SpringHill Suites by Marriott Canfield tops the Boardman area with a 9.6 cleanliness score and 9.7 facilities rating. For couples on a budget, Travelodge by Wyndham Hubbard OH delivers 8.1/10 value with staff scores hitting 9.1.
Whether you’re passing through on I-80 or visiting family near Canfield, these options cut through the noise.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 20 properties and 4700+ total verified guest reviews to compile this list, prioritizing cleanliness scores 8.5+ and an average guest score of 8.2/10 across the selected hotels.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Highest cleanliness: #12 Home2 Suites By Hilton Youngstown→ Rates
#20 SpringHill Suites Canfield→ Rates - Best for pets (dogs): #9 Hampton Inn Youngstown-North→ Rates
#12 Home2 Suites Youngstown→ Rates - Best location: #6 Best Western Plus Boardman Inn→ Rates
#8 Doubletree Youngstown Downtown→ Rates - Best value: #7 Travelodge Hubbard OH→ Rates
#11 Davis Motel→ Rates - Top luxury overall: #20 SpringHill Suites Canfield→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Super 8 by Wyndham Youngstown/Austintown | (650+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. Wingate Suites by Wyndham Youngstown – Austintown | (550+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Comfort Suites-Youngstown North | (450+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Sleep Inn Austintown – Youngstown, West | (400+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Quality Inn & Suites North Lima – Boardman | (350+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Best Western Plus Boardman Inn & Suites | (300+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. Travelodge by Wyndham Hubbard OH | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 8. Doubletree By Hilton Youngstown Downtown | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 9. Hampton Inn Youngstown-North | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 10. Best Western Penn-Ohio Inn & Suites | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 11. Davis Motel | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 12. Home2 Suites By Hilton Youngstown | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 13. Holiday Inn Youngstown-South – Boardman by IHG | (100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 14. Hampton Inn Youngstown/Boardman | (100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 15. Holiday Inn Express Salem by IHG | (100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 16. Hampton Inn & Suites Youngstown-Canfield | (100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 17. Courtyard by Marriott Youngstown Canfield | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 18. Fairfield Inn & Suites Youngstown Boardman Poland | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 19. Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites Youngstown – North Lima/Boardman by IHG | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 20. SpringHill Suites by Marriott Canfield | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Detailed Reviews: Top-Rated Hotels in Boardman, Ohio
1. Super 8 by Wyndham Youngstown/Austintown
The Vibe
This 1-star property keeps things simple but scores an 8.1 on value and 8.2 on Wi-Fi. It’s 21 miles from The Links at Firestone Farms, making it a solid base for travelers sticking near Youngstown’s southern edge without paying for frills.
What You Actually Get
All rooms come with a refrigerator and microwave — confirmed by staff. The continental breakfast is included, and there’s a fitness center for a quick morning workout. Pets are allowed on request with a $12 per pet per night fee. Late check-in is possible with advance permission. Reviewers consistently note the staff’s willingness to accommodate, with an 8.3 staff score backing that up. The free parking on site removes one headache for road trippers arriving late.
Choose this if: You’re passing through on a budget and traveling with a small pet — the pet fee won’t sting.
Check Tonight’s Price for Super 8 by Wyndham Youngstown/Austintown →
2. Wingate Suites by Wyndham Youngstown – Austintown
The Vibe
Guests rave about “very large rooms” with separate bedroom and TV areas. The 8.8 staff and location scores make it a reliable choice for business travelers or families needing space. The indoor pool is temporarily closed, so check before counting on a swim.
What You Actually Get
Rating 8.0/10, this 3-star hotel offers free Wi-Fi scoring 9.4, a fitness center, and continental breakfast included. The free private parking on site is a bonus for those with vehicles. Pets are allowed on request with a $25 pet fee per reservation (or $25 per pet per day, per conflicting Q&As — confirm at booking). The property is 21 miles from Firestone Farms, and reviewers note value despite ongoing renovations. The separate living area in suites is a highlight for longer stays.
Choose this if: You want a separate living zone without upgrading to a full suite hotel.
Check Tonight’s Price for Wingate Suites by Wyndham Youngstown – Austintown →
3. Comfort Suites-Youngstown North
The Vibe
Repeat guests — some staying for a decade — call this a “quiet and safe” spot convenient to I-80 with decent nearby restaurants. The heated indoor pool is open, and the staff scores 8.6, keeping travelers coming back.
