The Hotel at Oberlin leads with a 9.2 overall and 9.6 cleanliness score. For consistency, Hyatt Place Cleveland/Westlake/Crocker Park’s 8.9 rating and 9.5 location score make it a strong contender. Both deliver top-tier quality near Elyria.
Elyria’s hotel scene is solid, with options ranging from airport-adjacent convenience to campus-modern properties. Here’s what the scores actually say.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 15 properties and 3000+ total verified guest reviews to compile this list, with an average guest score of 8.2/10 across all selections.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Best overall score: The Hotel at Oberlin→ Rates
- Best for airport access: Aloft by Marriott Cleveland Airport→ Rates
Sonesta Simply Suites Cleveland North Olmsted Airport→ Rates - Pet-friendly pick: Motel 6-Amherst, OH – Cleveland West – Lorain→ Rates
Residence Inn Cleveland Avon→ Rates - Cleanest properties: The Hotel at Oberlin→ Rates
Hyatt Place Cleveland/Westlake/Crocker Park→ Rates - Best for extended stays: Sonesta Simply Suites Cleveland North Olmsted Airport→ Rates
Residence Inn Cleveland Avon→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. The Hotel at Oberlin | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. Hyatt Place Cleveland/Westlake/Crocker Park | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Elyria by IHG | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Residence Inn by Marriott Cleveland Avon | (40+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Aloft by Marriott Cleveland Airport | (30+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Wyndham Avon | (550+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. Homewood Suites by Hilton Cleveland/Sheffield | (100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 8. Hampton Inn & Suites – Elyria | (250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 9. Courtyard by Marriott Cleveland Elyria | (100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 10. Hampton Inn Cleveland-Westlake | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 11. Best Western Elyria | (450+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 12. Sonesta Simply Suites Cleveland North Olmsted Airport | (300+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 13. Ariel Broadway Hotel | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 14. Motel 6-Amherst, OH – Cleveland West – Lorain | (250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 15. South Ridge Inn | (100+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
In-Depth Reviews: Top Hotels in Elyria, Ohio
1. The Hotel at Oberlin
The Vibe
This 3-star property sits right on the Oberlin College campus, and its 9.6 cleanliness score is the highest of any hotel in this roundup. The 9.6 location score matches it, with guests calling the property “super-modern” and highly recommending it for campus visits. Staff score of 9.5 seals the deal.
What You Actually Get
Every room includes a mini fridge, and the lobby has a microwave available for guest use. Complimentary coffee is served in the lobby until 10 AM, and each room also has its own coffee maker with regular and decaf options. The on-site restaurant serves breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner. Pets are allowed on request with charges, and there’s no age restriction for check-in. Free parking and a fitness center round out the amenities. The 8.0 WiFi score is solid but not top-tier here.
Choose this if: You prioritize cleanliness and location — this hotel scores 9.6 in both categories.
2. Hyatt Place Cleveland/Westlake/Crocker Park
The Vibe
This 3-star hotel scores 9.3 for staff, 9.4 for comfort, and 9.2 for both facilities and cleanliness — a remarkably consistent performer. Its 9.5 location score puts it a short drive from Elyria and within walking distance of Crocker Park’s restaurants and shops.
What You Actually Get
Rooms here are sized generously — guests with families of five and a black lab noted the space comfortably fit everyone. The indoor swimming pool is open daily from 6 AM to 10 PM. Pet policy allows dogs under 50 lbs for a one-time $45 fee. The hotel charges a $25-per-day incidental fee on your card. A very good breakfast is included, and the on-site restaurant is convenient for dinner. Free WiFi scores a 9.0, and free parking is on-site.
Choose this if: You want a hotel that scores 9.0+ across staff, cleanliness, comfort, facilities, location, and WiFi.
3. Holiday Inn Express & Suites Elyria by IHG
The Vibe
Sitting at 8.8 overall, this Elyria property matches the Residence Inn in Avon for rating. Staff scores 9.3, cleanliness 9.3, and comfort 9.2 — all top marks. Guests noted the property is “clean, newly remodeled” with “friendly staff” and a breakfast that included shampoo, conditioner, and body wash in the room.
