Captains Retreat Apartments and Cottages leads with a 9.6/10 cleanliness score and a 9.6/10 location, just a short drive from Carnegie, PA. For consistent proximity value, Holiday Inn Dandenong by IHG offers a strong 9.4/10 Wi-Fi score and a solid 8.9/10 location. Both deliver well-reviewed stays near your target area.
Look, you’re here for hotels near Carnegie, PA. I’ve ranked 20 properties by what matters: real distances, verified guest scores, and the policies that actually affect your stay.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed 20 properties and over 20,900+ total verified guest reviews to compile this list, which has an average guest score of 8.4/10. Every distance and score listed is pulled directly from the property data.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Cleanest Score: #20 Captains Retreat→ Rates
- Best for Couples: #4 Rydges Ringwood→ Rates
#20 Captains Retreat→ Rates - Budget-Friendly: #9 Maruve Guesthouse→ Rates
#19 Bayside House→ Rates - Pet-Friendly: #18 MainStay Suites Hawthorn→ Rates
- Top Luxury: #1 Hotel Chadstone Melbourne→ Rates
- With a Full Kitchen: #6 Oros Hotel and Apartments→ Rates
#13 Quest Dandenong Central→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Hotel Chadstone Melbourne MGallery Collection | (2000+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. Little Drifter North Melbourne | (1750+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Atura Dandenong | (1600+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Rydges Ringwood | (1550+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. Discovery Parks – Melbourne | (1450+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Oros Hotel and Apartments | (1250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. The Dingley Hotel | (1200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 8. Best Western Plus Buckingham International | (1200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 9. Maruve Guesthouse 12 min from Melb airport | (1200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 10. Holiday Inn Dandenong by IHG | (1050+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 11. The Mansion Melbourne | (900+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 12. Quest Williamstown North | (850+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 13. Quest Dandenong Central | (700+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 14. Hyatt Place Melbourne Caribbean Park | (650+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 15. Beaumaris Bay Motel | (650+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 16. Punthill Williamstown | (550+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 17. Guiding Star Motel & Hotel | (550+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 18. MainStay Suites Hawthorn | (500+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 19. Bayside House | (500+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 20. Captains Retreat Apartments and Cottages | (400+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Carnegie, PA Hotels Reviewed: The Full Distance Breakdown
1. Hotel Chadstone Melbourne MGallery Collection
The Vibe
This 5-star property sits in Melbourne’s fashion capital, Chadstone. With a Location score of 9.4/10 and a Staff rating of 9.3/10, it’s a polished pick for those wanting luxury paired with shopping access near Carnegie, PA. The rooftop bar earns consistent praise from guests.
What You Actually Get
You get an indoor swimming pool, a spa and wellness centre, a restaurant, and room service. The private parking is a plus, though it costs $25.00 per night. Rooms come with individually controlled air-conditioning systems. Note the 1.4% credit card surcharge and the policy that children 12 and above are charged as adults.
Choose this if: You want a 5-star luxury base with a top-tier location score near Carnegie, PA.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hotel Chadstone Melbourne MGallery Collection →
2. Little Drifter North Melbourne
The Vibe
Little Drifter North Melbourne keeps things practical with a 8.6/10 Staff score and a solid 8.6/10 Location rating. It’s a good option if you’re prioritizing a short drive to Carnegie, PA, with the airport only 19 km away. The fitness centre is a bonus for morning workouts.
What You Actually Get
Facilities include a fitness centre, family rooms, a terrace, and a 24-hour front desk. There’s private parking available for $25 per night, though street parking with time restrictions is also an option. Luggage storage is available for early arrivals. A 2% charge applies when paying with credit cards.
Choose this if: You value a high Wi-Fi score (8.9) and need a 24-hour front desk for flexible check-in.
3. Atura Dandenong
The Vibe
Atura Dandenong scores a 9.0/10 on Cleanliness and a 9.0/10 on Comfort, making it a reliable pick for a clean, restful stay. While the drive to Carnegie, PA is a bit longer from here, the on-site amenities—including two restaurants and a fitness centre—make up for it.
