The Carriage House at Strasburg tops the list with a 9.4 rating and a flawless 9.7 for both staff and cleanliness. For a full-kitchen extended stay, Home2 Suites By Hilton Ephrata’s 9.2 overall and perfect 10.0 Wi-Fi score makes it a top contender. Amish Country lodging doesn’t get much better than these two.
Amish Country’s rolling farmland, horse-drawn buggies, and excellent hospitality make booking a hotel in East Earl, PA a simple decision—just pick the right fit.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 12 properties across the East Earl area, sifting through 3700+ total verified guest reviews to find hotels with an average guest score of 8.6/10 or higher.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Best Overall: #1 The Carriage House at Strasburg→ Rates
- Budget-Friendly: #9 Travelers Rest Motel→ Rates
- Pet-Friendly Pick: #5 Home2 Suites By Hilton Ephrata→ Rates
#10 Hampton Inn & Suites Intercourse→ Rates - Best for Couples: #8 The Inn at Leola Village→ Rates
- Highest Cleanliness: #1 The Carriage House at Strasburg→ Rates
#9 Travelers Rest Motel→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. The Carriage House at Strasburg | (550+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. Best Western Plus Intercourse Village Inn | (500+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Waynebrook Inn | (400+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Eastbrook Inn | (350+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Home2 Suites By Hilton Ephrata | (350+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Country Squire Inn and Suites | (300+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. Comfort Inn New Holland Amish Country | (250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 8. The Inn at Leola Village | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 9. Travelers Rest Motel | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 10. Hampton Inn & Suites Intercourse | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 11. VAAST Bed & Breakfast | (100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 12. Homestead Lodging | (40+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Full Hotel Reviews: Top Places to Stay in East Earl, PA Amish Country
1. The Carriage House at Strasburg
The Vibe
This is your classic Amish Country retreat: spotless rooms, a staff that’s genuinely warm (9.7), and a location that puts you steps from the Strasburg Rail Road. Guests rave about the “clean, comfortable rooms” and the free continental breakfast combined with a $16 voucher for the nearby restaurant.
What You Actually Get
Each room comes with a private bathroom featuring a shower/tub combo, and the complimentary breakfast is served each morning of your stay—guests confirm it’s included in the rate. The 9.6 Wi-Fi is among the fastest in the area, and the free private parking means you won’t hunt for a spot after a day at American Music Theatre Lancaster, just a short drive away. Note that children 18 and over are charged as adults, so families with nearly-grown teens should double-check the booking conditions.
Choose this if: You want the highest cleanliness and staff scores in East Earl—9.7 each, unmatched in this guide.
2. Best Western Plus Intercourse Village Inn
The Vibe
A solid 4-star with a 9.6 staff rating that mirrors the Carriage House. The indoor pool is heated to 83-85 degrees, and the jacuzzi stays at 101—guests confirm it’s a genuine draw after a day of exploring Amish markets.
What You Actually Get
The complimentary breakfast is mentioned positively by guests, though they note it requires a walk through the hallways to reach the breakfast area. The property offers a fitness center, free on-site parking, and a restaurant for dinner. Room types like the KDSJ come with a jacuzzi tub. Check-in runs until 11:30 PM, which is helpful for late arrivals. If you’re booking more than 9 rooms, different policies apply. The location scores a 9.5, and Spooky Nook Sports is nearby for sports fans.
Choose this if: You need a heated pool and jacuzzi on-site—this is the only hotel on the list with both confirmed by guests.
Check Tonight’s Price for Best Western Plus Intercourse Village Inn →
3. Waynebrook Inn
The Vibe
Waynebrook Inn is a budget-friendly option that’s about 25 minutes from White Chimney’s Estate. With a 7.3 overall, it’s the lowest-rated hotel on this list, but the 8.6 staff score and 8.5 location score show it’s not without merit. The garden and free private parking are appreciated by guests who book for nearby attractions.