What You Actually Get
The indoor swimming pool is open year-round. Free private parking is available on-site, and there’s room in the rear lot for a truck with a boat. The hotel has one accessible suite with a bathtub — if that matters, book early. Upper floors are accessible by elevator. Pets are not allowed. The 8.5 WiFi score is reliable. Breakfast is included and described as “wonderful” by guests. Check-in starts at 4 PM, later than some competitors.
Choose this if: You value staff friendliness and a clean, newly remodeled room.
Check Tonight’s Price for Sonesta Simply Suites Cleveland North Olmsted Airport →
4. Residence Inn by Marriott Cleveland Avon at The Emerald Event Center
The Vibe
This 3-star property scores 8.8 overall with a 9.2 cleanliness score and 9.1 location rating. Guests rave about the full kitchens — “the full kitchen was very convenient,” one wrote. The outdoor lounge features a fire pit and barbecue facilities, perfect for longer stays.
What You Actually Get
Every room comes with a full kitchen (not just a kitchenette), making this a strong pick for extended stays. The indoor pool is 4 feet deep throughout — good for adults and older kids. Pets are allowed on request with charges, and children 12 and above are charged as adults. Free on-site parking is available, and breakfast is included. There are no EV charging stations on-site, so plan accordingly if you drive electric. Staff scores 8.9, comfort 9.0, and facilities 8.7.
Choose this if: You need a full kitchen for longer stays or family meals.
5. Aloft by Marriott Cleveland Airport
The Vibe
This 4-star property scores 8.7 overall, with a perfect 10.0 WiFi score and 9.3 for cleanliness, comfort, and location. It’s 3.9 miles from Cleveland Hopkins Airport and offers a free shuttle (operating 5 AM to 10 PM). Guests noted the “easy access to coffee in the morning and a bar for a drink at night.”
What You Actually Get
The free airport shuttle runs from 5 AM to 10 PM — if you need an early morning flight before 5 AM, you’ll need alternative transport. Enhanced internet speed is available for Zoom calls. The indoor swimming pool and fitness center are open. Pets are allowed with charges, and there’s no age restriction for check-in. The on-site restaurant serves breakfast. Tax is 17.5% plus a $2.50 daily facility charge, plus a $50 incidental hold. The 4-star rating is the highest star-level in this list, tied with the Wyndham Avon and Ariel Broadway Hotel.
Choose this if: You need reliable airport access and top-tier internet for work calls.
Check Tonight’s Price for Motel 6-Amherst, OH – Cleveland West – Lorain →
6. Wyndham Avon
The Vibe
With 550+ reviews, the Wyndham Avon is the most-reviewed property on this list. It scores 8.6 overall with a 9.3 location rating. Guests said “the online reservation was the easiest to date” and praised the “top rate” lobby, rooms, and beds. It’s 9 miles from Cleveland Hopkins Airport.
What You Actually Get
Only three rooms in the house have Jacuzzis — book those specifically if a hot tub in-room is a priority. The indoor swimming pool and hot tub are available for all guests. The on-site restaurant and bar make dinner easy. Free parking is available, including space for guests who aren’t staying overnight to swim (max 4 people for a King room, 6 for 2 Queen rooms). Good breakfast is included. Pets are not allowed. Guests must be 21 or older to check in. The property charges a $150 deposit.
Choose this if: You want a well-reviewed hotel with a hot tub and indoor pool.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hyatt Place Cleveland/Westlake/Crocker Park →
7. Homewood Suites by Hilton Cleveland/Sheffield
The Vibe
This 3-star property in Sheffield Village scores 8.6 overall with a 9.1 staff rating. Guests praised the breakfast — “above average for the buffet — eggs, sausage, and potato/pepper mix was nice” — and noted the standard waffle maker is available. It’s 10 miles from the airport.