What You Actually Get
You get free parking at the front and back of the building, two restaurants, a fitness centre, and room service. There are also billiard tables, a couple of bars (ground level and basement), and a cafe. Note that a 1.50% charge applies when paying with a credit card. Children 12 and above are charged as adults.
Choose this if: You prioritize hotels near Carnegie, PA with excellent cleanliness standards and free parking.
4. Rydges Ringwood
The Vibe
Rydges Ringwood boasts a 9.4/10 Cleanliness score—the best on this list for that metric. Its 9.2/10 Staff score and 9.0/10 Value score round out a very strong profile. It’s a comfortable drive from Carnegie, PA, offering a consistently high-quality stay.
What You Actually Get
You’ll find a fitness centre, private parking, a terrace, and an on-site restaurant. Guests specifically praise the bathroom quality and room layout. A 1.4% credit card surcharge applies. Check-in is guaranteed from 2:00 PM onwards, and early arrivals can register at the desk.
Choose this if: A spotless room is non-negotiable—this has the highest cleanliness score on the list.
5. Discovery Parks – Melbourne
The Vibe
Discovery Parks scores a 9.0/10 Location and is just 13 km from the airport—a shorter drive for getting to Carnegie, PA. It’s a 4-star property with a cabin-like feel, praised for cleanliness and comfort. The outdoor pool is a summer draw.
What You Actually Get
You get an outdoor swimming pool, free parking, and family rooms. The cabins are well-fitted and praised for cleanliness vs. nearby Airbnbs. Guests under 18 must be supervised. Late arrivals after office hours are accommodated via prepared keys and maps if the booking is fully paid.
Choose this if: You’re looking for a cabin-style stay with a pool and a very high location score near Carnegie, PA.
6. Oros Hotel and Apartments
The Vibe
Oros Hotel and Apartments sits in Oakleigh, an 11-minute walk from Chadstone Shopping Mall. With a Kitchen in the units and a solid 8.3/10 Location score, it’s a practical choice for longer stays or self-catering near Carnegie, PA. The 4.5-star rating belies the value here.
What You Actually Get
You get a kitchen, private parking on site, family rooms, and facilities for disabled guests (including accessible bathrooms with roll-in showers and grab rails). Late check-in is available until midnight. Late check-out costs $20 per hour after 11:00 AM, maxing at 2:00 PM. No age restriction for check-in.
Choose this if: You need a kitchen for self-catering and a late check-in window (up to midnight).
7. The Dingley Hotel
The Vibe
The Dingley Hotel earns a stellar 9.3/10 Staff score and a 9.2/10 Cleanliness rating. With many repeat guests, it’s clearly doing something right. The free private parking and outdoor pool make it a comfortable base for exploring the area near Carnegie, PA.
What You Actually Get
You get an outdoor swimming pool (unheated, FYI), free parking, a fitness centre, room service, and a tea/coffee maker in all rooms. The beds are frequently praised. Microwaves are available on request. A credit card pre-authorization is required at booking for incidental charges.
Choose this if: Friendly, helpful staff are your priority—this property’s 9.3 score is top-tier.
8. Best Western Plus Buckingham International
The Vibe
Best Western Plus Buckingham International offers a reliable 8.0/10 overall rating with strong points on Staff (8.8) and Location (8.7). It’s a solid, no-surprises choice for travelers heading to the Carnegie, PA area. The on-site restaurant and pool add convenience.
What You Actually Get
You get an outdoor swimming pool, free parking, a fitness centre, a restaurant, and room service. Parking is ample and not allocated. A 3% charge applies to American Express or Diners Club credit cards. Check-out starts as early as 5:00 AM for early departures.
Choose this if: You need a dependable 4-star with free parking and an early check-out window.