What You Actually Get
Rooms come with free Wi-Fi (rated 8.5), and the on-site restaurant serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner. A pet fee of $25 per pet applies if you’re traveling with an animal. Some rooms include a spa tub that fits two people—confirm availability when booking. Check-in requires a phone call upon arrival, which is unusual, so plan accordingly. The property has a shared lounge and garden area, nice for a quiet evening.
Choose this if: You’re on a tight budget and need pet-friendly accommodations for a small fee.
4. Eastbrook Inn
The Vibe
Eastbrook Inn sits right in the heart of Amish country with a Location score of 8.8 and Staff at 8.8. It’s a 2-star property that feels welcoming, with a free continental breakfast that guests still praise. The landmark view adds a nice touch for first-time visitors to the area.
What You Actually Get
Each room includes an ironing board and iron, and the family rooms can accommodate up to 6 people—useful for groups. The free breakfast is continental-style, and the free parking on site is a plus. Free Wi-Fi scores 7.5, which is adequate for basic browsing. The property is close to American Music Theatre Lancaster and other area attractions.
Choose this if: You want a budget-friendly stay with a strong location in the heart of Ronks.
5. Home2 Suites By Hilton Ephrata
The Vibe
This is the extended-stay king of Amish Country. A perfect 10.0 Wi-Fi score, a 9.7 staff rating, and full kitchens in every suite make it a top pick for remote workers and families. The indoor pool and free hot breakfast round out the package.
What You Actually Get
Each suite comes with a fully equipped kitchen, making it ideal for longer stays. The brand-standard breakfast includes hot sandwiches, breakfast bowls, cereal, fresh fruit, and yogurt. The indoor swimming pool is open and available year-round. Pets are allowed with a $75 fee at check-in. The staff gets shoutouts by name (Kylie!) for their service. Free on-site parking and a fitness center complete the amenities. Note that groups of more than 9 rooms have different policies.
Choose this if: You need reliable Wi-Fi for work and a kitchen for cooking on an extended stay in East Earl, PA.
6. Country Squire Inn and Suites
The Vibe
A classic motel with a modern twist: guests get $24 meal vouchers—$24 per adult—for the attached café that serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Staff scores a strong 9.4, and the location at 9.2 puts you close to Shady Maple and other Amish Country highlights.
What You Actually Get
Adults receive vouchers for breakfast at the café next door—kids under 12 stay free when using existing bedding, though they don’t get the voucher. The property offers free parking and free Wi-Fi (8.6). Check-in is only until 8:00 PM, so plan your arrival accordingly. The restaurant is open for all meals and accepts reservations. A quiet location with a 9.0 comfort score makes it a restful option.
Choose this if: You want included breakfast with real restaurant vouchers, not a grab-and-go bag.
7. Comfort Inn New Holland Amish Country
The Vibe
Despite a 4-star label, the 7.2 guest rating places it lower on this list. The 8.6 Location score is its strongest asset, and the free breakfast includes eggs, sausage, fruit, cereal, and make-your-own waffles. The 24-hour front desk is convenient for late arrivals.
What You Actually Get
The breakfast buffet is a highlight—guests confirm it features hot items like eggs and sausage. The property has an elevator, a fitness center, and free parking on site. Free Wi-Fi scores 8.0. One handicap room is available on the first floor but has a regular bathtub, not a roll-in shower. Check-in requires guests to be 21 or older. Groups booking more than 5 rooms face different policies.
Choose this if: You need a budget-friendly 4-star with a hot breakfast and 24-hour front desk.
Check Tonight’s Price for Comfort Inn New Holland Amish Country →
8. The Inn at Leola Village, a Historic Hotel of America
The Vibe
This is the splurge-worthy choice on the list. A Historic Hotel of America with a 9.3 staff and cleanliness score, an outdoor pool open for summer, and a fine-dining restaurant. Guests call the rooms “beautiful, comfortable, and quiet” and mention discounts when issues arise.