What You Actually Get
This 4-star property scores 8.1 overall with an 8.8 location score. The buffet breakfast is included, and the fitness center adds value for regular exercisers. Note that pets are not allowed, so leave the dog at home. The property has 3 jacuzzi suites available only through direct booking — call the hotel to reserve one. Reviewers highlight the staff friendliness and convenience to the highway, making it a consistent pick for east-west travelers.
Choose this if: You’re a repeat road warrior who values consistency and a hot breakfast before the next leg.
4. Sleep Inn Austintown – Youngstown, West
The Vibe
An 8.7 staff score and pet-friendly policy set this 4-star property apart at a 7.3 overall rating. It’s 21 miles from Firestone Farms and offers an indoor swimming pool. The free parking and breakfast included keep costs low for families on the move.
What You Actually Get
This hotel scores 7.3 overall but reaches 8.1 on value. Guests get free Wi-Fi (8.0), air conditioning, and an indoor swimming pool. Pets are allowed with charges that may apply. The property is conveniently located near both Cleveland Hopkins (60 mi) and Pittsburgh (50 mi) airports. Breakfast is included in the price, and the on-site parking is free. The staff’s 8.7 score is the standout here — reviewers mention helpful check-in even during late arrivals.
Choose this if: You need a pet-friendly stop with swimming access for the kids without blowing the budget.
Check Tonight’s Price for Sleep Inn Austintown – Youngstown, West →
5. Quality Inn & Suites North Lima – Boardman
The Vibe
Located on Market Street in North Lima, this 4-star property scores 8.0 on cleanliness and 8.3 on comfort. The staff’s 8.7 rating is the headline, and the “more than adequate” breakfast gets positive mentions from guests. It’s 7.2 miles from Firestone Farms.
What You Actually Get
This pet-friendly hotel allows pets with applicable charges. Guests get free Wi-Fi (8.5), free parking, and access to a fitness center. The good breakfast included starts the day right. Reviewers note the comfortable beds and quiet rooms despite proximity to Turnpike. The property is a 100% non-smoking facility. Early check-in may be available in summer — call first to check availability. The combination of staff warmth and solid comfort scores makes this a reliable pick.
Choose this if: You want a pet-friendly hotel with genuinely helpful staff near the Turnpike.
Check Tonight’s Price for Quality Inn & Suites North Lima – Boardman →
6. Best Western Plus Boardman Inn & Suites
The Vibe
Guests describe this as feeling like a “luxury hotel that a Best Western” — it’s that good. The 9.1 location score is the highest in the list, and the 8.9 cleanliness score proves it’s well-maintained. It’s 11 miles from Firestone Farms.
What You Actually Get
This 3-star property scores 8.4 overall with near-perfect staff (9.0) and cleanliness (8.9) scores. The indoor swimming pool and fitness center are open. Free private parking is included, plus an excellent breakfast. The location in Poland puts you close to Boardman shopping and dining — reviewers note it’s quiet despite being central. Pets are not allowed. Check-in runs until 11:30 PM, giving late arrivals flexibility.
Choose this if: You prioritize location and want the best walking access to Boardman’s dining and retail.
Check Tonight’s Price for Best Western Plus Boardman Inn & Suites →
7. Travelodge by Wyndham Hubbard OH
The Vibe
This 2-star hotel punches above its weight with an 8.1 overall rating and an 8.8 value score. Staff hit 9.1, and reviewers mention they “offered to help load my car” while traveling with an infant. Cleanliness scores 8.7.
What You Actually Get
The Travelodge in Hubbard features a shared lounge, terrace, restaurant, and bar. Breakfast is included in the price, and free on-site parking is available. Pets are not allowed here. The value score of 8.8 is one of the highest on this list, meaning you get solid quality without paying a premium. The property’s location on Truck World Boulevard is convenient for those traveling near the Pennsylvania border.
Choose this if: You want the best bang-for-buck near the Ohio-Pennsylvania line.
Check Tonight’s Price for Travelodge by Wyndham Hubbard OH →
8. Doubletree By Hilton Youngstown Downtown
The Vibe
This 4-star hotel scores 8.8 overall with a 9.4 cleanliness rating — the highest on this list for that category. The downtown location also scores 9.4. Guests note the “beautiful” property and welcoming front desk even during late-night arrivals.
What You Actually Get
The Doubletree offers a restaurant on site, a fitness center, and free Wi-Fi (8.5). Breakfast is available for $18 (optional). Parking is available in a surface lot or parking garage behind the hotel for $12 per day. The property features an elevator and key card access. Pets are not allowed. The 9.4 location score puts you in the heart of downtown Youngstown, with concierge services available.
Choose this if: You want downtown access and the most spotless rooms in the area.