Check Tonight’s Price for Best Western Plus Buckingham International →
9. Maruve Guesthouse 12 min from Melb airport
The Vibe
Maruve Guesthouse is a budget-friendly option just 19 km from the airport. With a solid Value score of 8.4/10 and self check-in available anytime, it’s a practical stop for travelers needing a no-fuss base near Carnegie, PA. The free private parking is a bonus.
What You Actually Get
You get free private parking on site, family rooms, and air conditioning. Check-in is self-service and available at any time, making it ideal for late-night arrivals. Inform the property of your expected arrival time in advance using the Special Requests box. The guesthouse is in Broadmeadows, about 8.8 miles from Melbourne Zoo.
Choose this if: Value and 24/7 self check-in matter more than frills on your way to Carnegie, PA.
Check Tonight’s Price for Maruve Guesthouse 12 min from Melb airport →
10. Holiday Inn Dandenong by IHG
The Vibe
Holiday Inn Dandenong by IHG brings brand reliability with an 8.7/10 Excellent rating. Its Wi-Fi scores a 9.4/10, the staff rate at 9.3/10, and the property is consistently praised for cleanliness (9.2) and comfort (9.1). A strong choice if you’re looking for consistent quality near Carnegie, PA.
What You Actually Get
You get a fitness centre, restaurant, room service, and tea/coffee makers in all rooms. Payment is required at check-in with a valid credit card. IHG One members can get complimentary late checkout until 2 PM. Kids eat for free at the restaurant, adding family value.
Choose this if: You need rock-solid Wi-Fi and brand-standard comfort for your stay near Carnegie, PA.
11. The Mansion Melbourne
The Vibe
The Mansion Melbourne is centrally located with a 9.2/10 Location score and a fantastic 9.3/10 Staff rating. The building itself is beautiful, and the vibe is consistently praised. It’s a great option for those wanting a central stay while exploring near Carnegie, PA.
What You Actually Get
You get a garden, free Wi-Fi, and a shared lounge. Bag drop is available from 9 AM, and luggage storage is free until 9 PM on checkout day. Note that children are not allowed, and no personal sleeping bags are permitted. Events happen Monday to Friday in the bar.
Choose this if: You’re an adult traveler who values a beautiful garden, great staff, and a central location.
12. Quest Williamstown North
The Vibe
Quest Williamstown North offers a 9.4/10 Staff score—the joint highest on this list. The location (9.0) near the lake and wildlife makes it a scenic base. It’s a short drive from Carnegie, PA, with the added bonus of an outdoor pool and spa centre.
What You Actually Get
You get an outdoor swimming pool, spa and wellness centre, free parking, and family rooms. Note that housekeeping service is not included on Sundays or Public Holidays. There is a 1.5% charge for Visa/MasterCard and a 2.5% charge for Amex/Diners Club. No restaurant on-site.
Choose this if: You want a scenic stay with a pool and spa, plus top-tier staff service.
13. Quest Dandenong Central
The Vibe
Quest Dandenong Central is a 4-star aparthotel with strong scores across the board (8.6 overall). It’s pet-friendly on request, which is a big plus for animal owners heading to the Carnegie, PA area. Staff at 8.9 and Cleanliness at 8.9 make it a consistent performer.
What You Actually Get
You get a fitness centre, private parking on site, and family rooms. Standard studio apartments do not have a balcony, but other rooms do. Pets are allowed on request with possible charges. Staff speak English, Dutch, and Thai. Cash is not accepted.
Choose this if: You’re traveling with a pet and need aparthotel-style convenience near Carnegie, PA.
14. Hyatt Place Melbourne Caribbean Park
The Vibe
Hyatt Place Melbourne Caribbean Park earns an 8.8/10 Excellent rating with a stellar 9.3/10 Cleanliness score and 9.1/10 for both Staff and Facilities. The free parking and excellent breakfast make it a strong value proposition for your trip near Carnegie, PA.
What You Actually Get
You get a fitness centre, restaurant, bar, free parking, and family rooms. The front desk is 24/7. Check-in is between 3:00 PM and 10:00 PM, with early check-in available for a fee. Late checkout is offered before you even ask—according to guest reviews. Children 13 and above are charged as adults.
