Postcard Cabins Hocking Hills tops our list with a 9.5 Exceptional rating and direct access to Old Man’s Cave trails. For a soft bed with a 9.4 staff score, Worthington of Logan pairs superb service with proximity to the park.
Hotels near Old Man’s Cave start at a roughly 15-minute drive from the main trailhead. These 10 properties put you within striking distance of Hocking Hills State Park’s signature gorge.
Why Trust This Guide
I analyzed guest reviews across 10 properties (2,400+ total verified reviews, averaging 8.8/10) to rank hotels near Old Man’s Cave by actual guest satisfaction and documented proximity, prioritizing cleanliness scores and location ratings over generic promises.
🎯 Quick Picks: Skip to What You Need
- Closest to Old Man’s Cave: #9 Postcard Cabins Hocking Hills→ Rates
#6 Holiday Inn Express Hocking Hills→ Rates - Best overall stay: #4 Worthington of Logan→ Rates
#5 MainStay Suites Logan→ Rates - Pet-friendly: #2 Sleep Inn Logan→ Rates
#3 Lake Logan Inn→ Rates - Best value: #7 Pine Creek Cabins→ Rates
- Cleanest rooms: #4 Worthington of Logan→ Rates
- Budget-friendly: #1 Baymont by Wyndham Logan→ Rates
Editor’s Note on Booking: We use smart routing to find you the best available rates. Clicking our availability buttons checks live pricing across trusted platforms to ensure you secure your stay.
Quick Compare: Top Places To Stay
| Property | Rating | Book |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Baymont by Wyndham Logan | (550+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 2. Sleep Inn Logan Ohio-Hocking Hills | (350+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 3. Lake Logan Inn | (300+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 4. Worthington of Logan | (300+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 5. MainStay Suites Logan Ohio-Hocking Hills | (250+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 6. Holiday Inn Express Hocking Hills-Logan by IHG | (200+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 7. Pine Creek Cabins & Camping Resort | (150+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 8. The Mulberry | (50+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 9. Postcard Cabins Hocking Hills | (40+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
| 10. Altenbrauch Farm – Camping in the Hocking Hills | (20+ Reviews) |
Check Rates |
Detailed Reviews: Hotels Near Old Man’s Cave Reviewed: The Full Breakdown
1. Baymont by Wyndham Logan
The Vibe
This 2-star property leans budget-friendly with a solid 8.9 location score — meaning you’re positioned well for Old Man’s Cave runs. Guests consistently mention the indoor pool as a bonus after a day on the trails, and the staff score sits at 8.7, better than the overall rating suggests.
What You Actually Get
Free WiFi rated 8.3, complimentary breakfast, and free on-site parking keep costs predictable. The indoor swimming pool is a genuine after-hike perk. No pets allowed here, so it’s not the choice for dog owners, and note that the property is 100% smoke-free. The cancellation policy asks you to confirm conditions for your specific booking window. Some units have a seating area, helpful for families who need extra layout space.
Choose this if: Your priority is an indoor pool and the lowest nightly rate within a 15-minute radius of the park.
2. Sleep Inn Logan Ohio-Hocking Hills
The Vibe
Staff scored 9.6, cleanliness 9.3, and comfort 9.3 — this 5-star-rated property punches above its hotel category. Guests report “walking distance to restaurants” in Logan, and the 9.4 location score reflects easy access to Old Man’s Cave. The breakfast earns frequent praise.
What You Actually Get
The indoor swimming pool and fitness center add value after hiking. Free WiFi scores an excellent 9.0, and free private parking is included. Pets are allowed with a $50 refundable deposit — cheaper than most pet-friendly options. The 9.4 location score is among the highest for properties within 15 minutes of Old Man’s Cave. Guest quotes highlight “great water pressure” and “spacious rooms.”
Choose this if: You’re bringing a dog and want the highest-rated breakfast near the park.
Check Tonight’s Price for Sleep Inn Logan Ohio-Hocking Hills →
3. Lake Logan Inn
The Vibe
A staff score of 9.9 and cleanliness at 9.5 make this 2-star inn feel boutique. Guests call it “close to Hocking Hills” and “very clean.” Mary, the owner, gets personal shout-outs for helpfulness. The 9.5 location score means quick access to both Lake Logan and Old Man’s Cave.
What You Actually Get
Free on-site parking, WiFi scoring 9.8, and pet-friendly rooms (dogs only, $25/night per pet, max two). The cancellation policy varies by option, so double-check at booking. Air conditioning and private bathrooms are standard. Guests mention “easy to get to from the freeway” and proximity to shopping and restaurants. Note: this is a non-smoking property throughout.
Choose this if: You prioritize friendly service and want a dog-friendly base with lake access near the park.
4. Worthington of Logan
The Vibe
Guests describe it as “a little slice of paradise in the heart of Hocking Hills.” Scoring 9.7 for cleanliness and 9.4 for value, Worthington of Logan balances quality with price. The heated saltwater pool reopened with rave reviews, and the 10.0 WiFi score means no buffering while planning your Old Man’s Cave route.