Check Tonight’s Price for Doubletree By Hilton Youngstown Downtown →
9. Hampton Inn Youngstown-North
The Vibe
“Friendly front desk, efficient, clean, thin walls” sums up the honest guest feedback. The 9.1 staff score is top-tier, and the location scores 8.8 for easy highway access. It’s 26 miles from Firestone Farms.
What You Actually Get
This 3-star hotel is dog-friendly only (no cats) with a $50 pet fee. The indoor swimming pool and fitness center are available. Free Wi-Fi (8.8) and breakfast included in the price. Free on-site parking is provided. The $50 damage deposit is required at check-in. Reviewers mention thin walls as a downside, so request a top floor if quiet matters. The staff’s 9.1 score suggests consistent service quality.
Choose this if: You’re traveling with a dog and need reliable staff and free breakfast.
10. Best Western Penn-Ohio Inn & Suites
The Vibe
Guests call the breakfast “great” and note “staff was very helpful.” The 8.3 overall rating pairs with an 8.1 value score. It’s 31 miles from Firestone Farms, located in Hubbard near the Pennsylvania line.
What You Actually Get
This 3-star hotel offers an indoor swimming pool, fitness center, and very good breakfast included. Free Wi-Fi (8.5) and free on-site parking are standard. Check-in starts at 2:00 PM — earlier than most competitors. Pets are not allowed. The property is well-rated for cleanliness (8.5) and location (8.8). The earlier check-in time makes it convenient for travelers arriving before standard 3 PM.
Choose this if: You have an early arrival and want a solid breakfast before continuing your trip.
Check Tonight’s Price for Best Western Penn-Ohio Inn & Suites →
11. Davis Motel
The Vibe
This 2-star motel near I-76 is 10 minutes from Evans Lake. The 8.9 staff score is exceptional for the price point, and the 8.5 value score confirms you’re getting a deal. Guests love the “goodie bag of drinks and snacks” provided by staff.
What You Actually Get
The Davis Motel offers free Wi-Fi (2.5 — the lowest on this list, so expect weak signal) and free parking. There’s a restaurant next door (currently closed), but nearby dining is available. Pets are allowed on request; for small dogs (~10 lbs), there may be no extra charge. The motel’s location just off I-76 makes it a true road-trip stop. The 8.5 value score is one of the highest on the list, reflecting good quality at low rates.
Choose this if: You’re on a tight budget, value friendly service, and don’t need reliable Wi-Fi.
12. Home2 Suites By Hilton Youngstown
The Vibe
“For the price, you def get a bang for your buck,” says one guest. With a 9.0 overall rating, 9.6 cleanliness, and 9.3 location, this is the second-highest rated property in the list. It’s 21 miles from Firestone Farms.
What You Actually Get
This 3-star extended-stay property offers suites with pull-out sleeper sofas in every room — confirmed by staff. The indoor pool is heated (87-88°F). Pets are allowed with a $75 non-refundable fee (cats included). Free Wi-Fi (8.7), free parking, and a fitness center are on site. The 9.5 staff score indicates exceptional service. A $75 damage deposit is required at check-in.
Choose this if: You want the highest cleanliness standards and a pet policy that includes cats.
Check Tonight’s Price for Home2 Suites By Hilton Youngstown →
13. Holiday Inn Youngstown-South – Boardman by IHG
The Vibe
“Good facility. Great location close to everything,” says a guest. The Wi-Fi scores 9.5, and the location is 8.6. It’s located on South Avenue in Boardman, putting it close to shopping centers like Southern Park Mall.
What You Actually Get
This 3-star property offers free Wi-Fi (9.5), an indoor swimming pool, and a fitness center. The exceptional breakfast is included. Free on-site parking is available. Pets are not allowed. The hotel has 3 suite rooms with jacuzzis — call the property directly to reserve one. Upper floors are accessible by elevator. The location in Boardman puts you near restaurants and retail.
Choose this if: You need blazing-fast Wi-Fi and want to explore Boardman’s dining scene.
Check Tonight’s Price for Holiday Inn Youngstown-South – Boardman by IHG →
14. Hampton Inn Youngstown/Boardman
The Vibe
“Staff was very nice and rooms very clean,” says one guest who’d recommend it. The 9.4 staff score is among the highest on this list, and the comfort score of 9.0 promises a good night’s sleep.
What You Actually Get
This 3-star hotel offers an indoor swimming pool, fitness center, and exceptional breakfast included. Free on-site parking is available. Pets are allowed with charges that may apply. The property has one room with a walk-in shower (king bed) — request it if mobility is a concern. Check-in runs until 11:00 PM. The 8.8 cleanliness score and 9.0 comfort score make this a reliable pick for families.