Choose this if: Free parking, excellent breakfast, and high cleanliness standards are your must-haves near Carnegie, PA.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hyatt Place Melbourne Caribbean Park →
15. Beaumaris Bay Motel
The Vibe
Beaumaris Bay Motel scores a 9.4/10 for Staff—tied for the best in this list. Its 9.2/10 Location score and 8.7/10 Value score make it a solid choice. It’s just a 10-minute walk from Beaumaris Beach, adding a coastal element to your stay near Carnegie, PA.
What You Actually Get
You get free private parking on site, a restaurant, room service, and a tea/coffee maker in all rooms. Some rooms have a spa bath. Airport shuttle service is available on request. No age restriction applies for check-in. Children 6 and above are charged as adults.
Choose this if: You want access to a beautiful beach (10-min walk) and exceptional staff at a 3-star price.
16. Punthill Williamstown
The Vibe
Punthill Williamstown sits right on Hobson’s Bay with a 9.3/10 Location score. The modern apartment hotel offers a 9.2/10 Wi-Fi score and a strong 8.6/10 Cleanliness rating. It’s a great choice for couples or solo travelers wanting a scenic bay stay near Carnegie, PA.
What You Actually Get
You get a fitness centre, terrace, private parking, and family rooms. All apartments have a shower over the bath setup, excluding the accessible room. Loaner bikes are available from reception. Smoking is allowed on balconies. A 2% charge applies to Visa, Mastercard, Amex, or Diners Club.
Choose this if: You want a modern apartment by the bay with a terrace and the option to bring a pet (on request).
17. Guiding Star Motel & Hotel
The Vibe
Guiding Star Motel & Hotel is located in Brooklyn, just 16 km from the airport—the closest to the airport after Discovery Parks. With a 9.2/10 Staff score and an 8.8/10 Cleanliness rating, it’s a well-run property. It’s a practical choice for those on a road trip near Carnegie, PA.
What You Actually Get
You get free parking at the hotel, a restaurant, a bar, and a tea/coffee maker in all rooms. Coin laundry is available on site opposite rooms 3 and 4. After-hours check-in is available by contacting the hotel in advance. Check-in runs from 11:30 AM to 7:00 PM.
Choose this if: You need a clean, staff-friendly motel with coin laundry and free parking, close to the airport.
18. MainStay Suites Hawthorn
The Vibe
MainStay Suites Hawthorn boasts a 9.3/10 Location score and a 9.2/10 Staff rating. It’s pet-friendly, well-rated for comfort (8.9), and just 1312 feet from Glenferrie Railway Station. A solid pick for those wanting a self-contained suite near Carnegie, PA.
What You Actually Get
You get a fitness centre, private parking ($25.00 per car, per night), and tea/coffee makers. Only about 5 out of 119 apartments have bath tubs—most have walk-in showers. Credit card surcharges vary: 1.50% for Visa, 2% for MasterCard, 2.30% for others. The apartments face different directions.
Choose this if: You’re bringing a pet and want a self-contained suite in a highly-rated location near Carnegie, PA.
19. Bayside House
The Vibe
Bayside House sits in the St. Kilda district, 1.1 miles from Middle Park Beach. The Wi-Fi scores a 9.4/10, matching the best connection on this list. All bathrooms are shared, so it’s a budget-oriented option for solo or backpacker travelers heading to Carnegie, PA.
What You Actually Get
You get free Wi-Fi and luggage storage. All bathrooms are shared—no private bathrooms. Parking is available on the side street after 6 PM until 11 AM the next day, free of charge. Check-in begins at 2:00 PM. Children are not allowed. The property is well-located in St. Kilda for exploring.
Choose this if: You’re on a tight budget, need excellent Wi-Fi, and are comfortable with shared bathrooms near Carnegie, PA.
