indianapolis-Fishers (H13) offers an indoor pool with an exceptional breakfast. Hilton Garden Inn Indianapolis Northeast/Fishers (H14) confirms their indoor pool is open. The Holiday Inn Express Indianapolis – Fishers (H9) also confirmed their pool operates into October. Always call ahead during winter or renovation periods to confirm availability.

Are there any pet-friendly hotels with pools near Fishers?

Yes. Drury Inn & Suites Indianapolis Northeast (H2) allows pets and has an outdoor pool. Hilton Garden Inn Indianapolis Northeast/Fishers (H14) allows pets and has an indoor pool. Hampton Inn Indianapolis Northeast/Castleton (H15) is pet-friendly with a $50 fee and offers an indoor pool. Best Western Fishers (H19) accepts dogs under 45 pounds with a $30 nightly fee and has an outdoor pool (temporarily closed). Each property applies separate charges, so confirm fees at booking.

What’s the best time to visit Fishers for swimming?

Indoor pool hotels like Comfort Inn & Suites Fishers, Drury Plaza, and the Renaissance North work year-round. For outdoor swimming, Drury Inn Northeast and Best Western are seasonal (Memorial Day through Labor Day typically). Summer months (June-August) offer the most pool options, but indoor pools remain open through fall and winter. October is still fine for indoor swimming, as confirmed by Holiday Inn Express Fishers.

Which hotels near Fishers offer free cancellation?

Most properties in this guide have cancellation policies that vary by room type and date. Drury Plaza Hotel Carmel (H1), Drury Inn Northeast (H2), and Hampton Inn Suites Fishers (H13) all offer flexible cancellation options on select rates. For the best flexibility, choose a “free cancellation” rate during the booking process. Properties like Candlewood Suites (H3) may have stricter policies for longer stays.

How far are these hotels from downtown Indianapolis?

Fishers properties are approximately 15-20 minutes from downtown Indianapolis. Comfort Inn & Suites Fishers (H5) is about 12 minutes from the Ruoff Music Center and 20 minutes from Lucas Oil Stadium. Hampton Inn Suites Fishers (H13) is 18 miles from Lucas Oil Stadium. The Drury Plaza in Carmel (H1) sits 11 miles from the Children’s Museum and about 25 minutes from downtown. Keystone area hotels like Hampton Inn (H17) are 11 miles from downtown (30 minutes by car).

Can I check in late at any of these Fishers hotels?

Yes. Most properties offer 24-hour front desk service or late check-in windows. Candlewood Suites (H3) accepts check-in until 12:00 AM. Hampton Inn Castleton (H15) and Hilton Garden Inn Fishers (H14) accept check-in until 11:00 PM. Drury Plaza (H1) allows check-in until 11:00 PM as well. For arrivals after midnight, it’s best to call ahead and inform the property – most will hold your reservation with a credit card guarantee.