The Artezen Hotel tops our list with a 9.3/10 rating and staff scores reaching 9.7, set in the Financial District’s quieter corners. For a Midtown base with Central Park proximity, the Hilton Club The Central at 5th New York matches a 9.3/10 rating with a location score of 9.8. Both deliver polished stays many visitors skip.
Forget the tourist herds. These hotels in Soho District, New York, and its surrounds trade Times Square chaos for genuine character and local rhythm.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 20 properties across 47,100+ verified guest reviews to build this list, prioritizing an average guest score of 8.9/10 and specific neighborhood walkability.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Best for location: #13 Casablanca Hotel→ Rates
#13 Casablanca Hotel→ Rates - Best for couples: #10 Artezen Hotel→ Rates
- Best for families: #13 Casablanca Hotel→ Rates
#13 Casablanca Hotel→ Rates - Budget-friendly: #1 HI New York City Hostel→ Rates
- Cleanest: #11 Hilton Club The Central at 5th→ Rates
- Highest reviewed: #10 Artezen Hotel→ Rates
#10 Artezen Hotel→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. HI New York City Hostel | (15,900+ Reviews) |
|
| 2. San Carlos Hotel New York | (4,300+ Reviews) |
|
| 3. LUMA Hotel – Times Square | (3,150+ Reviews) |
|
| 4. U.S. Pacific Hotel | (2,400+ Reviews) |
|
| 5. Park Terrace Hotel | (2,350+ Reviews) |
|
| 6. The Nolita Express Hostel | (2,150+ Reviews) |
|
| 7. Hotel Indigo NYC Financial District | (1,950+ Reviews) |
|
| 8. The Chemists Club Hotel | (1,600+ Reviews) |
|
| 9. Hilton Club The Quin New York | (1,450+ Reviews) |
|
| 10. Artezen Hotel | (1,400+ Reviews) |
|
| 11. Hilton Club The Central at 5th | (1,250+ Reviews) |
|
| 12. Mint House 70 Pine by Kasa | (1,250+ Reviews) |
|
| 13. Casablanca Hotel | (1,250+ Reviews) |
|
| 14. The Wallace Hotel | (1,200+ Reviews) |
|
| 15. The Ludlow Hotel | (950+ Reviews) |
|
| 16. NobleDEN Hotel | (900+ Reviews) |
|
| 17. Pestana Park Avenue | (850+ Reviews) |
|
| 18. Bryant Park Hotel | (800+ Reviews) |
|
| 19. The Hotel Chelsea | (800+ Reviews) |
|
| 20. Trump International New York | (750+ Reviews) |
Detailed Reviews: Hotels in Soho District, New York
Let’s break down each property by neighborhood so you can pick the right pocket of the city.
1. HI New York City Hostel
The Vibe
This is the Upper West Side’s backpacker hub. A block from Broadway and a ten-minute walk to Central Park, it pulls solo travelers and student groups who want location without the price tag. Quiet hours from 11 PM to 8 AM mean actual sleep is possible.
What You Actually Get
Coffee shop setup in the lobby, a garden terrace, and a movie lounge keep you occupied between outings. The free Wi-Fi scores 8.9, and staff gets a 9.0 for helpfulness. Heads up: NYC residents can’t stay here, and the property doesn’t accept kids. They charge $1.75 per dryer load—bring quarters. The elevator reaches upper floors, but it’s a basic hostel frame.
Choose this if: you’re a solo budget traveler prioritizing Central Park proximity over room size.
2. San Carlos Hotel New York
The Vibe
A polished Midtown stay where the location score hits 9.7 and guests rave about the beds. The 9.4 comfort score backs that up. This is for travelers who want to be near everything—St. Patrick’s, Rockefeller Center, Fifth Avenue—without the Times Square crush.
What You Actually Get
Each room comes with a kitchenette, which changes the game for quick breakfasts and late-night snacks. The fitness center handles the basics, and there’s a restaurant on-site. Staff scores 9.5. Note the $34.42 daily facility fee plus a $75 security deposit at check-in. Parking is discounted nearby, not on-site. The elevator serves all floors.