20. Captains Retreat Apartments and Cottages
The Vibe
Captains Retreat Apartments and Cottages is the top-rated property on this list with a 9.2/10 Wonderful score. It scores 9.6/10 for Cleanliness, 9.6/10 for Location, and 9.6/10 for Comfort. The sea views and free parking make it a premium pick for a special stay near Carnegie, PA.
What You Actually Get
You get free parking, free Wi-Fi, family rooms, an airport shuttle, and a balcony. Many units have water views. For the “breakfast included” option, guests receive a continental breakfast basket. The property offers rooms, suites, apartments, and cottages—many with private balconies. Children 18 and above are charged as adults.
Choose this if: You want the highest-rated stay near Carnegie, PA, with sea views and exceptional cleanliness.
Check Tonight’s Price for Captains Retreat Apartments and Cottages →
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#20 Captains Retreat Apartments and Cottages
Top-rated at 9.2/10 with perfect 9.6 scores in cleanliness, location, and comfort.
Check Tonight’s Price for Captains Retreat Apartments and Cottages →
💰 Best Value
#4 Rydges Ringwood
An 8.9/10 overall rating with a 9.0/10 Value score, 9.4/10 Cleanliness, and free parking.
✨ Editor’s Choice
#1 Hotel Chadstone Melbourne MGallery Collection
5-star luxury with a 9.4 Location score, indoor pool, and spa. Best for a premium stay.
Check Tonight’s Price for Hotel Chadstone Melbourne MGallery Collection →
How We Ranked These Hotels
We analyzed 20 properties with over 20,900+ verified guest reviews to find the best hotels near Carnegie, PA. Each property was evaluated on its overall rating, guest score breakdowns, and proximity data to ensure the list reflects real-world value.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 8.0+ overall and 10+ verified reviews
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and value — the categories that drive repeat bookings
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns
- Location signals: Proximity to Carnegie, PA and key transport links like nearby airports
Frequently Asked Questions
Which hotels near Carnegie, PA are pet-friendly?
Two properties on our list allow pets on request: Quest Dandenong Central (#13) and MainStay Suites Hawthorn (#18). Quest Dandenong Central permits pets with possible charges, while MainStay Suites Hawthorn is also pet-friendly with potential fees. Always confirm the pet policy directly with the property before booking, as charges may apply.
Which hotels offer free cancellation near Carnegie, PA?
Most properties in our list have cancellation policies that vary by accommodation type. It’s best to check the specific conditions for your chosen hotel during the booking process on the booking platform. For example, Hotel Chadstone Melbourne (#1) and Rydges Ringwood (#4) both state that cancellation and prepayment policies vary. Always review the terms before confirming your reservation.
What’s the best time to visit the area around Carnegie, PA?
The area around Carnegie, PA is a vibrant region. The best time to visit Victoria is typically during the spring (September to November) and autumn (March to May) when temperatures are mild and crowds are smaller. However, the hotels on our list are year-round options, so you can plan your trip based on local events or your personal schedule.
Do any of these hotels feature a full kitchen?
Yes, Oros Hotel and Apartments (#6) includes a kitchen in its units, making it ideal for longer stays or self-catering. Additionally, Quest Dandenong Central (#13) is an aparthotel that offers self-contained accommodations, which often include kitchenette facilities. These properties are great choices if you prefer to prepare your own meals during your stay near Carnegie, PA.
How do I get from Melbourne Airport to these hotels?
Melbourne Airport (MEL) is the main gateway to the area. The distance to our listed properties ranges from 13 km (Discovery Parks – Melbourne) to 48 km (Holiday Inn Dandenong by IHG and Quest Dandenong Central). Taxis and rideshares like Uber are the most direct options, with Maruve Guesthouse (#9) noting an Uber cost of approximately $25–30 to the property from the airport.
Which properties have the highest cleanliness scores?
Captains Retreat Apartments and Cottages (#20) leads with a perfect 9.6/10 Cleanliness score. Rydges Ringwood (#4) follows closely at 9.4/10, and Hyatt Place Melbourne Caribbean Park (#14) scores 9.3/10. These three properties are your best bet for a spotless room during your stay near Carnegie, PA.