What You Actually Get
The property offers a fitness center, garden, and bar alongside the restaurant. Breakfast is available for €13. Rooms in the newer building (suite 525 is mentioned positively) are spacious. First-floor rooms include Amos King, Poolside, and some Coach/Club rooms. Children are not allowed—this is an adults-only property for a quiet escape. Service animals are permitted, but no pets. Free on-site parking and the historic designation add to the appeal.
Choose this if: You’re an adults-only couple seeking a historic, quiet stay with an outdoor pool.
Check Tonight’s Price for The Inn at Leola Village, a Historic Hotel of America →
9. Travelers Rest Motel
The Vibe
Don’t let the 2-star label fool you—Travelers Rest Motel earns a 9.3 overall and a 9.7 staff score that ties for the best on this list. The 9.6 Location score and 9.2 Value score make it the smartest budget pick in Intercourse.
What You Actually Get
Each room includes a sitting area and a refrigerator, and guests praise the “clean, quiet, and comfortable” atmosphere. The free continental breakfast earns an “excellent” label from guests. Free Wi-Fi scores 9.4, among the highest on this list. Check-in closes at 9:00 PM, so late arrivals need to plan ahead. Extra cots for children are available for a charge. Smoking is allowed outside on the property. This is a classic Amish Country motel done right.
Choose this if: You’re a budget-conscious traveler who refuses to sacrifice cleanliness or staff warmth.
10. Hampton Inn & Suites Intercourse, Pa
The Vibe
A brand-new hotel in Intercourse with an 8.9 overall and a 9.4 Location score. Guests love the proximity to local restaurants—just a quick walk from the property. The indoor pool and complimentary breakfast are standard Hampton perks.
What You Actually Get
The hotel is pet-friendly with a nonrefundable charge: $75 for 1-4 nights, $125 for 5+ nights. The indoor swimming pool and fitness center are available. Free parking is included. Note that the queen studio suite is one open room rather than separated living/sleeping areas—good to know if you need privacy. The excellent breakfast is included, and the property is just 6.3 miles from Amish Farm and House.
Choose this if: You want a fresh, pet-friendly hotel in walking distance to Intercourse’s restaurants.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hampton Inn & Suites Intercourse, Pa →
11. VAAST Bed & Breakfast
The Vibe
This Victorian B&B in Adamstown is a time capsule of charm. The 9.6 Value score is the highest on the entire list, and the 9.5 Location score puts you in a walkable small-town setting. Guests love the unique owners and their friendly pets (awesome dogs and a cat!).
What You Actually Get
Breakfast is included and served self-serve style on the main floor, with a bar in the kitchen where you can sit. The outdoor swimming pool is open seasonally. Free on-site parking is available. Pets are allowed with charges that may apply. The property is decorated for Christmas, creating a cozy holiday atmosphere. Note that some rooms—like the king room—may not have a private bathroom; confirm when booking.
Choose this if: You want a unique B&B experience with a pool and the highest value score in our guide.
12. Homestead Lodging
The Vibe
A small holiday home in Smoketown with only 40+ reviews, but an 8.3 is respectable. The 8.8 Wi-Fi score and 8.6 Value score make it a solid pick for those wanting a quieter, more private setup. Guests note the “very clean and roomy” rooms and a “great location.”
What You Actually Get
The property offers free Wi-Fi (8.8), free parking on site, and a private terrace for relaxing. Rates are based on 2 people—extra person charges apply. The property is not suitable for children under 13, making it an adults-only option for those seeking quiet. No breakfast is provided, but complimentary coffee, tea, and cocoa are available. Check-in is from 3:00 PM to 9:00 PM. The location is close to American Music Theatre Lancaster (1.3 miles) and other attractions.
Choose this if: You want a quiet, private holiday home near the American Music Theatre with no children under 13.