Choose this if: Location is your top priority and you want a kitchen for easy meals.
3. LUMA Hotel – Times Square
The Vibe
Right on the edge of Times Square—close enough for the buzz, far enough for sleep. The 9.8 location score is the second-highest in our list. Staff gets a 9.5 and the facilities score 9.1. It’s a smart pick for first-timers who want to be in the thick of it.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi hits 9.1, and the included continental breakfast features pastries, fruit, and hot items. The hotel partners with Blink Fitness for complimentary gym access. No pets allowed, and kids 18+ are charged as adults. Parking is available but pricey. The elevator reaches all floors. Late checkout isn’t guaranteed but ask at the desk.
Choose this if: you’re a first-time visitor prioritizing Times Square walkability.
4. U.S. Pacific Hotel
The Vibe
A bare-bones crash pad on the Bowery. The 7.1 rating reflects minimal facilities and stairs-only access (no elevator). Location scores 8.7, which means you’re close to the action but the room is purely functional. Only guests 12+ allowed.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi is the standout feature here, scoring 9.0. You get air conditioning and free luggage storage until 5 PM on checkout day. But the facilities score of 6.9 and cleanliness at 7.2 tell the real story: this is a no-frills, accessible-by-stairs setup. The 2nd-floor location means hauling bags. No pets. No kids under 12.
Choose this if: budget is everything and you only need a bed and Wi-Fi.
5. Park Terrace Hotel
The Vibe
One of very few Midtown hotels where pets stay free—no extra charges. The location is insane: Bryant Park right outside, NYPL across the street, and a 9.8 location score. Staff scores 9.2. Guests call it “elevated but comfortable” with an attentive front desk team.
What You Actually Get
Rooms feature free 1GB Wi-Fi (8.7 score), and Premier Rooms include a fridge. The fitness center covers workout basics. Private parking is available but must be booked. Some rooms have Juliet balconies—request one. Note the $100/night incidental deposit. Check-in closes at 11:30 PM sharp.
Choose this if: you’re traveling with a pet and want Bryant Park as your backyard.
6. The Nolita Express Hostel
The Vibe
A Bowery hostel with shared bathrooms and a communal kitchen. Location scores 8.8—Bloomingdale’s is 7 minutes away. Cabins are single occupancy only, and fines apply for extra guests. Staff gets 8.4. The 7.0 rating reflects the no-frills setup: it’s a bed, a locker, and a kitchen.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi scores 8.2. The shared kitchen is available for all guests. Luggage stores inside your cabin. Bathrooms are communal—no private options. Check-in runs until midnight. The $250 fine for unauthorized extra guests is strict. No kids allowed. No pets.
Choose this if: you’re a solo backpacker who cooks their own meals.
7. Hotel Indigo NYC Financial District by IHG
The Vibe
Financial District polish with Trinity Church views from higher floors. The 9.0 rating comes from strong scores across the board: staff at 9.3, cleanliness at 9.3, comfort at 9.4. Guests mention the full glass window walls and extremely comfortable king beds.
What You Actually Get
The included breakfast is “wonderful” per guest reviews, with hot options. Free Wi-Fi scores 8.5. The fitness center is solid. Rooms average 388 sq ft for the two-double configuration. A $250 damage deposit is required at check-in. Pets allowed with charges. The elevator serves all floors. National September 11 Memorial is 5 minutes away.
Choose this if: You want a polished FiDi base with a killer breakfast included.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hotel Indigo NYC Financial District by IHG →
8. The Chemists Club Hotel
The Vibe
A historic building turned hotel where guests consistently note how quiet the rooms are—rare for Midtown. Wi-Fi scores 9.4, cleanliness hits 9.4. Staff scores 9.3. The location at 9.6 puts you near Grand Central and Bryant Park without the direct street noise.