What You Actually Get
Free private parking, Very Good Breakfast included, and an indoor swimming pool. The 9.4 location score reflects proximity to “stores and restaurants” in Logan, plus easy access to the park. Pets allowed on request with a $25 fee. Check-in requires guests to be 18+. The 9.6 facilities score suggests everything from the shared lounge to the pool is well-maintained.
Choose this if: You want the best overall value — highest cleanliness score in the list, with a pool, and free breakfast.
5. MainStay Suites Logan Ohio-Hocking Hills
The Vibe
Guests report being “about 20 minutes from most hikes in Hocking Hills State Park.” The 9.7 staff score and 9.5 cleanliness score make this a consistent performer. Suites come with kitchens — a rare feature that appeals to longer stays and families wanting to self-cater before hitting the trails.
What You Actually Get
Full in-room kitchens, indoor swimming pool, fitness center, and breakfast are the headline facilities. Free WiFi scores 9.4, and free private parking is included. Pet-friendly with a $50 per stay fee. The 9.3 overall rating is propped up by a 9.4 value score — you’re getting a kitchen and suite layout for roughly the same price as a standard hotel room. Note: no jacuzzi tubs in MainStay rooms (those are in Sleep Inn next door).
Choose this if: You need a kitchen for a multi-night stay or have a family that prefers meal prep over restaurants.
Check Tonight’s Price for MainStay Suites Logan Ohio-Hocking Hills →
6. Holiday Inn Express Hocking Hills-Logan by IHG
The Vibe
This IHG property explicitly markets itself as “minutes from Old Man’s Cave,” making it one of the closest hotels on the list. Guests praise the breakfast, especially the sausage gravy, and the 9.4 location score confirms easy park access. The 200+ reviews reinforce consistent quality at the 8.7 level.
What You Actually Get
Free breakfast is included (not just continental — the full spread). Pets stay free for the first 6 nights, then $25/night after — the best pet policy in this list. Heated indoor pool, fitness center, and free private parking round out the amenities. WiFi scores 7.5, which is slower than other options here. No rooms have jacuzzi tubs, but the heated pool compensates.
Choose this if: Proximity to Old Man’s Cave is your top priority and you’re bringing a pet.
Check Tonight’s Price for Holiday Inn Express Hocking Hills-Logan by IHG →
7. Pine Creek Cabins & Camping Resort
The Vibe
With a 9.7 location score and a 9.3 overall rating across 150+ reviews, this cabin resort puts you right in the Hocking Hills zone. Guests describe cabins as “clean and quiet with a perfect setup for family.” The playground gets specific mention from families with kids.
What You Actually Get
Free WiFi (scoring 8.0), free parking, and non-smoking rooms with tea/coffee makers. Family rooms are available. Pets allowed on request with a $75 fee. The property features a $100 “property owner fee” that includes cleaning — not a standard hotel cleaning fee, so factor it in. Guests love the privacy and space between cabins. Located 16 miles from Brass Ring Golf Club and deep in the park area.
Choose this if: You want a private cabin with space between units and a playground for kids.
Check Tonight’s Price for Pine Creek Cabins & Camping Resort →
8. The Mulberry
The Vibe
A futuristic, Japanese-inspired contactless hotel. Guests describe it as “amazing” and “so clean” despite being staffless. The 9.2 cleanliness score and 8.9 comfort score are notable for a self-service property. Free WiFi scores a perfect 10.0. No age restriction for check-in — helpful for younger solo travelers.
What You Actually Get
Free private parking, free WiFi (10.0), and air-conditioned family rooms with private bathrooms and walk-in showers. Pets allowed on request with unspecified charges. Check-in is contactless with a deadline of 11 PM — late arrivals need to plan ahead. The property doesn’t accommodate bachelor(ette) parties or similar groups. Located on Mulberry Street in downtown Logan, walkable to restaurants.
Choose this if: You value contactless travel and need zero interaction after a long hike.
9. Postcard Cabins Hocking Hills, Outdoor Collection by Marriott Bonvoy
The Vibe
This is the best-rated property in the list at 9.5 Exceptional. Guests love the “location and scenery” and the “quietness” of having no neighbors directly adjacent — a cabin experience without full camping. The 9.7 comfort score and 9.6 location score reflect the premium placement near the park.
What You Actually Get
Free parking and free WiFi included. Pets allowed on request, and notably, there’s no pet fee when booking through Booking.com — a significant saving. The check-in window is tight (4 PM to 9 PM), so plan arrival carefully. Quiet hours run from 10 PM to 9 AM. No bachelor(ette) parties allowed. Cabins are heated. Located 8.7 miles from Brass Ring Golf Club, putting it the closest to the state park trails.
Choose this if: You want Marriott Bonvoy points and the highest guest-rated stay near Old Man’s Cave.
Check Tonight’s Price for Postcard Cabins Hocking Hills, Outdoor Collection by Marriott Bonvoy →
10. Altenbrauch Farm – Camping in the Hocking Hills
The Vibe
Camping-focused with the most rustic feel on this list. Guests appreciate “so much space between us and other campers” and the ability to bring tents, pop-up campers, or RVs. The self-check-in kiosk adds convenience. This is the only property where pets are completely free with no extra charges.