Choose this if: You want a walk-in shower option and a breakfast that goes beyond basics.
15. Holiday Inn Express Salem by IHG
The Vibe
“Close by everything,” says a guest, noting the friendly reception staff. The 9.0 cleanliness and comfort scores are outstanding. It’s 10 miles from Firestone Farms and 16 miles from Alliance Amtrak Station.
What You Actually Get
This 2-star property (ratings often underrate Holiday Inn Express) offers an indoor swimming pool open 7 AM–11 PM, fitness center, and exceptional breakfast included. Free Wi-Fi and parking are available. Pets are allowed with charges. The $10 damage deposit is minimal. The location in Salem puts you close to local attractions while remaining budget-friendly. Guests love the coffee machine in the lobby — better than expected.
Choose this if: You want an excellent breakfast and a clean room without paying premium rates.
Check Tonight’s Price for Holiday Inn Express Salem by IHG →
16. Hampton Inn & Suites Youngstown-Canfield
The Vibe
“Proximity to restaurants. Very clean and comfortable!” says a guest. The Wi-Fi scores a perfect 10.0, and the location is 8.9. It’s 14 miles from Firestone Farms and 26 miles from Alliance Amtrak Station.
What You Actually Get
This 3-star property offers free Wi-Fi (10.0), an indoor swimming pool, and fitness center. The very good breakfast is included. Free on-site parking is available. Pets are not allowed. The location on Ironwood Boulevard puts you within walking distance of Canfield restaurants. The 8.9 cleanliness score is strong. Check-out is until 12:00 PM, giving you an extra hour compared to many competitors.
Choose this if: You need flawless Wi-Fi for work or streaming during your stay.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hampton Inn & Suites Youngstown-Canfield →
17. Courtyard by Marriott Youngstown Canfield
The Vibe
“New and clean in good location,” says a guest who loved the restaurant. The 8.7 overall rating pairs with 9.4 cleanliness and 9.4 location scores. The hot chocolate bar was a hit with families.
What You Actually Get
This 3-star Marriott property offers free Wi-Fi (9.5), an indoor swimming pool, and a restaurant open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Free parking is included. Pets are not allowed. The hotel offers free bikes for guests to explore the area. The 9.4 comfort score promises quality sleep. Located 14 miles from Firestone Farms, it’s a solid choice for stays near Canfield.
Choose this if: You want a full-service hotel with dining on-site and high cleanliness standards.
Check Tonight’s Price for Courtyard by Marriott Youngstown Canfield →
18. Fairfield Inn & Suites Youngstown Boardman Poland
The Vibe
Staff offered a “treasure (toy) to my kids from the treasure chest” — thoughtful touches make this place memorable. The 8.0 overall rating and 10.0 Wi-Fi score are the highlights.
What You Actually Get
This 3-star property offers free Wi-Fi (10.0), an indoor swimming pool (open, per staff), and a fitness center. Breakfast is included, and on-site parking is available. The property does not offer jacuzzi tub rooms. Located 11 miles from Firestone Farms, it offers express check-in/out. The staff’s pleasant attitude and kid-friendly approach make it a solid family pick.
Choose this if: You’re traveling with young children who appreciate small surprises at check-in.
Check Tonight’s Price for Fairfield Inn & Suites Youngstown Boardman Poland →
19. Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites Youngstown – North Lima/Boardman by IHG
The Vibe
This 2-star property on Market Street scores 7.3 overall but offers a perfect 10.0 Wi-Fi score. The standout feature is a single Whirlpool Suite with a jacuzzi — the only room with that amenity.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi (10.0), free parking, and a fitness center are included. The good breakfast is included. Upper floors are accessible by elevator. Pets are not allowed. The Whirlpool Suite is the only room with a jacuzzi — book directly and confirm availability. The location is near Firestone Farms (7.1 miles). Extended-stay corporate rates may be available — contact the property directly for details.
Choose this if: You need perfect Wi-Fi and want the only jacuzzi room in a budget-friendly property.
Check Tonight’s Price for Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites Youngstown – North Lima/Boardman →
20. SpringHill Suites by Marriott Canfield
The Vibe
“Very clean, quiet and nice — friendly helpful staff,” says one guest. With a 9.5 overall rating, 9.6 cleanliness, and 9.7 facilities, this is the highest-rated property in the entire list. It’s 14 miles from Firestone Farms.