What You Actually Get
American breakfast is included. The fitness center is on-site. Off-site parking costs $53-$63 per day. A $35 service fee applies per night plus the $10 Refreshment Fee. No bathtubs in rooms. The elevator serves all floors. The building’s original character means higher ceilings and thicker walls than modern builds.
Choose this if: you need a quiet Midtown base with character and solid Wi-Fi.
9. Hilton Club The Quin New York
The Vibe
Central Park is a literal walk away—164 feet from West 57th. Location scores 9.7, staff gets 9.3, and Wi-Fi hits 9.2. Guests mention the welcoming staff and birthday surprises. It’s a Hilton Club property, so timeshare owners get priority, but regular bookings work fine.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi scores 9.2. Fitness center and restaurant on-site. Parking available. Check-in is at 4 PM, late compared to some. Checkout is 10 AM—early. The elevator serves all floors. No pets allowed. Groups booking more than 9 rooms face different policies. The credit card used for booking must match the guest.
Choose this if: Central Park access is your non-negotiable priority.
10. Artezen Hotel
The Vibe
The highest-rated property on this list, tied at 9.3. Staff scores an incredible 9.7—the best in our entire dataset. Cleanliness hits 9.5, comfort 9.6. The small FiDi boutique runs a tight ship, and guests consistently mention the 6 PM car service and free daily water.
What You Actually Get
The facility fee ($9.95/day plus tax) covers high-speed Wi-Fi (9.4), two Fiji water bottles daily, a welcome snack, gym and yoga access, and free local calls. The $100 security deposit is a one-time hold. The elevator serves all floors. Fulton Street subway station is steps away. No pets allowed. Kids 13+ are charged as adults.
Choose this if: service quality matters more than any other factor.
11. Hilton Club The Central at 5th New York
The Vibe
Another Hilton Club property tied at 9.3 overall. But look at the scores: location 9.8, cleanliness 9.6, comfort 9.6, facilities 9.3, staff 9.4. The Wi-Fi scores 9.1. Grand Central is a block away. This is the cleanest hotel in Midtown on this list.
What You Actually Get
Bathtubs are available in select rooms—request one. Free Wi-Fi is solid at 9.1. The fitness center is on-site. Parking is available. Check-in is 4 PM; checkout at 10 AM is early. A $100 damage deposit is required. No pets allowed. The 48th Street location puts Fifth Avenue shopping within a 2-minute walk.
Choose this if: cleanliness and Fifth Avenue proximity drive your choice.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hilton Club The Central at 5th New York →
12. Mint House 70 Pine by Kasa
The Vibe
A converted historic landmark building with full kitchens in every unit. Staff scores 9.4, facilities at 9.3, cleanliness 9.4. Free pet stays with no extra charges. Guests mention the large rooms and updated interiors. It’s a Mint House by Kasa, so the vibe leans aparthotel.
What You Actually Get
Each unit includes a kitchen with fridge, stovetop, and cookware. Two-bedroom units have washer/dryer; a card-operated laundry room is on the 6th floor. Free Wi-Fi scores 9.3. Parking is available. No cash payments—credit card only, and the card must match the reservation name. The elevator serves upper floors.
Choose this if: you need kitchen facilities and space for a longer stay.
13. Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection
The Vibe
The location score is 9.9—tied for the highest on this list. Staff scores 9.8, the second-best in our dataset. Guests call the rooms “large” with “huge bathrooms.” Rick’s Cafe on the second floor adds a Casablanca-movie charm. It’s a Theater District boutique with genuine warmth.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi scores 9.4. Good breakfast is included. The terrace is a bonus. All rooms are accessible via stairs for those avoiding elevators. Checkout is a generous 12 PM. No pets allowed. The hotel sits on West 43rd Street, steps from Times Square but far enough for quiet. Groups booking 5+ rooms face different policies.
Choose this if: you want Theater District convenience with boutique hospitality.
Check Tonight’s Price for Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection →
14. The Wallace Hotel
The Vibe
A 5-star on the Upper West Side with a comfort score of 9.7—the highest in our entire dataset. Staff at 9.5, cleanliness at 9.6. Guests call the rooms “spacious” and the staff “the most accommodating.” Strawberry Fields is an 11-minute walk. It’s quiet, refined, and feels removed from Midtown chaos.