What You Actually Get
The indoor swimming pool is open, and guests can reserve pool time after check-in. Breakfast is included, though the hotel noted simplified breakfast options due to staffing. A $50 damage deposit is required at check-in. Pets are not allowed. Free parking is available on-site. Wi-Fi scores 8.5, and staff scores 9.1. Comfort scores 8.9 and cleanliness 8.8. The location score is 8.8.
Choose this if: Staff interaction quality matters most — this has the second-highest staff score.
Check Tonight’s Price for Holiday Inn Express & Suites Elyria by IHG →
8. Hampton Inn & Suites – Elyria
The Vibe
Guests call this property “newly updated” with “exceptional staff.” The 8.7 cleanliness score matches the 8.7 staff score — a strong pairing. Breakfast was noted as “so much better than the last Hampton we stayed in.” The indoor pool is open year-round. Located on Lorain Boulevard in Elyria.
What You Actually Get
The indoor pool is open year-round (no outdoor pool). Free parking is available. Pets are allowed with charges. Check-in extends until midnight, helpful for late arrivals. The 8.7 staff and cleanliness scores are the highlights here. Location scores 7.7, so it’s a bit off the beaten path — fine for a car traveler. Wi-Fi scores 8.0. Free breakfast is included. The property has a 24-hour front desk.
Choose this if: You want a recently updated Elyria property with an indoor pool.
9. Courtyard by Marriott Cleveland Elyria
The Vibe
This 3-star Marriott property scores 7.9 overall but punches above with an 8.8 staff score — the best score category. Guests said “the rooms are always clean, beds are comfortable, staff is friendly.” The indoor pool and on-site restaurant and bar add value. Located on Travelers Lane in Elyria.
What You Actually Get
Standard rooms have one TV; suites have two. There’s tractor-trailer parking available — a real bonus for truck travelers. The indoor pool is open. Breakfast is optional (€7) or included depending on your rate. Free on-site parking and free WiFi (scoring 7.5) are included. Pets are not allowed. Children 12 and above are charged as adults. The shared lounge and fitness center are available.
Choose this if: You’re driving a large vehicle and need a reliable Elyria property with parking.
10. Hampton Inn Cleveland-Westlake
The Vibe
This 3-star Hampton Inn scores 7.8 overall but earns a 9.0 location score. Guests called it “very quiet and convenient to everything you need.” The location on Detroit Road in Westlake is 4.7 miles from the airport. The staff was noted as “very accommodating,” offering early check-in when available.
What You Actually Get
Every room has a microwave — confirmed by guest Q&A. Free WiFi scores 8.0. The wonderful breakfast is included. Accessible rooms are available on request. Pets are not allowed. Free parking is available on-site. Check-out is at 12:00 PM — later than most competitors. Staff scores 8.6 and comfort scores 8.6. Cleanliness is 8.4. The location is quiet despite being near major roads.
Choose this if: A quiet location near the airport with late check-out matters.
Check Tonight’s Price for Courtyard by Marriott Cleveland Elyria →
11. Best Western Elyria
The Vibe
With 450+ reviews, the Best Western Elyria is one of the most-tested properties on this list. It scores 7.6 overall with an 8.6 staff score. Guests said the “staff made us feel very welcome” and the “breakfast was above average.” Located off I-90, it’s 1 mile from Midway Crossings Shopping Center.
What You Actually Get
The indoor swimming pool and fitness center are available. Free parking is on-site. All rooms are non-smoking — no queen smoking handicap rooms exist. Each room has one-cup coffee makers. A $150 deposit is required at check-in. Good breakfast is included. Pets are not allowed. The 24-hour front desk handles late arrivals. Staff scores 8.6, cleanliness 8.0, and value 8.0.
Choose this if: You want a budget-friendly Elyria option with proven guest feedback.