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#1 The Carriage House at Strasburg
Top guest scores (9.4 overall, 9.7 staff, 9.7 cleanliness) with walking-distance access to the Railroad Museum of Pennsylvania.
💰 Best Value
#9 Travelers Rest Motel
A 9.3 overall rating with a 9.2 Value score, free excellent breakfast, and 9.7 staff—all at a 2-star price.
🐕 Best Pet-Friendly
#5 Home2 Suites By Hilton Ephrata
Perfect 10.0 Wi-Fi, full kitchens, indoor pool, and a $75 pet fee per stay (not per night) make it the top pet-friendly choice.
How We Ranked These East Earl Hotels
I evaluated 12 properties across the East Earl and greater Amish Country area, analyzing 3700+ verified guest reviews to find only the best. This guide spotlights hotels with strong scores in cleanliness, location, and value—the metrics that matter most for travelers booking hotels in East Earl, PA.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 7.0+ overall and 40+ verified reviews made the cut
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and value—the categories that drive repeat bookings
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns
- Location signals: Distance to key Amish Country attractions like the Railroad Museum, American Music Theatre, and Shady Maple Smorgasbord
Frequently Asked Questions
Are pets allowed at these East Earl hotels?
Yes, some properties are pet-friendly. Home2 Suites By Hilton Ephrata (#5) allows pets with a $75 per-stay fee. Hampton Inn & Suites Intercourse (#10) charges $75 for 1-4 nights and $125 for 5+. Waynebrook Inn (#3) charges a $25 pet fee per stay. VAAST Bed & Breakfast (#11) allows pets with charges that may apply. The remaining eight hotels on this list do not allow pets.
Which hotels offer free cancellation?
Free cancellation policies vary by rate and property across all the hotels in this guide. The Carriage House at Strasburg (#1), Best Western Plus Intercourse Village Inn (#2), and Home2 Suites By Hilton Ephrata (#5) typically offer flexible rates with free cancellation up to 24-48 hours before check-in. Always check the specific rate’s cancellation policy before booking, as some deeply discounted rates may be non-refundable.
What’s the best time to visit East Earl and Amish Country?
May through October is prime season for Amish Country, with mild weather perfect for touring the countryside, visiting farmers’ markets, and attending events at the American Music Theatre Lancaster. Fall (September-October) offers stunning foliage and harvest festivals. Spring (April-May) has fewer crowds but still pleasant temperatures. Winter can be quiet and cold, but some travelers prefer the lower rates and peaceful atmosphere.
How do I get to East Earl from major airports?
Harrisburg International Airport (MDT) is the closest major airport, about 30-35 miles from East Earl. Philadelphia International Airport (PHL) is roughly 47-50 miles away. Baltimore-Washington International (BWI) is about 61 miles from Strasburg. Renting a car is strongly recommended, as Amish Country is spread out and public transportation is limited. Most hotels in this guide offer free on-site parking.
What’s the most walkable area in East Earl for hotels?
Strasburg and Intercourse are the most walkable areas for travelers booking hotels in East Earl, PA. The Carriage House at Strasburg (#1) is within walking distance of the Railroad Museum of Pennsylvania. In Intercourse, Travelers Rest Motel (#9) and Hampton Inn & Suites (#10) are close to local restaurants and shops. For most attractions, however, you’ll want a car to explore the Amish countryside and sites like Shady Maple Smorgasbord.
Can I check in late at any of these properties?
Yes, several properties offer late check-in options. Best Western Plus Intercourse Village Inn (#2) and Waynebrook Inn (#3) accept check-in until 11:30 PM. VAAST Bed & Breakfast (#11) allows check-in until 11:30 PM. Travelers Rest Motel (#9) and Homestead Lodging (#12) have check-in until 9:00 PM. Country Squire Inn and Suites (#6) closes check-in at 8:00 PM. Always call ahead if you expect a late arrival, especially for smaller properties.