What You Actually Get
Private parking available—rare for this area. Free Wi-Fi scores 9.4. The fitness center is clean and well-equipped. A bar/lounge is planned but not yet open. Executive suites have fridges. A $100 damage deposit is required. Pets allowed with charges. The elevator serves all floors. Checkout is a generous 12 PM.
Choose this if: comfort and Upper West Side calm are your priorities.
15. The Ludlow Hotel
The Vibe
The Lower East Side’s coolest hotel. Comfort scores 9.5, staff at 9.3. The lounge draws locals and guests alike—it’s a social hub with skyline and bridge views. Guests love the vibe: “a place people came to hang, work, grab a drink.” The Ludlow is less a crash pad and more a scene.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi scores 8.3. The in-room coffee machines are a nice touch. All rooms have safes. ADA rooms have walk-in showers, no bathtubs. A $75/night incidental deposit applies, and refunds can take up to 30 days. Pets allowed on request with charges. The terrace and restaurant add to the appeal.
Choose this if: you want Lower East Side nightlife without leaving the hotel.
16. NobleDEN Hotel
The Vibe
Right on Grand Street in Little Italy, 39 feet from Ferrara Bakery. Staff scores 9.5, location 9.5. Guests call it “a great little hotel” with unbeatable price-to-quality ratio. Comfy beds and cleanliness at 9.4 make it a strong value play in a food-centric neighborhood.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi scores 9.0. The terrace is available for guests. Air conditioning works well. No pets allowed. Kids 9+ are charged as adults. Note there may be noise from 10/09/2026 to 20/09/2026 due to nearby work. The elevator serves all floors. Check-in is standard at 3 PM.
Choose this if: Little Italy food crawls and value matter more than luxury.
17. Pestana Park Avenue
The Vibe
Staff scores 9.7—tied for highest on this list. Location at 9.7 on Park Avenue. A pet-friendly hotel with balconies in select rooms. Guests mention cleanliness (9.3) and comfort (9.3). It’s a Portuguese chain (Pestana) with a CR7 fitness partnership for guests.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi scores 8.5. Balconies available—request one. The terrace and shared lounge are nice extras. Laundry service is available. The facility fee includes free local calls and 10 printed pages per day. Pets allowed with charges. A $50/night security deposit applies, max $400. Kids 3+ welcome. Checkout is 11 AM.
Choose this if: you’re traveling with a pet and want a balcony overlooking Park Ave.
18. Bryant Park Hotel
The Vibe
Tied for highest location score at 9.9. Directly across from Bryant Park. Staff at 9.6, cleanliness at 9.6, comfort at 9.6—nearly perfect across the board. Guests call it “central and quiet” with excellent restaurants and coffee nearby. It’s Midtown’s premier park-front option.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi scores 9.1. The fitness center is solid. Private parking is available. A $200/night incidental authorization is required. Guests under 21 need a parent or guardian. Tea kettles available on request. Connecting rooms are not available, but rooms with two beds exist in limited number. Check-in ends at 11:30 PM.
Choose this if: you want Midtown’s best park-front location with top-tier service.
19. The Hotel Chelsea
The Vibe
The legendary Chelsea Hotel, fully renovated. Comfort at 9.7, staff at 9.6, cleanliness at 9.6, facilities at 9.5, Wi-Fi at 9.6—this is the highest-scoring hotel in our dataset by category depth. Guests say it “manages to keep the history yet update the feel to modern expectations.”
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi scores 9.6—the best on this list. The fitness center is modern. Rooms have either one king or one queen bed; no double beds. Rollaway beds available in Premier rooms for $35/night. Smoking is permitted on balconies. Pets allowed with charges. The elevator serves all floors. History buffs will appreciate the preserved 1880s details.
Choose this if: you want iconic Chelsea history with genuinely modern comfort.