Check Tonight’s Price for Homewood Suites by Hilton Cleveland/Sheffield →
12. Sonesta Simply Suites Cleveland North Olmsted Airport
The Vibe
This 2-star Sonesta property scores 7.6 overall with 300+ reviews. It’s just 3.9 miles from Cleveland Hopkins Airport — tied with Aloft for closest airport access. Guests loved the “little kitchen with a full-size refrigerator” and ice maker. The 8.6 location score reflects its proximity to Westfield Great Northern Shopping Center.
What You Actually Get
All rooms are suites — studio suites and one-bedroom suites with separate bedrooms. Pet fee is $75 for 1-6 nights, $150 flat for 7+. Private parking is available. The fitness center is open. Check-in starts at 4 PM — later than most. Wi-Fi scores 7.7. Staff scores 8.5. This is a strong choice for extended stays thanks to the kitchen facilities.
Choose this if: You need a pet-friendly suite with a kitchen near CLE airport.
13. Ariel Broadway Hotel
The Vibe
The Ariel Broadway Hotel is a 4-star property on Broadway Avenue in Lorain, scoring 7.5 overall with an 8.6 location score. Rooms include refrigerators and microwaves. The on-site restaurant serves breakfast, brunch, lunch, and dinner. The indoor pool was closed as of spring 2021 — check current status before booking.
What You Actually Get
This is a historic Broadway building — the vibe is more character than cookie-cutter. The fitness center and shared lounge are available. Pets are not allowed. Free WiFi scores 7.5. Staff scores 8.5 and cleanliness 8.3. If you arrive after 3 AM without calling, your room may be rented to someone else — notify the front desk of late arrivals. The 4-star rating is the highest star level in this list.
Choose this if: You want a historic hotel with a restaurant and Lorain location.
14. Motel 6-Amherst, OH – Cleveland West – Lorain
The Vibe
This 3-star Motel 6 in Amherst scores 7.4 overall with 250+ reviews. The standout feature: pets stay free with no extra charges. The outdoor swimming pool is open seasonally. Value scores 8.1 — the highest category. Staff scores 8.4. It’s 19 miles from the airport, making it the farthest from CLE on this list.
What You Actually Get
Free pet stays with no extra charges — this is the only property in this list with zero pet fees. The outdoor pool is open. Check-in starts at 2 PM — the earliest on this list. Free WiFi is available (no score listed for WiFi). Children over 17 are welcome; 18+ are charged as adults. Location score is 8.3. The staff score of 8.4 and value score of 8.1 are the highlights.
Choose this if: You’re traveling with pets and want no extra fees.
Check Tonight’s Price for Residence Inn by Marriott Cleveland Avon at The Emerald Event Center →
15. South Ridge Inn
The Vibe
This 2-star property in North Ridgeville scores 7.0 overall but earns a perfect 10.0 WiFi score — tied with Aloft for best internet in this list. Staff scores 8.8, and the location scores 8.2. It’s 5.6 miles from Westfield Great Northern Shopping Center. Free private parking is available.
What You Actually Get
The perfect WiFi score (10.0) makes this a strong choice for remote work or streaming. Very good breakfast is included. Free private parking is on-site. Pets are allowed with charges. There’s no age restriction for check-in — all ages welcome. Check-in is from 4 PM to midnight. The property doesn’t accommodate bachelor/bachelorette parties. Staff scores 8.8, and value scores 7.4.
Choose this if: You need guaranteed, high-speed internet at a lower price point.
Check Tonight’s Price for Aloft by Marriott Cleveland Airport →
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#1 The Hotel at Oberlin
Highest overall rating (9.2) and top cleanliness (9.6) and location (9.6) scores — unmatched in this roundup.
💰 Best Value
#11 Best Western Elyria
450+ reviews, 8.6 staff score, and an 8.0 value rating — proven consistency at a budget price.
Check Tonight’s Price for Homewood Suites by Hilton Cleveland/Sheffield →
🏖️ Best for Airport Access
#5 Aloft by Marriott Cleveland Airport
3.9 miles from CLE with free shuttle, 10.0 WiFi, and 8.7 overall — unbeatable convenience.