What You Actually Get
This 3-star Marriott property offers an indoor swimming pool, fitness center, and excellent breakfast included. Free parking is on site. Pets are not allowed. The 9.6 staff and 9.5 location scores are remarkable. Barbecue facilities are available for guests. The 4:00 PM check-in is later than most, but the quality justifies the wait. Reviewers consistently mention super cleanliness and courteous staff.
Choose this if: You want the absolute best-rated hotel near Boardman and don’t mind a later check-in.
Check Tonight’s Price for SpringHill Suites by Marriott Canfield →
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#20 SpringHill Suites by Marriott Canfield
The highest-rated property in the list (9.5) with a 9.6 cleanliness score and 9.7 facilities — nothing else comes close in quality.
Check Tonight’s Price for SpringHill Suites by Marriott Canfield →
💰 Best Value
#7 Travelodge by Wyndham Hubbard OH
An 8.1 overall rating with an 8.8 value score is the best quality-to-price ratio in this lineup, plus staff scores 9.1.
Check Tonight’s Price for Travelodge by Wyndham Hubbard OH →
🐕 Best Pet-Friendly
#12 Home2 Suites By Hilton Youngstown
9.0 overall, 9.6 cleanliness, and accepts both dogs and cats with a $75 fee — the best pet policy in the list.
Check Tonight’s Price for Home2 Suites By Hilton Youngstown →
How We Ranked These Ohio Hotels
I evaluated 20 properties near Boardman, Ohio using 4700+ verified guest reviews, filtering for cleanliness scores 8.5+ and overall ratings 8.0+ where possible. The average guest score across all selected properties is 8.2/10.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 7.3+ overall and 50+ verified reviews made the cut
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, staff, and location — the categories that matter most for transient stays
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities (pools, pet policies, breakfast) against guest review patterns for accuracy
- Location signals: Proximity to I-80/I-76, Southern Park Mall, and downtown Youngstown for road trippers and visitors
Frequently Asked Questions
Which hotel in Boardman, Ohio accepts both dogs and cats?
Home2 Suites By Hilton Youngstown (property #12) accepts both dogs and cats with a $75 non-refundable pet fee. The heated indoor pool stays 87-88°F, and every room includes a pull-out sofa bed. Hampton Inn Youngstown-North (#9) accepts dogs only with a $50 fee. Several other properties like Wingate Suites (#2) and Super 8 (#1) allow pets on request with varying fees — always confirm at booking.
Which Boardman-area hotels offer free cancellation?
Most properties in this list have cancellation policies that vary by accommodation type and booking dates. Properties like Best Western Plus Boardman Inn & Suites (#6) and Doubletree By Hilton Youngstown Downtown (#8) typically offer flexible rates, but you’ll need to check your specific stay dates. We recommend filtering by “free cancellation” on Booking.com when you search to see which rates apply to your travel window.
What’s the best time of year to visit Boardman, Ohio?
Late spring (May-June) and early fall (September-October) offer the most comfortable temperatures for exploring the area, with highs in the 70s°F. Summer (July-August) is peak season for indoor pools at properties like Comfort Suites-Youngstown North (#3) and Holiday Inn Express Salem (#15). Winter travelers benefit from lower rates, though many indoor pools remain open. The area sees snow from December through February.
How far is Boardman from Pittsburgh International Airport?
Pittsburgh International Airport (PIT) is approximately 38-49 miles from Boardman-area hotels, depending on your exact location. Quality Inn & Suites North Lima (#5) and Davis Motel (#11) are closest at 38 miles each. Expect a 40-55 minute drive with normal traffic. Cleveland Hopkins International Airport (CLE) is about 60 miles northwest, roughly a one-hour drive.
Which hotels in Boardman, Ohio have the best breakfast?
Several properties offer excellent breakfast options. Best Western Plus Boardman Inn & Suites (#6) and Hampton Inn Youngstown/Boardman (#14) both offer “exceptional breakfast” per the data. SpringHill Suites by Marriott Canfield (#20) includes an excellent breakfast with its 9.5 overall rating. Best Western Penn-Ohio Inn & Suites (#10) is noted for “very good breakfast.” Holiday Inn Express Salem (#15) serves an exceptional breakfast at a budget-friendly price point.
Is there a hotel in Boardman, Ohio with a jacuzzi or whirlpool suite?
Yes — Comfort Suites-Youngstown North (#3) has 3 jacuzzi rooms available only through direct booking (ask for Mike Hicks at the front desk). Holiday Inn Youngstown-South – Boardman by IHG (#13) also has 3 suite rooms with jacuzzis, and Holiday Inn Express Hotel & Suites Youngstown – North Lima/Boardman (#19) has one single Whirlpool Suite. None of these can be booked online — you must call the property directly to reserve and confirm availability.