20. Trump International New York
The Vibe
The only 5-star on this list, at Columbus Circle. Location scores 9.7. Staff at 9.2, comfort at 9.3. Guests mention the welcoming staff and spacious rooms. The indoor swimming pool is a rare NYC hotel amenity. Central Park is across the street.
What You Actually Get
Free Wi-Fi scores 8.8. Indoor pool and fitness center. Valet parking only—no self-park. All suites have sofa beds; no double beds are available. Minimum check-in age is 21. A $1,000 cleaning fee applies if smoking in the room. Pet fee is $125 per stay. The restaurant serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Landmark views from higher floors.
Choose this if: luxury, a pool, and Central Park access are non-negotiable.
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#10 Artezen Hotel
9.3/10 rating with staff scoring 9.7 and a $100 flat deposit—FiDi’s quietest, most service-driven boutique.
💰 Best Value
#16 NobleDEN Hotel
9.2/10 rating in Little Italy with comfy beds and a 9.5 location score, at a fraction of Midtown prices.
🏖️ Best for Location
#13 Casablanca Hotel
Location 9.9, staff 9.8, and a 9.2/10 rating—Theater District charm with Rick’s Cafe on-site.
Check Tonight’s Price for Casablanca Hotel by Library Hotel Collection →
How We Ranked These New York Hotels
I evaluated 20 properties across 47,100+ verified guest reviews to surface only the highest-quality hotels in Soho District, New York, and surrounding neighborhoods. Every property meets an 8.0/10 minimum guest score with at least 750 verified reviews.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 8.0+ overall and 10+ verified reviews
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and value—the categories that drive repeat bookings
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns
- Location signals: Proximity to Soho, Nolita, Little Italy, and walkability to subway lines
Frequently Asked Questions
Are pets allowed at these Soho District hotels?
Yes, several properties on this list welcome pets. Park Terrace Hotel (H5) allows pets free with no extra charges. Mint House 70 Pine by Kasa (H12) also permits free pet stays. Hotel Indigo FiDi (H7), Pestana Park Avenue (H17), The Ludlow Hotel (H15), Trump International (H20), and The Hotel Chelsea (H19) allow pets with applicable fees. Always confirm the pet policy at booking.
Which hotels offer free cancellation?
Cancellation policies vary by room type and rate plan across all properties. Most hotels in this list offer flexible or free cancellation on
Can I check in late at any of these properties?
Yes, several properties accommodate late arrivals. U.S. Pacific Hotel (H4) accepts check-in until 11:30 PM. The Nolita Express Hostel (H6) accepts until midnight. Artezen Hotel (H10) and Casablanca Hotel (H13) allow check-in until midnight. The Wallace Hotel (H14) and Pestana Park Avenue (H17) accept until midnight as well. For arrivals after midnight, contact the property directly.
When’s the best time to visit New York City?
Spring (April to June) and fall (September to November) offer the most comfortable weather for walking the city’s neighborhoods. Summer months bring humidity and higher hotel rates, while winter (December to February) offers lower prices but cold temperatures. For the best balance of weather and rates on hotels in Soho District, New York, aim for May or October.
How do I get from JFK to Soho District hotels?
The AirTrain JFK connects to the subway system at Howard Beach or Jamaica Station. From there, take the A, E, or J/Z lines to reach Lower Manhattan and Soho-area hotels. A taxi or rideshare costs approximately $60-$80 flat fare plus tolls and tip. Some hotels like Artezen (H10) offer car service drop-offs within a reasonable radius—ask the front desk.
What’s the most walkable area in this guide?
Midtown properties offer the highest walkability scores—Bryant Park Hotel (H18) and Casablanca Hotel (H13) both have 9.9 location scores, placing you steps from Times Square, Fifth Avenue, and Bryant Park. For a Soho-adjacent walkable base, NobleDEN Hotel (H16) in Little Italy and The Ludlow Hotel (H15) on the Lower East Side put you within a 10-minute walk of Soho’s cobblestone streets and boutiques.