Check Tonight’s Price for Motel 6-Amherst, OH – Cleveland West – Lorain →
How We Ranked These Elyria Hotels
We analyzed 15 properties and 3000+ verified guest reviews, prioritizing properties within 25 miles of Elyria that scored 7.0 or higher. The average guest score across selections was 8.2/10. We weighted guest score breakdowns, facility availability, and review recency to create this ranked list.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 7.0+ overall and 30+ verified reviews
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and staff scores — the categories that drive repeat bookings
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns
- Location signals: Proximity to Elyria city center, I-90 access, and Cleveland Hopkins Airport
Frequently Asked Questions
Are pets allowed at hotels in Elyria, Ohio?
It varies by property. The Hyatt Place Cleveland/Westlake/Crocker Park accepts dogs under 50 lbs for a one-time $45 fee. Aloft by Marriott Cleveland Airport and Residence Inn Cleveland Avon also allow pets with charges. Motel 6 in Amherst lets pets stay free with no extra charges — the best deal for pet owners. South Ridge Inn accepts pets with charges. The Hotel at Oberlin allows pets on request. Properties like Wyndham Avon, Holiday Inn Express Elyria, and both Hampton Inns do not allow pets.
Which Elyria hotels offer free cancellation?
All properties in this list have cancellation policies that vary by room type and booking date. You’ll need to check the specific conditions for each option when booking. Generally, refundable rates are available but cost more than non-refundable rates. The Holiday Inn Express & Suites Elyria by IHG, Hampton Inn & Suites – Elyria, and Courtyard by Marriott Cleveland Elyria typically offer free cancellation windows of 24-48 hours before check-in — confirm at booking.
Which hotels near Elyria have the best indoor pools?
Several properties offer indoor pools. Wyndham Avon has an indoor swimming pool plus a hot tub (only 3 rooms have in-room Jacuzzis). The Holiday Inn Express & Suites Elyria by IHG has a year-round indoor pool. Hyatt Place Cleveland/Westlake/Crocker Park’s indoor pool is open 6 AM to 10 PM daily. Hampton Inn & Suites – Elyria also has an indoor pool open year-round (no outdoor pool). The Ariel Broadway Hotel’s indoor pool was closed as of spring 2021 — confirm current status before booking.
How far is Elyria from Cleveland Hopkins International Airport?
Cleveland Hopkins International Airport (CLE) is about 14 miles from central Elyria. The closest properties to the airport are Aloft by Marriott Cleveland Airport (3.9 miles) and Sonesta Simply Suites Cleveland North Olmsted Airport (3.9 miles) — both offer excellent airport access. Wyndham Avon is 9 miles from CLE, and Homewood Suites in Sheffield Village is 10 miles. The farthest property on this list is Motel 6 in Amherst at 19 miles from the airport.
What’s the best area to stay in near Elyria?
The best area depends on your itinerary. Elyria proper has the Holiday Inn Express & Suites (8.8 rating), Hampton Inn & Suites (8.1), and Courtyard by Marriott (7.9) — all convenient to I-90 and local restaurants. For college visits, The Hotel at Oberlin (9.2 rating) sits on Oberlin College campus. For airport access, North Olmsted properties (Aloft and Sonesta) are closest to CLE. Westlake’s Hyatt Place (8.9) and Hampton Inn Westlake (7.8) offer proximity to Crocker Park shopping and dining.
Which hotels in this list have the best WiFi?
Two properties score a perfect 10.0 for WiFi: Aloft by Marriott Cleveland Airport (8.7 overall) and South Ridge Inn (7.0 overall). The Hyatt Place Cleveland/Westlake/Crocker Park scores 9.0, Wyndham Avon scores 8.5, and Homewood Suites by Hilton Cleveland/Sheffield scores 8.5. The weakest WiFi is at Best Western Elyria (7.1) and Ariel Broadway Hotel (7.5). For remote work or streaming, Aloft or South Ridge Inn are your best bets.