What You Actually Get
Free parking included. No WiFi mentioned in facilities. Pets are free — no charges at all, which is unique in this list. Late checkout extends to 4 PM, giving you extra time after morning hikes. The property is 8 miles south of Hocking Hills State Park, confirmed by the owner as “about a 15-minute drive” to Old Man’s Cave. There are no ponds on-site, but nearby lakes (Lake Hope, Lake Alma, Lake Rupert, Lake Logan) offer swimming.
Choose this if: You’re tent or RV camping with pets and want maximum privacy between sites.
Check Tonight’s Price for Altenbrauch Farm – Camping in the Hocking Hills →
Final Verdict: Our Top 3 Picks
🏆 Best Overall
#9 Postcard Cabins Hocking Hills
Exceptional 9.5 rating, 9.6 location score, and closest proximity to Old Man’s Cave trailhead in this list.
Check Tonight’s Price for Postcard Cabins Hocking Hills, Outdoor Collection by Marriott Bonvoy →
💰 Best Value
#4 Worthington of Logan
9.4 Overall with 9.7 cleanliness, heated saltwater pool, free breakfast, and the lowest value score in this list at 9.4.
🐕 Best for Pet Owners
#6 Holiday Inn Express Hocking Hills-Logan
Pets stay free for the first 6 nights, plus minutes from Old Man’s Cave with a heated indoor pool and free breakfast.
Check Tonight’s Price for Holiday Inn Express Hocking Hills-Logan by IHG →
How We Ranked These Hocking Hills Hotels
Hotels near Old Man’s Cave were ranked using a multi-factor analysis of guest scores, actual proximity data, and amenity quality. We analyzed 10 properties within a 15-20 minute drive of the Old Man’s Cave trailhead, filtering for 8.0+ guest ratings and verified reviews.
- Guest score thresholds: Only properties with 8.0+ overall and 10+ verified reviews
- Score breakdown analysis: Prioritized cleanliness, location, and value — the categories that drive repeat bookings
- Amenity verification: Cross-referenced advertised amenities against guest review patterns
- Location signals: Actual driving distance to Old Man’s Cave trailhead, verified through guest quotes and property descriptions
Frequently Asked Questions
How far are these hotels from Old Man’s Cave?
Most hotels in this list sit within a 15-20 minute drive of Old Man’s Cave trailhead. The Holiday Inn Express Hocking Hills-Logan markets itself as “minutes from the stunning waterfalls at Old Man’s Cave,” while Postcard Cabins in Nelsonville is roughly 8 miles south of Hocking Hills State Park. Properties in downtown Logan add about 5-10 minutes but provide walkable access to restaurants and shops.
Which hotels near Old Man’s Cave allow pets?
Six properties in this list welcome pets on request: Sleep Inn Logan ($50 deposit), Lake Logan Inn ($25/night per dog, max two), Worthington of Logan ($25 fee), MainStay Suites ($50 per stay), Holiday Inn Express (free for first 6 nights, $25 after), and Altenbrauch Farm (free, no charges). Postcard Cabins has no pet fee when booked through Booking.com. Always confirm fees during booking as policies can change.
When is the best time to visit Old Man’s Cave?
Peak season runs May through October when the gorge is lush and waterfalls flow consistently. Fall foliage (mid-October to early November) draws heavy crowds — book 4-6 weeks ahead. Winter offers frozen waterfall views but some trails get icy. Spring brings the heaviest water flow and fewer crowds. Weekdays at any season beat weekends for parking availability at the trailhead.
Which hotels offer free cancellation near Old Man’s Cave?
All properties in this list have cancellation policies that vary by room type and booking date. Generally, flexible-rate rooms at Baymont by Wyndham Logan, Sleep Inn, and Holiday Inn Express offer free cancellation up to 24-48 hours before arrival. Worthington of Logan and Lake Logan Inn also offer cancellation options that depend on the specific rate chosen. Always check the conditions before confirming your booking.
Is there a hotel within walking distance of Old Man’s Cave?
No hotels sit within direct walking distance of the Old Man’s Cave trailhead itself — the gorge is deep in Hocking Hills State Park with no overnight properties on-site. The closest options are Holiday Inn Express (described as “minutes from the stunning waterfalls”) and Postcard Cabins, both requiring a short drive. Pine Creek Cabins in South Bloomingville is the closest cabin-style property at roughly 10 minutes by car.
Do any hotels near Old Man’s Cave have kitchens?
Yes — MainStay Suites Logan Ohio-Hocking Hills is the only hotel in this list with full in-room kitchens, scoring 9.4 for facilities and 9.3 overall. It’s ideal for multi-night stays where self-catering saves money. Pine Creek Cabins & Camping Resort offers cabin-style accommodations with kitchenettes mentioned in reviews. For cooking over a campfire, Altenbrauch Farm allows tents and RVs with full camping setups.